gasohol experiment slideshare

Alcohol fuel

The use of alcohol as a fuel for internal combustion engines , either alone or in combination with other fuels , has been given much attention mostly because of its possible environmental and long-term economical advantages over fossil fuels .

Both ethanol and methanol have been considered for this purpose. While both can be obtained from petroleum or natural gas , ethanol may be the most interesting because many believe it to be a renewable resource , easily obtained from sugar or starch in crops and other agricultural produce such as grain, sugarcane or even lactose. When alcohol fuel is mixed into gasoline , the result is known as gasohol . Other experiments involve butanol , which can also be produced by fermentation of plants.

Fuel alcohols

Proposals to use alcohol as a fuel are generally concerned with its use in transportation, chiefly as a total or partial replacement for gasoline in combustion engines in cars and other road vehicles. However, other less conventional approaches have been advanced, such as the use of alcohol in fuel cells , either directly or as a feedstock for hydrogen production.

Fuel alcohols can be produced from a variety of crops, such as sugarcane , sugar beets , maize , barley , potatoes , cassava , sunflower , eucalyptus , etc. Two countries have developed significant bio-alcohol programmes: Brazil (ethanol from sugarcane) and Russia (methanol from eucalyptus). Ethanol for industrial use is often made synthetically from petroleum feedstock, typically by the catalytic hydration of ethylene with sulfuric acid as catalyst. This process is cheaper than the production by fermentation. It can also be obtained via ethene or acetylene , from calcium carbide , coal, oil gas, and other sources.

Agricultural alcohol for fuel requires substantial amounts of cultivable land with fertile soils and water. It is hardly an option for densely occupied and industrialized regions like Western Europe. For example, even if Germany were to be entirely covered with sugarcane plantations, it would get only half of its present energy needs (including fuel and electricity). However, if the fuel alcohol is made of the stalks, wastes, clippings, straw, corn cobs, and other crop field trash, then no additional land is needed. However using these sources for this purpose would require additional replacement animal feedstock, fertilizers and electric power plant fuels.

Ethanol can be derived from corn, wheat, potato wastes, cheese whey, rice straw, sawdust, urban wastes, paper mill wastes, yard clippings, molasses, sugar cane, seaweed, surplus food crops, and other cellulose waste. Petroleum is also used to make industrial ethanol.

Ethanol, which is the same chemical as the alcohol in alcoholic beverages , can reach 96% purity by volume by distillation , and is as clear as water. This is enough for straight-ethanol combustion. For blending with gasoline, purities of 99.5 to 99.9% are required, depending on temperature, to avoid separation. These purities are produced using additional industrial processes. Ethanol in water is an azeotropic mixture which cannot be purified beyond 96% by distillation. Today, the most widely used purification method is the a physical absorption process using molecular sieves. Ethanol is flammable and pure ethanol burns more cleanly than many other fuels . It can be said that the combustion of ethanol produces no net carbon dioxide . When fully combusted, its combustion products are only carbon dioxide and water which are also the by-products of regular cellulose waste decomposition. For this reason, it is favoured for environmentally conscious transport schemes and has been used to fuel public buses . However, pure ethanol reacts with or disolves certain rubber and plastic materials and cannot be used in unmodified engines. Additionally, ethanol has a much higher octane rating than ordinary gasoline , requiring changes to the compression ratio or spark timing to obtain maximum benefit. To change a gasoline-fueled car into an pure-ethanol-fueled car, larger carburetor jets (about 50% larger) are needed. A cold starting system is also needed to ensure sufficient vaporization to maximize combustion and minimize uncombusted nonvaporized ethanol. If 10 to 30% ethanol is mixed with gasoline, then no engine modification is needed. Many modern cars can run on the mixture very reliably.

A mixture containing gasoline with approximately 10% ethanol is known as gasohol. It was introduced nationwide in Denmark, and in 1989, Brazil produced 12 billion litres of fuel ethanol from sugar cane, which was used to power 9.2 million cars. It is also commonly available in the Midwest of the United States and is the only automobile fuel allowed to be sold in the state of Minnesota . The most common gasohol variant is "E10", containing 10% ethanol and 90% gasoline. Other blends include E5 and E7. These concentrations are generally safe for recent, unmodified automobile engines, and some regions and municipalities mandate that the locally-sold fuels contain limited amounts of ethanol. One way to measure alternative fuels in the US is the " gasoline-equivalent gallons " (GEG). In 2002, the U.S. used as fuel an amount of ethanol equal to 137 petajoules (PJ), the energy of 1.13 billion US gallons (4,280,000 m³) of gasoline. This was less than 1% of the total fuel used that year. [1]  ( http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/alternate/page/datatables/table10.html )

The term " E85 " is used for a mixture of 15% gasoline and 85% ethanol. Beginning with the model year 1999 , an increasing number of vehicles in the world are manufactured with engines which can run on any gasoline from 0% ethanol up to 85% ethanol without modification. Many light trucks (a class containing minivans , SUVs and pickup trucks ) are desgined to be dual fuel or flexible fuel vehicles , since they can automatically detect the type of fuel and change the engine's behavior, principally air-to-fuel ratio and ignition timing to compensate for the different octane levels of the fuel in the engine cylinders.

In the past, when farmers distilled their own ethanol, they sometimes used radiators as part of the still . The radiators often contained lead , which would get into the ethanol. Lead entered the air during the burning of contaminated fuel, possibly leading to neural damage. However this was a minor source of lead since tetraethyl lead was used as a gasoline additive. Today, ethanol for fuel use is produced almost exclusively from purpose built plants eliminating any use of lead.

In Brazil and the United States , the use of ethanol from sugar cane and grain as car fuel has been promoted by government programs. Some individual U.S. states in the corn belt began subsidizing ethanol from corn ( maize ) after the Arab oil embargo of 1973 . The Energy Tax Act of 1978 authorized an excise tax exemption for biofuels , chiefly gasohol. The excise tax exemption alone has been estimated as worth US$ 1.4 billion per year. Another U.S. federal program guaranteed loans for the construction of ethanol plants, and in 1986 the U.S. even gave ethanol producers free corn.

Methanol , too, has been considered as a fuel, mainly in combination with gasoline. It has received less attention than ethanol , however, because it has a number of problems of its own. Its main advantage is that it can be easily manufactured from methane (the chief constituent of natural gas ) as well as by pyrolysis of many organic materials. Pure methanol has been used in indy cars since the mid- 1960s .

However, unlike ethanol, it is a toxic product; extensive exposure to it could lead to permanent health damage, including blindness. US maximum allowed exposure in air (40 h/week) are 1900 mg/m³ for ethanol, 900 mg/m³ for gasoline, and 260 mg/m³ for methanol. It is also quite volatile and therefore would increase the risk of fires and explosions.

Nevertheless, a drive to add a significant percentage of methanol to gasoline got very close to implementation in Brazil . A pilot experiment that was to be conducted in São Paulo was vetoed at the last minute by the city's mayor, out of concern for the health of gas station workers (who are mostly illiterate and could not be expected to follow safety precautions). The idea has not been heard of since.

See also the Methanol economy article.

Alcohol and hydrogen

There is an emerging view that current consumers of fossil fuels should move to using hydrogen as a fuel, creating a new so-called hydrogen economy . However, hydrogen is not a fuel source in and of itself. Rather, it is merely an intermediate energy storage medium existing between an energy source (be it solar power , biofuels , and nuclear power ) and the place where the energy will be used. Because hydrogen in its gaseous state takes up a very large volume when compared to other fuels, logistics becomes a very difficult problem. One possible solution is to use ethanol to transport the hydrogen, then liberate the hydrogen from its associated carbon in a hydrogen reformer and feed the hydrogen into a fuel cell . Alternatively, some fuel cells can be directly fed by ethanol.

By comparison, ethanol is a less efficient fuel in a fuel cell compared with methanol. Each molecule of methanol produces 6 electrons in a three-step anode reaction, while ethanol would only produce 2 electrons in a single step.

In early 2004 , researchers at the University of Minnesota announced that they had invented a simple ethanol reactor that would take ethanol, feed it through a stack of catalysts , and output hydrogen suitable for a fuel cell. The device uses a rhodium - cerium catalyst for the initial reaction, which occurs at a temperature of about 700 °C. This initial reaction mixes ethanol, water vapor, and oxygen and produces good quantities of hydrogen. Unfortunately, it also results in the formation of carbon monoxide, a substance that "chokes" most fuel cells and must be passed through another catalyst to be converted into carbon dioxide. The ultimate products of the simple device are roughly 50% hydrogen gas and 30% nitrogen, with the remaining 20% mostly composed of carbon dioxide. Both the nitrogen and carbon dioxide are fairly inert when the mixture is pumped into an appropriate fuel cell. Once the carbon dioxide is released back into the atmosphere, where it can be reabsorbed by plant life. No net carbon dioxide is released, though it could be argued that while it is in the atmosphere, it does act as a greenhouse gas.

Alternate sources

Sugar cane grows in the extreme southern United States, but not in the cooler climates where corn is dominant. However, many regions that currently grow corn are also appropriate areas for growing sugar beets . Some studies indicate that using these sugar beets would be a much more efficient method for making ethanol in the U.S. than using corn.

In the 1980s, Brazil seriously considered producing ethanol from cassava , a major food crop with massive starchy roots. However yields were lower than sugarcane, and the processing of cassava was considerably more complex, as it would require cooking the root to turn the starch into fermentable sugar. The babaçu plant was also investigated as a possible source of alcohol.

There is also growing interest in the use of biomass as a source for ethanol and other types of fuel. New technologies such as cellulose to ethanol production could provide much higher positive energy ratios of 2 to 3 times more energy in ethanol produced then inputted. Cellulose to ethanol production could also run on any cellulose source from farm waste, hay/grass, basically any plant matter including wood, cardboard and paper. Theoretically farms could produce fuel without sacrificing food production, because all that is needed is the left over plant matter after harvesting. Cellulose to ethanol production is still in development and has seen limited use in industrial ethanol production. The biggest challenges in using cellulose as a feedstock is the treatment and disposal of process waste and the conversion of C 5 sugars (these are typically unconverted adding to the waste treatment demand). Unlike grain based processes which produce a by-product known as distillers grain with minimal waste treatment needs, cellulosic processes are typically effluent and waste treatment intensive. Distiller grain is a protein enriched animal feed with much higher nutritional value than natural grain and is typically priced at less than half that of natural grain. It therefore tends to be a desirable product for animal feeders. Approximately one-third of grain usage in the production of ethanol in modern plants is recovered as distillers grain. [2]  ( http://www.public.iastate.edu/~brummer/ag/biomass2.htm ) [3]  ( http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/analysispaper/biomass.html ) [4]  ( http://www.newfarm.org/international/news/050104/0517/ca_ethanol.shtml )

At this time, most of the different processes for converting biomass into ethanol and other fuels are very complicated and not particularly efficient. A few processes have seen increasing buzz , including thermal depolymerization (though that process produces what is described as light crude oil ).

Net fuel energy balance

To be viable, an alcohol-based fuel economy should have positive net fuel energy balance . Namely, the total fuel energy expended in producing the alcohol — including fertilizing , farming , harvesting , transport , fermentation , distillation , and distribution, as well as the fuel used in building the farm and fuel plant equipment — should not exceed the energy contents of the product.

This is a controversial subject charged with potential bias. Much of it depends on what are included and what are excluded from the calculation, particularly when compared with the energy balance of the production of gasoline itself. Analyses are greatly complicated by various methods of accounting for the energy value coproducts and consideration of alternate uses of the feedstock. Not surprisingly, this debate has been at best inconclusive to date.

Switching to a system with negative fuel energy balance would only increase the consumption of non-alcohol fuels. Such a system would only be worth considering as a way of exploiting non-alcohol fuels that may not be suitable for transportation use, such as coal , natural gas , or biofuel from crop residues. (Indeed, many U.S. proposals assume the use of natural gas for distillation.) However, many of the expected environmental and sustainability advantages of alcohol fuels would not be realized in a system with negative fuel balance.

Even a positive but small energy balance would be problematic: if the net fuel energy balance is 50%, then, in order to eliminate the use of non-alcohol fuels, it would be necessary to produce two units of alcohol for each unit of alcohol delivered to the consumer.

In this regard, geography is the decisive factor. In tropical regions with abundant water and land resources, such as Brazil , the viability of production of ethanol from sugarcane is no longer in question; in fact, the burning of sugarcane residues (bagasse) generates far more energy than needed to operate the ethanol plants, and many of them are now selling electric energy to the utilities. Also, in countries with abundant hydroelectric power, the net fuel energy balance of the cycle could be improved to some extent by using electricity in the production, e.g. for milling and distillation.

The picture is quite different for other regions, such as the United States , where the climate is too cool for sugarcane. In the U.S., agricultural ethanol is generally obtained from grain , chiefly maize , and the net fuel energy balance of that route is still critical.

Energy balance in the United States

Many early studies concluded that the use of corn ethanol for fuel would have a negative net energy balance. Namely, the total energy needed to produce ethanol from grain — including fermentation, fertilizing , fuel for farm tractors , harvesting and transporting the grain, building and operating an ethanol plant, and the natural gas used to distill corn sugars into alcohol — exceeds the energy content of ethanol. Critics have argued that since production energy comes mostly from fossil fuels, gasohol isn't just wasting money but hastening the depletion of non-renewable resources. Most such studies were based on data collected in the 1970s and early 1980s , but some analyses in 2001 , continued to indicate that ethanol has a negative energy balance. A peer-reviewed study by Cornell University ecology professor David Pimentel seemed to confirm this conclusion. Pimentel's study was disputed by other specialists, forcing him to revise his figures. Still, in August 2003 , he stated in a Cornell bulletin that production of ethanol from corn only takes 29% more energy than it produces.

However, continuous refinements to ethanol production procedures have much improved the benefit/cost ratio, and most studies of modern systems indicate that they now have a positive net energy balance. Also, when ethanol is mixed with water vapor and converted into hydrogen, it does not need to be as pure as when it is used in a combustion engine, making the process more efficient. (see source below)

Many other studies of corn ethanol production have been conducted, with greatly varied net energy estimates. Most indicate that production requires energy equivalent to 1/2, 2/3, or more of the fuel produced to run the process. A 2002 report by the United States Department of Agriculture concluded that corn ethanol production in the U.S. has a net energy value of 1.34, meaning 34% more energy was produced than what went in. This means that 75% (1/1.34) of each unit produced is required to replace the energy used in production. MSU Ethanol Energy Balance Study:  ( http://www.ethanol.org/pdfs/msu_ethanol_study.pdf ) Michigan State University, May 2002. This comprehensive, independent study funded by MSU shows that there is 56% more energy per unit volume of ethanol than it takes to produce it.

Arguments and criticisms

The use of alcohol as fuel is advocated with various arguments, mainly relating to its beneficial effects on the local and global environment , its independence from foreign oil, and its economic advantages. Critics generally dispute those arguments, claim that the switch would be expensive, and object to perceived need for increased government subsidies, taxes, and regulations.

Air pollution

There has long been widespread acknowledgement that ethanol is a cleaner-burning fuel than gasoline. Ethanol has far fewer standard regulated pollutants such as carbon monoxide and hydrocarbons, compared with plain gasoline in equivalent tests. See, for example, the air pollution and environmental studies listed at the Renewable Fuels Association website http://www.ethanolrfa.org/pubs.shtml

There has been concern about increased evaporative smog-forming hydrocarbon emissions. For example, the conservative organization RPPI claims that "adding ethanol to gasoline will at best have no effect on air quality and could even make it worse. Studies show ethanol could even increase emissions of nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds, which are major ingredients of smog." [5]  ( http://www.rppi.org/ethanolmandates.html ) Other critics have argued that the beneficial effects of ethanol can be achieved with other cheaper additives made from petroleum.

It is important to distinguish the issues. Ethanol in a blend with gasoline replaces tetra ethyl lead, benzene and MTBE -- all of which are additives that are meant to raise octane levels. Ethanol, with an octane rating of 110, far surpasses regular gasoline and precludes needs for other dangerous additives. However, ethanol can increase vapor pressure of gasoline causing increased evaporative emissions which, on balance, are far less serious than lead, benzene or MTBE.

Ethanol as a straight fuel is far cleaner than gasoline in its own right and this has been recognized from the dawn of the automotive age. See, for instance, Kovarik's "Fuel of the Future" http://www.radford.edu/~wkovarik/lead

Fire safety

Ethanol appears to be less of a fire hazard than gasoline; while methanol, being more volatile, is somewhat more prone to fire and explosions. However, since ethanol and methanol dissolve in water (rather than floating on it like gasoline) their fires can be extinguished with ordinary water hoses.

One of the problems with accidental combustion of pure ethanol is that it burns with a dim, blue flame, with invisible smoke. Methanol flames are dim enough to be considered invisible in daylight. Blending significant amounts of gasoline produces a highly visible flame; small quantities of dye can also produce this effect.

Greenhouse gases

A separate (and perhaps more important) benefit of switching to an ethanol fuel economy would be the decreased net output of the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide ( C O 2 ), since all the CO 2 that would be liberated in the manufacture and consumption of ethanol would have to be absorbed by the plantations. In constrast, the burning of fossil fuels injects massive amounts of "new" CO 2 into the atmosphere, without creating a corresponding sink.

Needless to say, this advantage will be accrued only with agricultural ethanol, not with ethanol derived from petroleum — which, due to its much smaller cost, presently accounts for most of the alcohol produced for industrial consumption. This point must be taken into account when estimating the cost of the switch.

Renewable resource

According to its proponents, another advantage of (agricultural) alcohol as a fuel is that it is a renewable energy source that will never be exhausted; whereas an economy based on fossil fuels will sooner or later collapse when the world runs out of oil.

However, David Pimentel disputes that "ethanol production from corn" is a renewable energy source.

Dependency on foreign oil and international crime

A somewhat related (but more compelling) argument is that developed regions like the United States and Europe consume much more fossil fuels than they can extract from their territory, therefore becoming dependant upon foreign suppliers as a result. As such, this dependency has become a major cause of oil wars and coups d'etat initiated by Western powers, and attendant misery and human rights violations in certain oil-producing countries allied with the West. Even if the energy balance is negative, US production involves mostly domestic fuels such as natural gas and coal, so the impact on oil importation is still positive.

Some critics, mainly on ideological grounds, dislike the idea of an ethanol economy because they see it as leading to increased government subsidy for corn-growing agribusiness , and statism . The Archer Daniels Midland Corporation of Decatur, Illinois , better known as ADM, the world's largest grain processor, produces 40% of the ethanol used to make gasohol in the U.S. The company and its officers have been eloquent in their defense of ethanol and generous in contributing to both political parties.

Tax Incentives for ethanol and petroleum:  ( http://www.ethanol.org/pdfs/oil_incentive_study.pdf ) U.S. General Accounting Office, September 2000. This study examines subsidies historically given to the oil industry and to the ethanol industry and finds that the amounts of those to the oil industry are far higher. At the same time, this study applies only to historical subsidies and doesn't investigate the question of what the case would be if petroleum fuels were substantially replaced by ethanol.

Many economists argue that using bioalcohol as a petroleum substitute is economically infeasible because the energy required to grow the corn and other crops used as fuel is greater than the amount ultimately produced (see, trophic level ). They argue that government programs that mandate the use of bioalcohol are simply agricultural subsidies enacted to gain votes from heavily agricultural states, especially Iowa . As petroleum prices rise, the breakeven point may be established.

The Brazilian experiment

In Brazil, ethanol is produced from sugar cane which is a more efficient source of fermentable carbohydrates than corn as well as much easier to grow and process. Brazil has the largest sugarcane crop in the world, which, besides ethanol, also yields sugar, electricity, and industrial heating. Sugar cane growing requires little labor, and government tax and pricing policies have made ethanol production a very lucrative business for big farms. As a consequence, over the last 25 years sugarcane has become one of the main crops grown in the country.

Ethanol production basics

Sugarcane is harvested manually or mechanically and shipped to the distillery ( usina ) in huge specially built trucks. There are several hundred distilleries throughout the country; they are typically owned and run by big farms or farm consortia and located near the producing fields. At the mill the cane is roller-pressed to extract the juice ( garapa ), leaving behind a fibrous residue (bagasse). The juice is fermented by yeasts which break down the sucrose into CO2 and ethanol. The resulting "wine" is distilled, yielding hydrated ethanol (5% water by volume) and " fusel oil ". The acidic residue of the distillation ( vinhoto ) is neutralized with lime and sold as fertilizer. The hydrated ethanol may be sold as is (for ethanol cars) or be dehydrated and used as a gasoline additive (for gasohol cars). In either case, the bulk product was sold until 1996 at regulated prices to the state oil company ( Petrobras ). Today it is no longer regulated.

One ton (1,000 kg ) of harvested sugarcane, as shipped to the processing plant, contains about 145 kg of dry fiber (bagasse) and 138 kg of sucrose. Of that, 112 kg can be extracted as sugar, leaving 23 kg in low-valued molasses. If the cane is processed for alcohol, all the sucrose is used, yielding 72 liters of ethanol. Burning the bagasse produces heat for distillation and drying, and (through low-pressure boilers and turbines) about 288 MJ of electricity, of which 180 MJ is used by the plant itself and 108 MJ sold to utilities.

The average cost of production, including farming, transportation and distribution, is US$0.63 per US gallon (US$0.17/L); gasoline prices in the world market is about US$ 1.05 per US gallon (US$0.28/L). The alcohol industry, entirely private, was invested heavily in crop improvement and agricultural techniques. As a result, average yearly ethanol yield increased steadily from 300 to 550 m³/km² between 1978 and 2000, or about 3.5% per year.

Electricity from bagasse

Sucrose accounts for little more than 30% of the chemical energy stored in the mature plant; 35% is in the leaves and stem tips, which are left in the fields during harvest, and 35% are in the fibrous material ( bagasse ) left over from pressing.

Part of the bagasse is currently burned at the mill to provide heat for distillation and electricity to run the machinery. This allows ethanol plants to be energetically self-sufficient and even sell surplus electricity to utilities; current production is 600 MW for self-use and 100 MW for sale. This secondary activity is expected to boom now that utilities have been convinced to pay fair price (about US$10/GJ) for 10 year contracts. The energy is especially valuable to utilities because it is produced mainly in the dry season when hydroelectric dams are running low. Estimates of potential power generation from bagasse range from 1,000 to 9,000 MW, depending on technology. Higher estimates assume gasification of biomass, replacement of current low-pressure steam boilers and turbines by high-pressure ones, and use of harvest trash currently left behind in the fields. For comparison, Brazil's Angra I nuclear plant generates 600 MW (and it is often off line).

Presently, it is economically viable to extract about 288 MJ of electricity from the residues of one ton of sugarcane, of which about 180 MJ are used in the plant itself. Thus a medium-size distillery processing 1 million tons of sugarcane per year could sell about 5 MW of surplus electricity. At current prices, it would earn US$ 18 million from sugar and ethanol sales, and about US$ 1 million from surplus electricity sales. With advanced boiler and turbine technology, the electricity yield could be increased to 648 MJ per ton of sugarcane, but current electricity prices do not justify the necessary investment. (According to one report, the World bank would only finance investments in bagasse power generation if the price were at least US$19/GJ.)

Bagasse burning is environmentally friendly compared to other fuels like oil and coal. Its ash content is only 2.5% (against 30-50% of coal), and it contains no sulfur. Since it burns at relatively low temperatures, it produces little nitrous oxides. Moreover, bagasse is being sold for use as a fuel (replacing heavy fuel oil) in various industries, including citrus juice concentrate, vegetable oil, ceramics, and tyre recycling. The state of São Paulo alone used 2 million tons, saving about US$ 35 million in fuel oil imports.

Program statistics

Except where noted, the following data apply to the 2003/2004 season.

The labor figures are industry estimates, and do not take into account the loss of jobs due to replacement of other crops by sugarcane.

Effect on oil consumption

Most cars in Brazil run either on alcohol or on gasohol; only recently dual-fuel ("Flex Fuel") engines have become available. Most gas stations sell both fuels. The market share of the two car types has varied a lot over the last decades, in response to fuel price changes. Ethanol-only cars were sold in Brazil in significant numbers between 1980 and 1995; between 1983 and 1988, they accounted for over 90% of the sales. They have been available again since 2001, but still account for only a few percent of the total sales.

Ethanol-fuelled small planes for farm use have been developed by giant Embraer and by a small Brazilian firm (Aeroálcool), and are currently undergoing certification.

Domestic demand for alcohol grew between 1982 and 1998 from 11,000 to 33,000 cubic metres per day, and has remained roughly constant since then. In 1989 more than 90% of the production was used by ethanol-only cars; today that has reduced to about 40%, the remaining 60% being used with gasoline in gasohol-only cars. Both the total consumption of ethanol and the ethanol/gasohol ratio are expected to increase again with deployment of dual-fuel cars.

Presently the use of ethanol as fuel by Brazilian cars - as pure ethanol and in gasohol - replaces gasoline at the rate of about 27,000 cubic metres per day, or about 40% of the fuel that would be needed to run the fleet on gasoline alone. However, the effect on the country's oil consumption was much smaller than that. Although Brazil is a major oil producer and now exports gasoline (19,000 m³/day), it still must import oil because of internal demand for other oil byproducts, chiefly diesel fuel (which cannot be easily replaced by ethanol).

Environmental effect

The improvement in air quality in big cities in the 1980s, following the widespread use of ethanol as car fuel, was evident to everyone; as was the degradation that followed the partial return to gasoline in the 1990s.

However, the ethanol program also brought a host of environmental and social problems of its own. Sugarcane fields are traditionally burned just before harvest, in order to remove the leaves and kill snakes. Therefore, in sugarcane-growing parts of the country, the smoke from burning fields turns the sky gray throughout the harvesting season. As winds carry the smoke into nearby towns, air pollution goes critical and respiratory problems soar. Thus, the air pollution which was removed from big cities was merely transferred to the rural areas (and multiplied). This practice has been decreasing of late, due to pressure from the public and health authorities. In Brazil, a recent law has been created in order to ban the burnings of sugarcane fields, and machines will be used to harvest the cane instead of people. This not only solves the problem of pollution from burning fields, but such machines have a higher productivity than people.

Many nations have produced alcohol fuel with no destruction to the environment. Advancements in fertilizers and natural pesticides have eliminated the need to burn fields. With condensed agriculture, like hydroponics and greenhouses , less land is used to grow more crops. Now it is possible to grow crops in the desert and other un arable lands, where there are much fewer native plants and animals to disturb.

Social implications

The ethanol program also led to widespread replacement of small farms and varied agriculture by vast seas of sugarcane monoculture. This led to a decrease in biodiversity and further shrinkage of the residual native forests (not only from deforestation but also through fires caused by the burning of adjoining fields). The replacement of food crops by the more lucrative sugarcane has also led to a sharp increase in food prices over the last decade.

Since sugarcane only requires hand labor at harvest time, this shift also created a large population of destitute migrant workers who can only find temporary employment as cane cutters (at about US$3 to 5 per day) for one or two months every year. This huge social problem has contributed to political unrest and violence in rural areas, which are now plagued by recurrent farm invasions, vandalism, armed confrontations, and assassinations.

The Brazilian alcohol program has been often criticized for many motives, including excessive land use, environmental damage, displacement of food crops, reliance on misery-wage temporary labor, statism and dependency on government subsidies, etc..

Until 1996, the Brazilian oil company (Petrobras) was forced to buy ethanol from the private distilleries and sell it to gas station chains, both as pure (hydrated) ethanol and gasohol. Nowadays Petrobras only buy ethanol as a anti-knocking additive. However, for lack of internal demand, Petrobras is virtually forced to sell its surplus gasoline in the international market at a rather low price, US$ 0.13/liter. Since the domestic market price is about US$ 0.50/liter, Petrobras could increase its revenue by over 1 billion US$ per year if the ethanol program were cancelled. Petrobras also produces methyl-tert-butyl ether (MTBE), a compound that could replace ethanol in gasohol as an anti-knocking and anti-pollution additive.

On the other hand, the sugarcane agribusiness sector is politically powerful and so far it has successfully defended the program from its critics. The positive effect of the program on Brazil's overstrained foreign trade speaks louder than all its environmental and social problems.

• Energy directory compiles various energy technologies and issues featured at Wikipedia, with emphasis on clean, renewable energy systems.
• butanol from Clostridium acetobutylicum
• liquid fuels
• Timeline of Alcohol Fuel
• Landless Movement ( Movimento dos Sem-Terra ) under Politics of Brazil

External links

• U.S. Department of Energy: Biomass Program  ( http://www.eere.energy.gov/biomass/ ) .
• U.S. Department of Energy: Clean Cities  ( http://www.eere.energy.gov/cleancities/ ) . Includes info on flexible fuel vehicles.
• Ethanol as Fuel  ( http://freeenergynews.com/Directory/Ethanol/ ) - Documentation that Ethanol consumes more energy to make than is derived from its burning.
• American Coalition for Ethanol: www.ethanol.org . Advocacy group.
• Methanol Institute: [6]  ( http://www.methanol.org/altfuel/press/pr970521.html ) Article about methanol in race cars.
• How To Run Your Car On Alcohol Fuel  ( http://terrasol.home.igc.org/alky/alky.htm ) - A 1982 book, now published online, with information on converting gasoline cars to use ethanol .
• Farm Industry News: Hydrogen Corn Economy  ( http://farmindustrynews.com/news/hydrogen-corn-economy/ ) . Article about converting ethanol to hydrogen.
• Making Alcohol Fuel  ( http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel_library/ethanol_motherearth/me1.html ) - A website that covers the use and production of ethanol as a fuel .
• Cogeneration in Ethanol Plants by P. M. Nastari  ( http://www.inee.org.br/down_loads/forum/1B-15-30%20Plinio%20Nastari%20DATAGRO.pdf )
• CDM Potential in Brazil, by S. Meyers, J. Sathaye et al.  ( http://ies.lbl.gov/iespubs/46120.pdf )
• Brazilian Ethanol program  ( http://www.pick-upau.com.br/mundo/alcool/alcool.htm ) (in Portuguese) and its machine translation  ( http://babelfish.altavista.com/babelfish/tr?doit=done&tt=url&intl=1&lp=pt_en&url=%48ttp://www.pick-upau.com.br/mundo/alcool/alcool.htm )
• UNICA - Brazilian Sugarcane growers assoc.  ( http://www.unica.com.br/pages/sociedade_saude2.asp ) (in Portuguese) and its machine translation  ( http://babelfish.altavista.com/babelfish/tr?doit=done&tt=url&intl=1&lp=pt_en&url=%48ttp://www.unica.com.br/pages/sociedade_saude2.asp )
• Renewable Fuel Association [7]  ( http://www.ethanolrfa.org )
• National Ethanol Vehicle Coalition [8]  ( http://e85fuel.com ) Shows locations of E85 fuel pumps in the USA
• Clean Fuels Development Coalition [9]  ( http://cleanfuelsdc.org )

Categories : Fuels | Energy

• Art  ( https://academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Art )
• Architecture  ( https://academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Architecture )
• Cultures  ( https://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Cultures )
• Music  ( https://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Music )
• Musical Instruments  ( http://academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/List_of_musical_instruments )
• Biographies  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Biographies )
• Clipart  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Clipart )
• Countries of the World  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Countries )
• Maps  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Maps )
• Flags  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Flags )
• Continents  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Continents )
• Ancient Civilizations  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Ancient_Civilizations )
• Industrial Revolution  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Industrial_Revolution )
• Middle Ages  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Middle_Ages )
• Prehistory  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Prehistory )
• Renaissance  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Renaissance )
• Timelines  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Timelines )
• United States  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/United_States )
• Wars  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Wars )
• World History  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/History_of_the_world )
• Human Body  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Human_Body )
• Mathematics  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Mathematics )
• Reference  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Reference )
• Animals  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Animals )
• Aviation  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Aviation )
• Dinosaurs  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Dinosaurs )
• Earth  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Earth )
• Inventions  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Inventions )
• Physical Science  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Physical_Science )
• Plants  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Plants )
• Scientists  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Scientists )
• Anthropology  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Anthropology )
• Economics  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Economics )
• Government  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Government )
• Religion  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Religion )
• Holidays  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Holidays )
• Solar System  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Solar_System )
• Planets  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Planets )
• Sports  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Sports )
• Weather  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Weather )
• US States  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/US_States )
• Home Page  ( http://academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php )
• Contact Us  ( http://www.academickids.com/encyclopedia/index.php/Contactus )
• Clip Art  ( http://classroomclipart.com )

Personal tools

• This page has been accessed 27192 times.
• About Academic Kids
• Disclaimers

Remember Me

Shop Experiment Energy Content of Fuels Experiments​

Energy content of fuels.

Experiment #17 from Chemistry with Vernier

Introduction

In this experiment, you will find and compare the heat of combustion of two different fuels: paraffin wax and ethanol. Paraffin is a member of a group of compounds called alkanes that are composed entirely of carbon and hydrogen atoms. Many alkanes, such as gasoline and diesel oil, are important fuels. Ethanol, C 2 H 5 OH, is used as a gasoline additive (gasohol) and as a gasoline substitute. In this experiment, you will compare the energy content of paraffin and ethanol by measuring their heats of combustion in kJ/g of fuel.

In order to find the heat of combustion, you will first use the energy from burning ethanol or paraffin to heat a known quantity of water. By monitoring the temperature of the water, you can find the amount of heat transferred to it, using the formula

where q is heat, C p is the specific heat capacity of water, m is the mass of water, and Δ t is the change in temperature of the water. Finally, the amount of fuel burned will be taken into account by calculating the heat per gram of fuel consumed in the combustion.

In this experiment, you will

• Compare the heat of combustion for paraffin wax and ethanol.
• Calculate the heat of combustion and percent efficiency for both fuels.

Sensors and Equipment

This experiment features the following sensors and equipment. Additional equipment may be required.

Correlations

Teaching to an educational standard? This experiment supports the standards below.

Ready to Experiment?

Ask an expert.

Get answers to your questions about how to teach this experiment with our support team.

• Call toll-free: 888-837-6437
• Chat with Us
• Email [email protected]

Purchase the Lab Book

This experiment is #17 of Chemistry with Vernier . The experiment in the book includes student instructions as well as instructor information for set up, helpful hints, and sample graphs and data.

Your browser is not supported

Sorry but it looks as if your browser is out of date. To get the best experience using our site we recommend that you upgrade or switch browsers.

Find a solution

• Skip to main content
• Skip to navigation

• Back to parent navigation item
• Primary teacher
• Secondary/FE teacher
• Early career or student teacher
• Higher education
• Curriculum support
• Literacy in science teaching
• Periodic table
• Interactive periodic table
• Climate change and sustainability
• Resources shop
• Collections
• Remote teaching support
• Starters for ten
• Screen experiments
• Assessment for learning
• Microscale chemistry
• Faces of chemistry
• Classic chemistry experiments
• Nuffield practical collection
• Anecdotes for chemistry teachers
• On this day in chemistry
• Global experiments
• PhET interactive simulations
• Chemistry vignettes
• Context and problem based learning
• Journal of the month
• Chemistry and art
• Art analysis
• Pigments and colours
• Ancient art: today's technology
• Psychology and art theory
• Art and archaeology
• Artists as chemists
• The physics of restoration and conservation
• Ancient Egyptian art
• Ancient Greek art
• Ancient Roman art
• Classic chemistry demonstrations
• In search of solutions
• In search of more solutions
• Creative problem-solving in chemistry
• Solar spark
• Chemistry for non-specialists
• Health and safety in higher education
• Analytical chemistry introductions
• Exhibition chemistry
• Introductory maths for higher education
• Commercial skills for chemists
• Kitchen chemistry
• Journals how to guides
• Chemistry in health
• Chemistry in sport
• Chemistry in your cupboard
• Chocolate chemistry
• Adnoddau addysgu cemeg Cymraeg
• The chemistry of fireworks
• Festive chemistry
• Education in Chemistry
• Teach Chemistry
• On-demand online
• Live online
• Selected PD articles
• PD for primary teachers
• PD for secondary teachers
• What we offer
• Chartered Science Teacher (CSciTeach)
• Teacher mentoring
• UK Chemistry Olympiad
• Who can enter?
• How does it work?
• Resources and past papers
• Top of the Bench
• Schools' Analyst
• Regional support
• Education coordinators
• RSC Yusuf Hamied Inspirational Science Programme
• RSC Education News
• Supporting teacher training
• Interest groups

• More navigation items

Comparing heat energy from burning alcohols

In association with Nuffield Foundation

• Four out of five

In this investigation, students use a spirit burner to burn various alcohols while measuring and comparing the amount of heat energy produced

This experiment is suitable for pre-16 students, possibly as an introduction to a topic on fuels. It can be taken further if used with post-16 students who can calculate values for enthalpy changes of combustion, with subsequent discussion about heat losses and incomplete combustion.

The alcohols should be provided in labelled spirit burners ready to use. If each group investigates one alcohol, the experiment can be done in around 20 minutes. It is better if each spirit burner is used by more than one group of students. Variation of results will add substance to a discussion about errors.

• Eye protection
• Retort stand and clamp
• Conical flask, 150 cm 3 or larger
• Measuring cylinder, 100 cm 3
• Thermometer (–10 °C to +110 °C)
• Access to balances, preferably several, to avoid queuing
• Access to spirit burners with wicks and caps, containing the alcohols listed (note 1)

Apparatus notes

• Suitable spirit burners are hard to come by. Ideally they should be small, with a capacity of 50 cm 3 or less. Pictures and information in suppliers’ catalogues can be misleading. It is important that the wick fits tightly in the wick holder and that the wick holder fits tightly in the burner. If capacity is more than 50 cm 3 , reduce it, for instance by packing with mineral wool, or partially filling with epoxy. Refer to CLEAPSS L195 ’Safer chemicals, safer reactions’. One possible source is: A.J.Cope & Son Ltd , Unit 10, Cliffside Trade Park, Motherwell Way, Grays, Essex, RM20 3XD.
• Methanol 
• Ethanol 
• Propan-1-ol 
• Propan-2-ol 
• Butan-1-ol 

Health, safety and technical notes

• Read our standard health and safety guidance .
• Wear eye protection throughout.
• Methanol, CH 3 OH(l), (HIGHLY FLAMMABLE, TOXIC) – see CLEAPSS Hazcard HC040b . Methanol is volatile and has a low flash point.
• Ethanol, CH 3 CH 2 OH(l), (HIGHLY FLAMMABLE) – see CLEAPSS Hazcard HC040A . Ethanol is volatile and has a low flash point.
• Propan-1-ol, CH 3 CH 2 CH 2 OH(l), (HIGHLY FLAMMABLE, IRRITANT, HARMFUL) – see CLEAPSS Hazcard HC084A . Propan-1-ol is volatile and has a low flash point.
• Propan-2-ol, CH 3 CHOHCH 3 (l), (HIGHLY FLAMMABLE, IRRITANT, HARMFUL) – see CLEAPSS Hazcard HC084A. Propan-2-ol is volatile and has a low flash point.
• Butan-1-ol, CH3CH 2 CH 2 CH 2 OH(l), (HIGHLY FLAMMABLE, IRRITANT, HARMFUL) – see CLEAPSS Hazcard HC084B . Butan-1-ol is volatile and has a low flash point.

Source: Royal Society of Chemistry

Equipment required for measuring heat energy from burning alcohol.

• Measure 100 cm 3  of cold tap water into a conical flask.
• Clamp the flask at a suitable height so that a spirit burner can easily be placed below.
• Weigh the spirit burner (and cap) containing the alcohol and record this mass and the name of the alcohol.
• Record the initial temperature of the water in the flask.
• Place the spirit burner under the flask and light the wick.
• Allow the alcohol to heat the water so the temperature rises by about 40 °C.
• Replace the cap to extinguish the flame.
• Reweigh the spirit burner and cap, and record this mass.
• Work out the mass of alcohol used.
• Using a fresh 100 cm 3  of cold tap water, repeat the experiment with another alcohol.

Teaching notes

Get the class to record and share the results. Do not be surprised if groups get different answers for a given alcohol. Heat losses will almost certainly vary considerably.

Subsequent discussion depends on the level of the students’ experience.

Student questions

Here are some possible questions to ask students:

• Which alcohol produces the most energy per gram?
• Which alcohol produces the most energy per mole?
• Write equations for the complete combustion of each alcohol.
• Propan-1-ol and propan-2-ol are isomers (same molecular formula, different structures). Do they produce the same amount of heat on combustion?
• Does all the heat produced by combustion go into raising the temperature of the water?
• Is it possible that combustion may be incomplete, giving carbon monoxide among the products?
• Alcohols can be used as a substitute for hydrocarbon fuels, and so methods of producing alcohols are very important. What process converts sugar into alcohol and carbon dioxide?

Notes on questions

• On question 6, stress the dangers accompanying the production of carbon monoxide.

More resources

Add context and inspire your learners with our short career videos showing how chemistry is making a difference .

Additional information

This is a resource from the  Practical Chemistry project , developed by the Nuffield Foundation and the Royal Society of Chemistry. This collection of over 200 practical activities demonstrates a wide range of chemical concepts and processes. Each activity contains comprehensive information for teachers and technicians, including full technical notes and step-by-step procedures. Practical Chemistry activities accompany  Practical Physics  and  Practical Biology .

© Nuffield Foundation and the Royal Society of Chemistry

• 14-16 years
• 16-18 years
• Practical experiments
• Thermodynamics
• Quantitative chemistry and stoichiometry

Specification

• 9.28C Investigate the temperature rise produced in a known mass of water by the combustion of the alcohols ethanol, propanol, butanol and pentanol
• The heat change, q, in a reaction is given by the equation q = mcΔT; where m is the mass of the substance that has a temperature change ΔT and a specific heat capacity c.
• Students should be able to: use this equation to calculate the molar enthalpy change for a reaction.
• e) determination of enthalpy changes directly from appropriate experimental results, including use of the relationship: q = mcΔT
• 5 i. understand experiments to measure enthalpy changes in terms of: processing results using the expression: energy transferred = mass x specific heat capacity × temperature change (Q=mcΔT)
• In combustion, a substance reacts with oxygen releasing energy.
• Fuels burn releasing different quantities of energy.
• The quantity of heat energy released can be determined experimentally and calculated using, Eₕ = cmΔT.
• PRACTICAL: Determination of an enthalpy change of combustion
• (f) the combustion reactions of hydrocarbons and other fuels
• (g) how to determine experimentally the energy per gram released by a burning fuel
• (v) the uses of ethanol as a solvent and as a fuel and the social, economic and environmental factors that affect the development of bioethanol fuel
• determine the enthalpy changes for combustion and neutralisation using simple apparatus; and
• 2.8.6 recall experimental methods to determine enthalpy changes;
• 2.8.7 calculate enthalpy changes from experimental data using the equation q = mcΔT;

Related articles

Teaching enthalpy cycles at post-16

2024-09-16T05:45:00Z By Naomi Hennah

Use these tips and resources to help your students construct and interpret enthalpy cycles

Enthalpy change of combustion of ethanol | practical videos | 14–16 years

By Karen Marshall and Sandrine Bouchelkia

Video and resources investigating the heat energy change of combustion of ethanol

How to teach equilibrium constants at 14–16

2023-12-05T10:16:00Z By Emma Owens

Use these strategies to connect 14–16 and post-16 study when teaching this topic, and cover all the essentials so students master it

1 Reader's comment

Only registered users can comment on this article., more experiments.

‘Gold’ coins on a microscale | 14–16 years

By Dorothy Warren and Sandrine Bouchelkia

Practical experiment where learners produce ‘gold’ coins by electroplating a copper coin with zinc, includes follow-up worksheet

Practical potions microscale | 11–14 years

By Kirsty Patterson

Observe chemical changes in this microscale experiment with a spooky twist.

Antibacterial properties of the halogens | 14–18 years

By Kristy Turner

Use this practical to investigate how solutions of the halogens inhibit the growth of bacteria and which is most effective

• Contributors
• Email alerts

Site powered by Webvision Cloud

• My presentations

Auth with social network:

Download presentation

We think you have liked this presentation. If you wish to download it, please recommend it to your friends in any social system. Share buttons are a little bit lower. Thank you!

Presentation is loading. Please wait.

Gasoline - Gasohol.

Publish Darleen Phelps Modified over 5 years ago

Similar presentations

Presentation on theme: "Gasoline - Gasohol."— Presentation transcript:

Figure 13.8 a-c (a) The Initial Equilibrium Mixture of N 2, H 2, and NH 3 (b) Addition of N2. (c.) The New Equilibrium Position for the System Containing.

Bioenergy vs Petroleum-based energy * petroleum-based energy - price - demand vs supply - CO emissions * Bioenergy - CO recycle - renewable.

An Approach to Heat Recovery in Rural Alaska Introduction Introduction Background – Maintenance & Repair Background – Maintenance & Repair Small Scale:

Set America Free 101 Institute for the Analysis of Global Security Anne Korin.

Christianson & Associates, PLLP Ethanol Energy Efficiency Report & Iowa Plants Analysis Iowa Renewable Fuels Association Summit John O. Christianson.

Tuesday, April 28, 2015 B-Day Objective: YWBAT describe the advantages and disadvantages of different energy sources. Drill: Create a concept map using.

Using Heats of Combustion and Altering Fuels

Engines How they work. A spark plug is used to ignite the fuel in an engine.

 ◦Availability-Fewer than 1 percent of U.S. filling station have it.  ◦Quality-In a test, a Chevrolet Tahoe FFV got 27 percent fewer miles.

Energy Continued. Fuel Additives Increase octane rating by increasing amount of oxygen. Ex. Methyl t-butyl ether Ethanol, methanol.

Future Energy Sources for the Common Car Patrick de la Llana Date: 11/15/12.

A Good Alternative Fuel For Gasoline Kelly Veenstra 6 th Hour.

Kim Lyons WSU Energy Program All Extension Conference March 7, 2007 Biofuels in Washington.

Linear System Word Problems

Production of Ethanol. Producing Ethanol from Corn 1.The corn will be milled into a fine powder.

ENERGY RISK MANAGEMENT CONSIDERATIONS John Robinson Texas Cooperative Extension l Context of higher energy prices l Hearings & calls for government policy.

AmeriFuels 8.1 Liter Irrigation Power Unit Presentation.

26.2 Alternative Energy Resources Pages

Diesel Engines By: Douglas Aycock April 8, History Named after Dr. Rudolf Diesel Originally replaced the stationary steam engine –75% efficient.

News  /new_england_sending_a_crowd_to_climate_talks/

About project

© 2024 SlidePlayer.com Inc. All rights reserved.

On Gasohol Production by Extracting Alcohol with Gasoline

• January 2016
• CC BY-NC 4.0
• Conference: 2016 2nd International Conference on Advances in Energy, Environment and Chemical Engineering (AEECE 2016)
• This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.

Discover the world's research

• 25+ million members
• 160+ million publication pages
• 2.3+ billion citations
• ENVIRON SCI TECHNOL
• G Z Whitten
• P S A C Leeper
• Recruit researchers
• Join for free
• Login Email Tip: Most researchers use their institutional email address as their ResearchGate login Password Forgot password? Keep me logged in Log in or Continue with Google Welcome back! Please log in. Email · Hint Tip: Most researchers use their institutional email address as their ResearchGate login Password Forgot password? Keep me logged in Log in or Continue with Google No account? Sign up

Automotive Fuel History: Why Gasoline Beat Alcohol

Julian girard december 8, 2015, submitted as coursework for ph240 , stanford university, fall 2015, introduction to the conflict.

In the modern age, fuel is power. Our global societies still depend significantly upon energy reserves in the form of fossil fuels, most notably petroleum-based fuels such as gasoline, to develop themselves and prosper. In the context of ever impinging climate change and frequent hostility in oil-rich regions of the world, alternative fuel choices have become increasingly necessary. Among the several options for renewable, clean, and efficient energy sources is one that, ironically, has been around for well over a century. [1] This essay will explore the history of this automotive fuel, once dubbed 'The Fuel of the Future' by Henry Ford, in the United States and outline the primary reasons it has not been - and might never be - the substitute for gasoline we so desperately need. [1] Ethyl alcohol or ethanol, which can be produced from just about any farm product including corn, has been widely promoted in our country at least 3 times in its history, though it has never quite reached the potential it promised.

By modern standards, ethyl alcohol is a strong fuel that has found success in several other countries such as Brazil because of its many advantages; it burns clean, it has a very high octane rating compared to gasoline, and it can be produced from renewable waste products. The reasons alcohol has failed as an automotive fuel in the United States on more than one occasion are quite straightforward. While ethanol is a strong alternative to gasoline, the gasoline industry in our country is powerful and generally against fuel competition. Additionally, and more to the point, gas has always been a little bit cheaper. [1]

Discovery of Petroleum

Before the discovery and commercialization of kerosene in the United States in the 1860's, the fuel of choice was a blend of alcohol, usually methanol, and turpentine called camphene. [1] For most of the 19th century, alcohol based fuels such as camphene were used almost exclusively as burning fluids, and alcohol saw great success in this era as a relatively cheap alternative to the whale fat and other lard oils used previously. [1] Kerosene produced from petroleum entered the lamp fuel market at the perfect moment, as with the passing of the Internal Revenue Act in the early 1860's, alcohol in all forms was taxed very heavily. [1] This measure destroyed the chances of camphene to compete in the market of the day. As a result of the federal alcohol tax, petroleum based fuels were in sense incentivized and so dominated in the United States through the end of the 19th century. Until the Civil War alcohol tax, which was still in place in the late 1890's, was lifted there would be no chance for ethyl alcohol to prosper in United states as an automotive fuel choice as it did in several Western European nations seeking to boost agricultural production, such as France and Germany. [1] Ethanol was actually a compatible fuel for most internal combustion engine designs and therefore assumed the role of direct competitor with petroleum-based automotive fuel, or gasoline. In 1906, Theodore Roosevelt, in a move to place a check on the dominant petroleum industry, lifted the alcohol tax in the United States. [1]

Farm Chemurgy

Following the lift the alcohol tax in 1906, there was much promotion, both by the federal government and the national media, of ethyl alcohol fuels as a promising and cheap alternative to petroleum-based fuel (at the time ethanol from corn was quoted by the New York Times as up to 60 percent cheaper than gasoline). [1] According to Senator Champ Clark, who served in the early 1900's, oil producers such as Standard Oil were publicly against the "free alcohol" bill and supported retaining the alcohol tax. [1] Interestingly, automobile manufacturers supported ethyl alcohol as an alternative to gasoline, as most manufacturers designed their engines to run on pure alcohol fuel, in addition to gasoline and any composite blends. Ethyl alcohol was widely considered as preferable to gasoline because it was relatively clean burning and because alcohol markets would be far less volatile than those of gasoline as a result of the the renewable nature of its source. [2] Despite the original praise of ethyl alcohol and its promise as a gasoline alternative, it largely failed in the early 1900's. Fewer alcohol distilleries than expected were built, and as a result of low supply, prices became non-competitive. The discovery of plentiful oil reserves in Texas in the early 1900's re-established gasoline as the fuel of choice in the United States. [1]

Much research was conducted in the United States and internationally on ethyl alcohol, aimed at characterizing its performance relative to gasoline. [2] Many of the technical benefits of alcohol resulted from it high octane rating, which prevented engine knocking (a common problem in automobile engines running on pure gasoline) and also increased the the the maximum operational engine pressure ratio, thus increasing maximum horsepower generation. Some problems that were noted were trouble starting, low volatility, and sensitivity to moisture, though these were generally considered minor drawbacks in comparison to the benefits of a higher octane rating. [2] Despite the significant scientific support generated, forces in favor of petroleum such as the American Petroleum Industries Committee were able to paint ethanol as an entirely inferior fuel in front of Congress on multiple occasions. The result was that the oil industry was able to block up to 40 state and federal bills supporting alcohol-gasoline tax incentives and blending programs during the 1930's. [2] The alcohol-blending support revived in the 1930's following the promising results of ethyl alcohol research (dubbed farm chemurgy)was stamped out not by free-market competition, or by lack of supply as in past instances, but by political and questionable business practices carried out by the industries it threatened. Besides the political lobbying against alcohol fuel incentives and blending programs, some companies, such as Ethyl Corp., went as far as denying contracts to petroleum refineries and wholesalers who produced blended varieties of gasoline. [2]

Gasohol and the Revival of Ethanol

The American petroleum industry saw undisturbed success for 40 years after politically discrediting farm 'chemurgists' and their alcohol-blend fuels in the 1930's. [2] In the 1970's, spurred on by increasing price volatility of imported oil supplies from the Middle-East, ethyl alcohol once again found footing. "Gasohol", as the new blend was called, first gained popularity in the American Midwest, which served as the center of ethyl alcohol production. [2] Improvement of distilling technology, as well as renewed interest in American motorists for a cheap and clean fuel that could eliminate American dependence on OPEC oil, gave the gasohol industry the kick start it needed. [1] A powerful Gasohol lobby formed in the late 1970's managed to gain influence in Washington and guarantee federal support of the gasohol industry, even after election of Ronald Reagan, who supported synthetic fuels over renewable ones, and was famous for his extensive funding cuts in 1981. [1] Despite the positive outlook for gasohol in the early 1980's, national support of the industry became tarnished by concerns over the renewability of its source. 'Food vs Fuel' became a common phrase associated with gasohol opponents, who claimed America's heartland was being overworked and it's bounty being used for the production of fuel, which would only spike the prices of produce. America began to fear a farmer 'mafia'; a made-up organization seeking to monopolize both the fuel and grain industries. [1]

Ultimately, the gasohol industry has survived and gradually gown up to the twenty-first century, primarily as an octane-booster in gasoline, and recently gaining popularity with the advent of 'flex-fuel' capable vehicles and increasing American demand for fuel-choice in the midst of record oil price fluctuations. According to the the Annual Energy Review, Ethanol consumption, primarily as an automotive fuel octane booster, has increased from 7 trillion BTU in 1981 to 1091 trillion BTU in 2011. This is in contrast to an increase in petroleum consumption in transportation from 9.487 million barrels per day in 1981 to 13.223 million barrels per day in 2011. This means that since 1981, the growth of the ethyl alcohol industry is 393.23 times that of the transportation petroleum industry. [3]

Future of the Industry

The ethyl alcohol industry is an older one than that of gasoline, though as an automotive fuel it has never been as successful. Ever since the pre-Civil War tax on alcohol was lifted in 1906 with the help on an anti-oil Roosevelt administration, ethyl alcohol has been promoted as a clean, cheap, renewable, and powerful alternative fuel to gasoline. Due to economic difficulties, political blockades, and fierce adversaries, ethanol never saw the success in the United States that some believed it should have had. Brazil stands as the best example of the potential for ethyl alcohol to lift an enormous economy out of dependence on international petroleum imports and establish itself has a largely self-sufficient powerhouse nation. [1] But Brazil also teaches us that there is a cost to revolutionizing an entire nation's fuel industry, as Brazilian President Geisel and his National Alcohol Program were able to do in the 1970's following OPEC oil price hikes and a national sugarcane surplus problem. [1] Specifically, the cost is the free market principle, which normally would not allow an inferior fuel to take over. As long as the priority of the American people in fuel choice is price, they will continue to fill their cars with gasoline. Without an extreme shortage of gasoline in the near future, it is likely that 'The Fuel of the Future' will be surpassed by a more promising, and ultimately cheaper alternative to gasoline.

© Julian Girard. The author grants permission to copy, distribute and display this work in unaltered form, with attribution to the author, for noncommercial purposes only. All other rights, including commercial rights, are reserved to the author.

[1] H. Bernton, W. Kovarik, S. Skylar, The Forbidden Fuel: A History of Power Alcohol (Bison Books, 2010).

[2] C. B. Gray and A. R. Varcoe, " Octane, Clean Air, and Renewable Fuels: A Modest Step Towards Energy Independence ," Texas Review of Law and Politics 10 , No. 1, 9 (Fall, 2006).

[3] "Annual Energy Review 2011," U.S. Energy Information Administration, DOE/EIA-0384(2011) , June 2011.

Gasoline - Gasohol

Nov 10, 2014

150 likes | 361 Views

Gasoline - Gasohol. Created for CVCA Physics by Dick Heckathorn 12-6-2K+1. Gasoline BTU's/Gal Methanol 116,860 57,100 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 90% Gasoline 10% Methanol 105,175 5,710 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Share Presentation

• gasoline gasohol
• gasohol 10 methanol
• 90 gasoline 10 methanol

Presentation Transcript

Gasoline - Gasohol Created for CVCA Physics by Dick Heckathorn 12-6-2K+1

Gasoline BTU's/Gal Methanol 116,86057,100 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 90% Gasoline 10% Methanol 105,1755,710 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Gasohol (10% methanol) 110,885

Gasohol (10% methanol) 110,885 BTU’s Gallon 1 Gallon 10% Methanol - Gasoline Mixture has 94.9% Energy of 1 Gallon of Gasoline

(Miles/Gallon) Gasoline Gasohol Methanol • 25 23.7 12.2 • 30 28.5 14.7 • 20 19.0 9.8 • 15 14.2 7.3

(Miles/Gallon) Gasoline Gasohol Methanol • 1.299 1.233 0.635 • 1.199 1.138 .586 • 1.099 1.049 .537 • 0.999 .948 .488

That’s all folks.

Can you stop the Carand/orthe Bullet Created for CVCA Physics by Dick Heckathorn 19 January 2K + 5

A 100-gram bullet and a 1500-kg car, each strike a block of wood. The bullet has an initial speed of 300 m/sec; the car, 0.02 m/sec.

A 100-gram bullet and a 1500-kg car, each strike a block of wood. The bullet has an initial speed of 300 m/sec; the car, 0.02 m/sec. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Change in momentum to stop? Car 30kg.m/s Bullet 30kg.m/s Estimated Force to stop? 100(N) Estimated time to stop? Car 0.3(s) Bullet 0.3(s)

Change in momentum to stop? Bullet 30 kg.m/s Car 30 kg.m/s Estimated Force to stop? 100 (N) Estimated time to stop? Bullet 0.03 (s) Car 0.03 (s) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Do you think you would be able to stop the car? Explain.

A 100-gram bullet and a 1500-kg car, each strike a block of wood. The bullet has an initial speed of 300 m/sec; the car, 0.02 m/sec. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Change energy to stop? Bullet 4500 (J) Car 0.3 (J) Estimated Force to stop? 100 (N) Estimated distance to stop? Bullet 45 (m) Car 0.003 (m)

Change in energy to stop? Bullet 4500 (J) Car 0.03 (J) Estimated Force to stop? 100 (N) Estimated distance to stop? Bullet 45 (m) Car 0.003 (m) - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Do you think you would be able to stop the car? Explain.

• More by User

Gasoline Alley

Gasoline Alley Inaugural Car Show Held June 8, 2007 Our First Show We had a great turnout, over 50 cars signed in Student Vehicles Modern and classic cars, trucks and bikes Our Show Included Classic and modern cars, from 1930 - 2007 Classic trucks Muscle cars

1.44k views • 8 slides

GASOLINE TANKERS

GASOLINE TANKERS. A Seattle , Washington WWII Original. Other Tanker History occurred in Seattle . Two Cimarron Class Oilers were Jumboized at Harbor Island. USS Navasota (AO-106) and USS Waccamaw AO-109 were cut in two and lengthened by 111 ft. in 1964.

448 views • 12 slides

California Gasoline Transport

California Gasoline Transport. James Montgomery & Karen Teague. Background. Williams Tank Lines is one of the largest for-hire bulk petroleum carriers in California (Fuel Transport Co.) Founded by Michael Williams

599 views • 50 slides

Non Gasoline Transportation

Non Gasoline Transportation. By Samuel Puckowitz. Bike. A bike, a very common non gasoline powered transportation device. These can be expensive, but are worthwhile . Scooter.

213 views • 6 slides

Gasoline Analysis

Gasoline Analysis. By: Travis Slaysman and Drew Landerman. Urushiol extraction Gasoline Comparison Octane Rating. Brainstorming. Sample Acquisition Standard Creation Sample Dilution. Methodology. Standard Running Sample Running. Experimentation. Spectrum Development

333 views • 20 slides

Gasoline. where did it come from?. Before history was “his-story” Crude Oil (Petroleum ) Distillation process “…a light unto our path…” 1859- Bissell & Eveleth (Seneca) -“River Fire”. Structure. Structure Crude oil derivative Variable, single- bonded hydrocarbon “skeleton”

910 views • 13 slides

CNG vs. Gasoline

CNG vs. Gasoline. cheaper CNG is 40-50% cheaper than gasoline Gasoline: $3.50/gal or $0.92/L CNG: $1.80/gal. CNG vs. Gasoline. efficient CNG has dramatically lower emissions. efficient.

350 views • 18 slides

Experimental Gasoline Markets

Experimental Gasoline Markets. Cary A. Deck University of Arkansas. Bart J. Wilson George Mason University. Evidence-Based Public Policy Conference Fall, 2005. Motivation. Few industries evoke such strong sentiments by consumers, retailers, wholesalers, and policy makers as gasoline. Why?

379 views • 28 slides

Gasoline Engines

Gasoline Engines. Operation. Energy and Power. Energy is used to produce power. Chemical energy is converted to heat energy by burning fuel at a controlled rate. This is called Combustion

624 views • 44 slides

Gasoline. Matt Dixon Jim Halderman. Introductions. Matt Dixon- Former technician and Chrysler Trainer, Assistant Professor of Automotive Technology Jim Halderman- Former flat-rate technician, business owner and professor of Automotive Technology; author. Topics to be discussed.

1.03k views • 72 slides

Gasoline Direct Injection

GDI. GDI. GDI. Gasoline Direct Injection. THE WAY WE PROCEED. Introduction Advantages of Fuel Injection over Carburetor Main Components of Electronic Fuel Injection Electronic Fuel Injection Multi Point Fuel Injection Gasoline Direct Injection

961 views • 21 slides

66. GASOLINE. Figure 66-1 The crude oil refining process showing most of the major steps and processes.

554 views • 38 slides

Small Gasoline Engines

Small Gasoline Engines. Engine. “A machine for converting energy into mechanical force and motion.”. Heat Engine. An engine which uses heat to convert the chemical energy of a fuel into mechanical force and motion. Two general categories based on design. External combustion engine.

552 views • 42 slides

Gasoline Engine Operation

14. Gasoline Engine Operation. FIGURE 14.1 The rotating assembly for a V-8 engine that has eight pistons and connecting rods and one crankshaft.

602 views • 23 slides

4. Gasoline. Hybrid and Alternative Fuel Vehicles, Third Edition James D. Halderman. FIGURE 4.1 The crude oil refining process showing most of the major steps and processes.

572 views • 39 slides

GDI. GDI. GDI. GDI. Gasoline Direct Injection. Presented by P.MEGHANA 09001A0317 M.MOUNIKA 09001A0331. THE WAY WE PROCEED. Introduction Advantages of Fuel Injection over Carburetor Electronic Fuel Injection Multi Point Fuel Injection Gasoline Direct Injection

837 views • 20 slides

445 views • 38 slides

Gasoline - Gasohol. Gasoline BTU's/Gal Methanol 116,860 57,100 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 90% Gasoline 10% Methanol 105,175 5,710 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Gasohol (10% methanol) 110,885. Gasohol (10% methanol)

98 views • 6 slides

Gasoline vs. Gasohol — What's the Difference?

Difference Between Gasoline and Gasohol

Table of contents, key differences, comparison chart, composition, environmental impact, energy content, performance, economic factors, sustainability, compare with definitions, common curiosities, what is gasohol, why is gasohol considered more environmentally friendly, can all vehicles use gasohol, what are the economic implications of using gasohol vs. gasoline, is gasohol less efficient than gasoline, how does the ethanol in gasohol impact engine performance, what are the challenges in adopting gasohol, what is gasoline, how does gasohol differ from gasoline, what is the most common gasohol blend, why is gasohol important for sustainable transportation, how does gasohol fit into the future of energy, what is the role of government policies in promoting gasohol, how does gasohol support the agricultural industry, can the use of gasohol reduce carbon footprints, share your discovery.

Author Spotlight

Popular Comparisons

Trending Comparisons

New Comparisons

Trending Terms