(Spoiler Alert)
Courtrooms in Indian mainstream cinema are akin to theatre. There are artists and an audience, rendition of the hyperbole and abandonment of objectivity. The actors belt out long dialogue, while the camera impassively records the faces and the proceedings.
The courtrooms in director Dijo Jose Antony ’s films – Queen (2018) and the latest, Jana Gana Mana – are loud and explosive, headlined by a lawyer, the superhero in a black coat, who is immune to character development. He lashes out at everyone in the room and the audience, occupying a moral ground so high that one would need a telescope to sight them from the earth. In Queen , Salim Kumar played an angry lawyer who turned the entire latter half of the film into a tirade. In Jana Gana Mana , Prithviraj trembles in rage and terrorises the courtroom. The film, centred on the death of a college professor Saba ( Mamta Mohandas ), argues against media trials in high-profile cases. It asks the viewers to not succumb to sentimentalism but look for what lies beyond the obvious. Ironically, Jana Gana Mana uses the same language of hyperbole it warns the audience against.
The film unfolds in the fictional town of Ramnagara in Karnataka, in a central university that eerily resembles Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU). The scenes of student protest and subsequent police violence on the campus take cues from the press reports on the incidents that unfolded in JNU in January 2020.
Subtlety, clearly, is not Dijo’s strength. The narrative teems with expository dialogue and scenes. In an early scene set on the college campus, at Saba’s memorial service, the chairman of the university takes the podium and delivers an offensive speech, blaming Saba for stepping out at night and terming the student protests in connection to her death part of a larger anti-national movement. Not just him but all the villains in Jana Gana Mana proclaim their villainy and reveal their carefully chalked out plans in casual phone calls or on public platforms. The film’s audacity to speak up against India’s dangerous right-wing nationalism and the ingrained misogyny of Indian society is rare and praiseworthy. But Dijo’s assumption that the evil likes to flaunt itself is a fatal error.
Similar absurdities, contradictions and empty rhetoric are plenty in Jana Gana Mana . The background score ( Jakes Bejoy ) is relentless, loud and too passionate, a sonic equivalent of the film’s characters. The student leaders, played by Vincy Mathew and Dhruv, are simplified into wannabe revolutionaries whose courage is marked by their angry rants and valiant screams. In the final part of the film, the students and the audience at the court, who had been passionately listening to the lawyer’s arguments against mob justice, fling themselves into yet another act of mob violence, vandalising police vehicles and baying for the blood of the cops. The lawyer, whose superpower is his self-righteousness, berates the honourable judge and the witnesses for their hypocrisy and prejudice against people who come from a certain socio-economic background. Yet, Saba, who holds the film’s emotional narrative together, is always framed like a cliched angel, the camera highlighting Mamta’s glowing face, impeccable smile and upper-class demeanour. There are more victims in the film, who resemble people like you and me, but they get nothing more than a story lazily lifted from newspaper headlines.
Dijo finds a great lead character in assistant commissioner Sajan Kumar, played by Suraj Venjaramoodu , but he gropes in the darkness about structuring a character arc for him. Great films conceal clues to create delicious plot twists, mediocre films put up charades. The viewer should feel betrayed by the big reveal in the climactic scene as the film had, until then, given them the feeling that they were privy to Sajan’s subjective point of view of the events. The hurried negation of this impression is the film’s weakest link.
Dijo crams several issues into the narrative. But he makes a daring move by pointing out the ingrained social biases in the media reporting of sexual harassment cases in a country that likes to consecrate its young rape-murder victims. By far, the best element of the film is Suraj’s portrayal of Sajan. His grey shades come through very well in his introduction scene when he negotiates with a group of protesting students and gains entry to the college campus. “They are just students, not an army of Taliban,” he remarks to his subordinate and walks to the student leaders, quickly concealing his contempt and switching to a position of empathy. In the end, the film is taken over by Prithviraj’s thundering speeches, but Suraj’s subtle mannerisms and careful body language stay memorable. The actor effortlessly turns Sajan into someone who deserves your pity and wrath.
This Jana Gana Mana review is a Silverscreen original article. It was not paid for or commissioned by anyone associated with the movie. Silverscreen.in and its writers do not have any commercial relationship with movies that are reviewed on the site.
Jana Gana Mana is undistinctive, notwithstanding its brave throwaway lines and moments that made my liberal heart sit up and take notice.
Language: Malayalam
The spotlight falls on the superstar of the new Malayalam film, Jana Gana Mana , only in the second half of the narrative. Once the camera rests on Prithviraj Sukumaran’s character though, it rarely moves away from him as he belts out speech after speech…after speech…after speech…steeped in powerful messaging that, despite the loudness and melodrama of those scenes, is largely well reasoned.
A film has to be more than the message/s it wishes to drive home though. And messages are conveyed by more than just speeches. Neither point appears to have struck director Dijo Jose Antony or writer Sharis Mohammed.
The tension pervading Jana Gana Mana is sparked by news of the rape and death of a popular college lecturer called Sabha Maryam (Mamta Mohandas). What follows is an apathetic response from her institution, student unrest, nationwide outrage, sensationalised media coverage and finally, a police encounter that sparks hysterical approval from the masses and celebrities. Sounds familiar?
The case of a doctor in Hyderabad who was raped and murdered after which the accused were killed by the police when they allegedly tried to escape is still fresh in public memory.
Jana Gana Mana draws on this and multiple other news developments and newsmakers from real life throughout the script in big and small ways. For instance, a point is made fleetingly about prejudice against Muslim women who cover their heads, a public figure says a person can be gauged by their attire while another cites outward appearance as his barometer, and a Machiavellian politician declares that he is willing to ban notes and even votes to retain power. All these are fitted into a script that ends up being primarily about caste oppression.
No doubt in the present Indian political scenario it could be argued that each of these elements is an act of courage and, therefore, laudable. Fair enough. But courage alone is not cinema, especially when these disparate components are not woven together into a cohesive whole.
Most characters in the film barring one - a policeman played by Suraj Venjaramoodu - are sketchily drawn and even his graph is unconvincing, the director relies too heavily on Prithviraj’s larger-than-life persona to sustain Jana Gana Mana post-interval, the script feels too crowded, and the narrative jumps from one point to the next to the next instead of flowing smoothly.
The bad writing extends to poorly constructed scenes and awkward dialogues, made worse by strained acting from several actors, in addition to unrelenting music.
The overall effect of the film is its high volume, not just in a literal sense but also in terms of its tendency to underline every point raised, through the use of its soundtrack and studied camerawork. An overly long epilogue announces a sequel to Jana Gana Mana , adding to the film’s already exhausting length.
The tacky direction and writing are combined with confused politics. Jana Gana Mana ’s title is drawn from India’s national anthem and alludes to the minds and will of the people, yet the film dithers in its position on mob justice. A college lecturer speaking to his class about their duty to fight the good fight appears to trivialise the Kiss of Love campaign started in Kerala to oppose self-appointed moral police. The incident that looms over the entire proceedings in Jana Gana Mana is a woman’s rape yet at the forefront of the script are two men - ACP Sajjan Kumar (Suraj) and advocate Aravind Swaminathan (Prithviraj). The woman herself, Sabha, is written as a rough outline of a kind soul committed to social welfare, and nothing beyond that. Caste bias, discrimination and atrocities are Jana Gana Mana ’s main concerns, yet the reins of the battle are not handed to the marginalised community in question.
The saviour complex should not come as a surprise for anyone who has seen the director’s film Queen with its deeply problematic treatment of rape; nor should the tackiness. In fact, in both respects, Jana Gana Mana is a vast improvement on Queen.
Prithviraj and Suraj teamed up not too long back in Lal Jr’s smartly written and crisply directed Driving Licence (2019). That film was an excellent addition to the Malayalam New New Wave from which has emerged some of the best Indian cinema of the past decade. Jana Gana Mana is undistinctive, notwithstanding its brave throwaway lines and moments that made my liberal heart sit up and take notice.
Despite the film’s limitations, Suraj manages to turn out a warm performance that rises above the failings of the script. Prithviraj’s charisma makes it hard to ever dislike him on screen, but it is just as hard not to wonder why a star who has directors and writers lining up at his door chose to back this film that lacks cohesion, clarity, depth, finesse and calm.
This review was first published in April 2022 when Jana Gana Mana was released in theatres. The film is now streaming on Netflix.
Rating: 2 (out of 5 stars)
Anna MM Vetticad is an award-winning journalist and author of The Adventures of an Intrepid Film Critic. She specialises in the intersection of cinema with feminist and other socio-political concerns. Twitter: @annavetticad, Instagram: @annammvetticad, Facebook: AnnaMMVetticadOfficial
Read all the Latest News _,_ Trending News _,_ Cricket News _,_ Bollywood News _,_ India News and Entertainment News here. Follow us on Facebook _,_ Twitter and Instagram _._
Find us on YouTube
Cast: Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Mamta Mohandas, Sri Divya
Director: Dijo Jose Antony
Call it an overtly meta reading of what's essentially a simple scene, but there's something about the timing of Jana Gana Mana 's release that made this stretch feel a lot more significant. With Sathyan Anthikad 's Makal set to release a day later, we get a scene where Jana Gana Mana 's director Dijo Jose Antony appears as a college professor. It is set in Maharajas College and the lecture is on Indian Polity with a full strength of students in attendance. But his speech does not compliment the "good students" for attending his class. Instead, his big mass dialogue here forces them to get up from their benches and go out in protest against the murder of a professor in another state. He calls it the "practicals" of the subject he's teaching, but it feels like an event in itself with a filmmaker teaching his audience to be more political. When seen just a day before the release of an Anthikad film, it's a sign of how most makers today have rejected the apolitical stands of films like Sandesham and Priyadarshan's Cheppu to embrace full student participation. Given how the film comes back later to underscore this very point only adds to the film's cleverly deceptive writing.
Deceptive is the word one needs to keep coming back to because Jana Gana Mana plays this game even before the movie begins. The anti-smoking disclaimer, read out by Suraj Venjaramoodu, too is in sync with this vision. Like two sides to a coin, the film first gets you to buy into yet another argument on the benefits of encounter killing. A case is created and clues are carefully placed right through the first half to get us to align with one side of a debate, only for the carpet to be pulled from right under our feet. Like members of a jury, we're asked to take stands but the stand we end up taking only reveals our own biases. So when we're first shown a set of criminals getting captured from what looks like a colony, the deceptive writing gets us to point the finger right back at ourselves for assuming they've surely done the crime.
Such themes are explored right through the second half with several notions getting dismantled to reveal a lot about ourselves. Surprisingly, the film is fully able to hold its cards close to its chest because of its casting. What actors like Suraj and Prithviraj (the duo repeat their excellent equation from Driving License ) have managed to do is keep their screen image wide enough to be able to accommodate any shade, which only makes the film even more engaging. All of these factors contribute a lot to what's also a film that uses several real-life events to make its political points.
It's also the engaging writing, which transforms into a courtroom drama, that separates Jana Mana Gana from a film like Varthamanam . Apart from basic similarities like its college setting and students' politics, the latter felt very verbose in its attempts to counter fascism using incidents from real life. Jana Gana Mana runs the risk of becoming talkative too, but the courtroom setting gives it the context it needs to allow for this. It is also much smarter in the way it incorporates events from life. We feel this in the eery way a series of events unfurl, leading to the murder of the aforementioned teacher. It takes points from the murder of the veterinary doctor in Hyderabad to give us a context and that chilling feeling we remember from the way the accused were encountered.
The manner in which the life of a PhD student is introduced too reminds us of many faces (including Rohit Vemula's), but this is done seamlessly without any injustice to the characters in the film. These scenes present us with interesting insights into how an argument steeped in real events can help you make the larger political points without comprising on the engagement. It's like a well-written editorial in The Hindu being brought to life for a Tik-Tok audience.
In fact, the only portion that didn't do justice to the film's tight screenplay is the way it ends with a teaser of the second part. This stretched out portion is both difficult to follow with odd editing choices to reveal too much of a film that's not as interesting as the first part we've just finished watching. In what appears to only be a template revenge story, one wishes that Jana Gana Mana had just ended with a tease of a sequel. Yet as a lone standing film, Jana Gana Mana is a thoroughly engaging call to action against fascism told in the most entertaining manner.
0 /5 Filmibeat
Jana gana mana cast & crew.
Director | |
Cinematography | |
Editor | |
Music | |
Producer | |
Budget | TBA |
Box Office | TBA |
OTT Platform | TBA |
OTT Release Date | TBA |
In this Jana Gana Mana film, Prithviraj Sukumaran , Suraj Venjaramoodu played the primary leads.
The Jana Gana Mana was released in theaters on 28 Apr 2022.
The Jana Gana Mana was directed by Dijo Jose Antony
Movies like Hunt , Thaanara , Secret and others in a similar vein had the same genre but quite different stories.
The soundtracks and background music were composed by Jakes Bejoy for the movie Jana Gana Mana.
The cinematography for Jana Gana Mana was shot by Sudeep Elamon .
The movie Jana Gana Mana belonged to the Action,Thriller, genre.
Disclaimer: The materials, such as posters, backdrops, and profile pictures, are intended to represent the associated movies and TV shows under fair use guidelines for informational purposes only. We gather information from social media, specifically Twitter. We strive to use only official materials provided publicly by the copyright holders.
Eda Mone! Happy Allae?
RMM is everything about the Kerala entertainment industry. One of the most active Indian film clubs on Reddit.
By continuing, you agree to our User Agreement and acknowledge that you understand the Privacy Policy .
You’ve set up two-factor authentication for this account.
Create your username and password.
Reddit is anonymous, so your username is what you’ll go by here. Choose wisely—because once you get a name, you can’t change it.
Enter your email address or username and we’ll send you a link to reset your password
An email with a link to reset your password was sent to the email address associated with your account
To enjoy additional benefits
CONNECT WITH US
After a not-so-great debut in ‘queen,’ filmmaker dijo jose antony widens the scale of his ambition in his sophomore effort.
April 28, 2022 04:54 pm | Updated April 29, 2022 01:41 pm IST
A still from ‘Jana Gana Mana’
To make people question some of their deeply-rooted biases, no amount of speeches or hurling of facts and proofs at them can pay off at times. A better way to go about it might be to first appeal to their biases, and slowly start chipping it away from within. Filmmaker Dijo Jose Antony and screenwriter Sharis Mohammed go by this maxim in the film Jana Gana Mana.
In quite an interesting set-up, at the interval point, they get the audience to cheer for encounter killings — which is unfortunately quite popular in our society too — only to spend the next half showing why that whole idea is wrong. But, at least in cinema, people would like the rug being pulled from beneath their feet, which is why many ended up cheering both for the idea and the dismantling of it.
At the centre of the narrative is a University in Karnataka. The charred body of Saba (Mamta Mohandas), an outspoken professor who stands up against the administration for various issues concerning the students, is found near the highway, leading to major student protests. In scenes reminiscent of the real world, the police beat up the protesting students brutally. The trust in the police is abysmally low among the students when Sajjan Kumar (Suraj Venjaramoodu) takes charge of the investigation in a seemingly purposeful manner.
Director: dijo jose antony, cast: suraj venjaramoodu, prithviraj, mamta mohandas.
After a not so great debut in Queen , filmmaker Dijo Jose Antony widens the scale of his ambition in his sophomore effort. The contemporary debates in the country, around the growth of far right politics, which survives on constant stirring of the communal pot and dissemination of hate propaganda, must certainly have been playing in the screenwriter's mind while writing the film.
But despite its right intent and partly interesting structure, the making is quite uneven. Much of the treatment is loud and over-dramatic, especially the court scenes in the latter half. While it meanders pointlessly in the initial campus scenes, too much is said in quite a few rushed sequences towards the end. Much of this has to do with the mystery around Prithviraj's character, who re-appears only at the interval point, after an introduction in the prologue. The script also banks on all the incessant talking that this character does, not only to convey its political ideas, but also to reveal the twists in the tale.
Yet for all its cinematic flaws, the film does not hold anything back as far as the politics that it wants to speak. It raises uncomfortable debates on how those who raise questions are branded and targeted, how the media sets narratives at the behest of the establishment, how it plays into the inherent biases of the common people, and how the politics of identity is used to divide people for votes.
Jana Gana Mana is currently running in theatres
Malayalam cinema / reviews / Indian cinema
Terms & conditions | Institutional Subscriber
Comments have to be in English, and in full sentences. They cannot be abusive or personal. Please abide by our community guidelines for posting your comments.
We have migrated to a new commenting platform. If you are already a registered user of The Hindu and logged in, you may continue to engage with our articles. If you do not have an account please register and login to post comments. Users can access their older comments by logging into their accounts on Vuukle.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Deepa Soman, TNN, Updated: Apr 28, 2022, 03.04 PM IST Critic's Rating: 3.5/5. Jana Gana Mana Story: A college lecturer gets killed and her body is burnt, and the incident leads to a massive public ...
'Jana Gana Mana' directed by Dijo Jose Anthony and scripted by Sharis Mohammed, is a lofty experiment dissecting the conflict between truth and perception. Is truth always what it seems to be, does law have no place in matters of conscience and why does selective outcry happen in a society are questions that are explored in the movie.
Jana Gana Mana, which already feels like three or four movies rolled into one, promises more surprises and high-intensity drama in a sequel. ... 'Jana Gana Mana' review: Prithviraj-starrer is an ...
Just like Dijo's first movie Queen, where Salim Kumar asks some relevant questions about gender equality, in Jana Gana Mana, Prithviraj plays an advocate and gives viewers some goosebump moments by asking relevant questions about the deep-rooted casteism and racism prevailing in the country.
Jana Gana Mana Malayalam Movie Review & Rating: പൃഥ്വിരാജിനെയും സുരാജ് വെഞ്ഞാറമൂടിനെയും ...
Jana Gana Mana Review. Second film of Dijo Jose Antony. തുല്യ പ്രാധാന്യമുള്ള വേഷങ്ങളില് ...
Jana Gana Mana (aka) Jana Kana Mana review. Jana Gana Mana (aka) Jana Kana Mana is a Malayalam movie. DHRUVAN, Ilavarasu, Mamta Mohandas, Prithviraj Sukumaran, Shammi Thilakan, Sri Divya, Suraj ...
Jana Gana Mana Movie Review (2022). Home; Malayalam; Review; Jana Gana Mana; Dijo Jose Antony's 'Jana Gana Mana' is a well-performed drama (Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu) about the ...
WATCH OR NOT. 'Jana Gana Mana' makes a powerful statement about social evil. While there are moments that are over dramatic, the film is overall a worthy story. Director: Dijo Jose Antony. Writer: Sharis Mohammed. Cast: Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Mamta Mohandas, Vincy Aloshious, Shari, Shammi Thilakan. Language: Malayalam.
Jana Gana Mana is a Malayalam socio-political drama that is directed by Dijo Jose Antony, and is written by Sharis Mohammed. The movie stars Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Mamta Mohandas, Sri Divya, Shammi Thilakan, Ilavarasu, Priyanka Nair, Vincy Aloshious, among others. 🎥 Jana Gana Mana Movie Review: Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu's Film Makes All The Right Noises in ...
Jana Gana Mana (transl. The Minds of All People) is a 2022 Indian Malayalam-language legal thriller film directed by Dijo Jose Antony and starring Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Pasupathi Raj, G. M. Sundar, Mamta Mohandas, Sri Divya.The music was composed by Jakes Bejoy with cinematography by Sudeep Elamon and editing by Sreejith Sarang. . The film released on 28 April 2022 to ...
Jana Gana Mana: Directed by Dijo Jose Antony. With Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Mamta Mohandas, Mammootty. As a college professor's brutal murder sparks student unrest, a cop launches an investigation while a lawyer seeks justice in the the courtroom.
Review: Right at the interval of Dijo Jose Antony's socio-political film Jana Gana Mana, one of its protagonists stares at a quote from Mahatma Gandhi: "In matters of conscience, the law of majority has no place."It's almost antithetical that the quotation finds a place in a court of law, but that's what Dijo and the film's scriptwriter Sharis Muhammed do in Jana Gana Mana ...
Jana Gana Mana brings together Prithviraj and Suraj Venjaramoodu again after the immensely successful Driving Licence (currently being remade in Hindi as Selfiee).Naturally, you expect great things from any film involving them after that. And Jana Gana Mana doesn't disappoint. I don't know if it would be fair to say whether one film is better than the other.
One of the most active Indian film clubs on Reddit. Jana Gana Mana review from newbie to Malayalam Movies. So to give some background, I'm from Australia born and bought up but of Indian origin. My parents are from North India, but my wife of over 7 years now is from Karnataka. Over the last few years I've been really getting more into South ...
Jana Gana Mana is a social crime thriller starring the lovely Driving License duo Prithviraj Sukumaran and Suraj Venjaramoodu in the lead roles. The film is directed by Dijo Jose Antony, whose previous and debut film was Queen [2018].. Premise
Become a member and support the channel and get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCD_UfVbw_YtH4vMrnJv7fGg/joinJana Gana Mana (transl. The Mind...
The courtrooms in director Dijo Jose Anthony's films - Queen (2018) and the latest, Jana Gana Mana - are loud and explosive, headlined by a lawyer, the superhero in a black coat, who is immune to character development.In an early scene set on the college campus, at Saba's memorial service, the chairman of the university takes the podium and delivers an offensive speech, blaming Saba for ...
The spotlight falls on the superstar of the new Malayalam film, Jana Gana Mana, only in the second half of the narrative.Once the camera rests on Prithviraj Sukumaran's character though, it rarely moves away from him as he belts out speech after speech…after speech…after speech…steeped in powerful messaging that, despite the loudness and melodrama of those scenes, is largely ...
Call it an overtly meta reading of what's essentially a simple scene, but there's something about the timing of Jana Gana Mana's release that made this stretch feel a lot more significant.With Sathyan Anthikad's Makal set to release a day later, we get a scene where Jana Gana Mana's director Dijo Jose Antony appears as a college professor. It is set in Maharajas College and the lecture is on ...
Jana Gana Mana is a 2022 Malayalam action-thriller movie, directed by Dijo Jose Antony. Jana Gana Mana stars Prithviraj Sukumaran, Suraj Venjaramoodu, Mamta Mohandas, Sri Divya, Dhruvan, Shari and ...
So, yeah, sure, the movie doesn't score a 100/100 on its politics, but it does score high enough that I can appreaciate it while also certainly acknowledging its flaws. "Except for the courtroom sequence, Jana Gana Mana is a complete drag." This, I think, is harsh. Felt as if the writer wanted to end the review on a banger of a sentence or ...
Filmmaker Dijo Jose Antony and screenwriter Sharis Mohammed go by this maxim in the film Jana Gana Mana. In quite an interesting set-up, at the interval point, they get the audience to cheer for ...