phd thesis on traditional knowledge

Traditional Knowledge and Practices, Sacred Spaces and Protected Areas: Their Success in Conserving Biodiversity

--> Parween, Rana (2021) Traditional Knowledge and Practices, Sacred Spaces and Protected Areas: Their Success in Conserving Biodiversity. PhD thesis, University of York.

While the loss of species is a well-known phenomenon that attracts much needed attention, the loss of traditional ecological knowledge is more insidious and goes unnoticed. Indigenous communities worldwide possess knowledge that has accumulated over generations, playing an important role in conserving biodiversity. India, as a mega-biodiverse country, is home to many indigenous communities who have a close relationship with the forests and hills, is also known for its historical conservation strategies entwined in traditional beliefs. This study explores the differences in knowledge and attitudes towards conserving biodiversity amongst different stakeholder groups living around Jim Corbett National Park and Rajaji National Park in the Indian state of Uttarakhand. The results show that although village elders and community heads are unfamiliar with the term ‘biodiversity’, their way of life ensures that they care for the ecosystem. The superimposition of government policies without any tangible benefit or consultation is seen as detrimental. Alienating villagers who are the reservoirs of traditional conservation practices would damage societal networks in the area and undermine years of tried and tested techniques. Forest officers recommend biodiversity and conservation education for women and children, and highlight the lack of documentation of traditional practices and a lack of their coverage in school curricula. School children’s’ test results show the lowest scores on biodiversity amongst all science subjects. The general public’s perceptions resonated with those of forest officers, further highlighting their concern regarding rural depopulation leading to added loss of potential for preserving traditional knowledge of nature conservation. Biodiversity not only plays a critical role in sustaining ecosystems and supporting livelihoods, it also has ethical, cultural and societal dimensions. More so, in times of environmental uncertainty when the experiences of the living past may not be directly applicable to conservation, its recognition as a tried and tested inventory could be a beneficial resource. Therefore, incorporating traditional knowledge into programs of biodiversity conservation should be explored with a sense of urgency before it is lost forever.

--> Examined Thesis (PDF) -->

Filename: Parween_1080492 CorrectedThesisClean.docx

Embargo Date:

You do not need to contact us to get a copy of this thesis. Please use the 'Download' link(s) above to get a copy. You can contact us about this thesis . If you need to make a general enquiry, please see the Contact us page.

• < Previous

Home > Theses, Dissertations, and Senior Projects > Theses and Dissertations > 2141

Theses and Dissertations

Indigenous knowledge system and decolonizing methodology interwoven into higher education experiences: autoethnography.

Franklin Sage

Date of Award

January 2017

Document Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)

Educational Foundations & Research

First Advisor

Cheryl A. Hunter

What ways can Indigenous Knowledge and Diné Knowledge Systems be useful in autoethnography doctoral research? This dissertation uses Indigenous Research Methodology and autoethnography to make use of storytelling from the Navajo Creation Story and Navajo Circular Model to examine the educational experiences of Native Americans in higher education. A Navajo Circular Model was developed to provide a visual guide of the Indigenous Research process utilizing various Navajo traditional elements. This dissertation highlights federal policies that changed the course of Native American education. The results are in autoethnography that reveals how cultural identity, names, dislocation from home, financial barriers and racism impacted my educational journey.

Recommended Citation

Sage, Franklin, "Indigenous Knowledge System And Decolonizing Methodology Interwoven Into Higher Education Experiences: Autoethnography" (2017). Theses and Dissertations . 2141. https://commons.und.edu/theses/2141

Since May 30, 2019

Advanced Search

• Notify me via email or RSS
• Collections
• Disciplines

Author Corner

• Author Submission Agreement
• About the Library

Home | About | FAQ | My Account | Accessibility Statement

Privacy Copyright

Advertisement

A Primer to Traditional Knowledge Protection in India: The Road Ahead

• Published: 03 June 2021
• Volume 42 , pages 401–427, ( 2021 )

Cite this article

• Shambhu Prasad Chakrabarty   ORCID: orcid.org/0000-0002-7871-7592 1 &
• Ravneet Kaur 2  

9814 Accesses

10 Citations

2 Altmetric

Explore all metrics

As India moves ahead in the twenty-first century to be a global player, it must take a balanced and inclusive approach. Marginalized and vulnerable tribal communities make approximately 10% of the massive population, playing a dynamic role in this regard. Their ancestral knowledge can be explored to inculcate the ethos in multiple disciplines. This would most certainly bring the much-needed balance in achieving the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Where the world is fast losing its natural resources, promoting traditional knowledge (TK) could become an initiative for its reconstruction in post-COVID 19 scenarios. Apart from reinstating the rights of these indigenous communities, this step would also facilitate the economic benefit of the country through the incorporation of TK in the realm of Intellectual Property. This would be a masterstroke for India to lead the Global South. This would also bring in a balance with the Global North, where significant developments have already taken place, in this regard. TK per se should not necessarily be protectable unless based on scientific evidence.

Similar content being viewed by others

Protection of Traditional Knowledge and Expressions of Folklore: Locating India in the Global Framework

Indigenous Peoples in the New Arctic

Introduction to Biorights

Avoid common mistakes on your manuscript.

Introduction

In this study, we will deliberate about indigenous peoples (of India) and their natural conservation practices through the lens of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR). The paper is divided into seven parts. The first, describes in brief, the role indigenous peoples have played in the conservation of natural resources and ecosystem services amidst the crisis. The complexity and misconceptions involved in TK and the difficulties in bringing it under IPR has been dealt with in the second. The third and fourth part unravels the challenges of biopiracy and the successful measures taken by India in protecting TK. The fifth and sixth part discusses the existing laws and proposes a policy that may be adopted by India in formulating the relevant policy and law concerning benefit sharing that could help India to be a leader in the Global South. The seventh part concludes the paper with a prelude to the beneficiaries of this strategic endeavour.

The methodology adopted in this paper incorporates drawing of conclusion using cross-country analysis for solutions to address the challenges brought forth by this complicated position.

The paper is based on primary and secondary sources in this genre of study.

Crisis in India's Natural Resources: The gift of Neo-Colonialism

It is estimated that over 75% of global biological resources are found in the Global South and in traditional or ancestral habitats utilized by Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities (IPLC). See, for example, Oguamanam ( 2013 ). Footnote 1 According to a recent study, Footnote 2 it was found that the world has lost over 90% of large fish species. Footnote 3 The primary reason identified behind this was its consistent demand leading to uninterrupted predatory fishing, irrespective of breeding seasons. Footnote 4 Lack of ecological ethics in the realm of the new world order of economic dominance by the Global North has played a significant role in this and similar others.

India has been blessed with fertile grounds, but modern scientific interventions like High Yielding Varieties (HYVs) and Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) have resulted in an imbalance in environmental sustainability. Studies have shown the adverse impact of the Green Revolution on the farmers and their farming lands. Footnote 5 Mono-cropping patterns have resulted in increased salinity of soils decreasing its fertility. Footnote 6 Such agricultural practices have attracted exponential use of pesticides by the farmers, and consequentially there has been deterioration. Punjab, which was the nucleus of the Green Revolution, now is a nucleus of agricultural distress. Kisan is the true nation-builders, but due to lopsided agrarian practices, they are being burdened with increasing debts and out-of-pocket expenditures on health, sinking them deeper into the vicious circle of poverty and vulnerability. Footnote 7 There have been thousands of recorded and unrecorded suicide deaths of farmers in India during the last two decades, Footnote 8 especially after introducing and implementing World Trade Organisation (WTO) and Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) in India. Footnote 9 “ According to the National Crime Record Bureau’s report, in the 20 years from 1996 to 2016, more than 30 lakh (0.3 million) farmers have committed suicide all over India. A good part of this is due to the impact of WTO and Free Trade Agreements (FTAs). Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) would be yet another monster that would eat our farmers.” Footnote 10  Phase wise reintroduction of indigenous agricultural practices to arrest agrarian distress to both the farmer and the land, is the key for India's progress in the next few decades. Footnote 11 The ecological ethics and ethos are the critical parameters to sustainability inherent in TK, and it is elusive in modern scientific education. Mono-crops needs to be phased out along with GMOs. To give the readers a brief idea of the stark difference between the two sets of agricultural practices, reference to Table 1  is given below.

Navdanya, Footnote 12 an Indian based NGO, (like some others, e.g., Vrihi) has actively advocated for the cause of traditional knowledge in agricultural practices. Footnote 13 It believes in the philosophy of living soil, living seed and living earth, which has enabled partnered small farmers with sustainable agricultural practices. Traditional food production systems offer a possible solution for food security and sovereignty. Footnote 14 Mono-crop cultivation has forced the farmers to buy genetically modified seeds Footnote 15 at the cost of innumerable indigenous varieties. This consequently destroyed the TK of production of such varieties as well as their unique ways of conservation. Footnote 16 Odhiambo states that,

Indigenous knowledge can reveal missing ecological keys, which may help scientists develop alternative agricultural technologies less dependent on non-renewable resources (e.g. fossil energy) and environmentally damaging inputs (e.g. chemical pesticides) than conventional technologies. Footnote 17

Deep Rooted Misconceptions Regarding Traditional Knowledge

Recent lifestyle trends (such as increased use of organic products like cosmetics, food etc.) and health care through the AYUSH knowledge system Footnote 18 indulges the consumers at large, in a fascination towards ancient and traditional knowledge which have been the basis and backbone of human civilization. As more information unearths in this area of environmental and ethical discourse, multiple biopiracy cases have buoyed up and exposed the nexus between TK on the one hand and modern scientific inventions on the other. The hypocrisy involved in bluntly pirating this knowledge, coupled with creating strategies to nomenclate a discovery as an invention without giving due credit (forget benefit sharing) to the people who carried such information for centuries. Parallel to this, by declaring TK as obsolete and superstitious, demystifies the truth behind such claims. Footnote 19 The fact that more than 75% of medicines used by modern science have a natural indigenous origin can no longer be ignored. Footnote 20 More so, the scientists are exploring further on ancient chemicals like aspirin etc. Footnote 21 to make new medicines. Before indulging too much on the relevance of TK, it shall be prudent to identify the significant contrasts between modern and traditional knowledge (Table 2 ).

TK Footnote 22 or indigenous knowledge (often used interchangeably) has been arrogated with various derogatory descriptions like primitive, backward, rural, savage, unscientific, etc. Footnote 23 The reason behind such misadventure is cultural heterogeneity coupled with European perception of superior bloodline which led to devastating torture and murder of millions of Jews in the Second World War and millions more in colonies like India where people died of hunger and famine irrespective of bumper crop production. A notion of absolute superiority has always played a dominant role in both the cases of German annihilation of Jews and modern scientific ideas over indigenous knowledge, especially during the colonial period and beyond in some jurisdictions. It is till recent decades the notion has been challenged in global platforms. Footnote 24 The knowledge that indigenous peoples have inherited and practised since time immemorial have been referred to as superstitious and based on unscientific claims. Footnote 25 Their self-identification with an isolated culture, which is territorial in nature, is intrinsic to their 'way-of-life and with the environment. Footnote 26 But being isolated puts them at a disadvantageous position with little bargaining power when it comes to their right on TK. Footnote 27 Apart from this, TK unlike, modern scientific knowledge, are transmitted through traditional folklores and through imitation amongst certain clans through centuries. Footnote 28 It generally has a spiritual essence which creates a sacred consciousness to it. Footnote 29 It behaves in an integrative and holistic fashion with the view of the world as interrelated. Another interesting, distinctive feature of TK is the emotional Footnote 30 involvement which has been criticised by many modern scientists as baseless. Footnote 31 In practice, the participation by subjective parameters in certain TK has confused even the advocates of TK as a weakness. Footnote 32 However, the strength of TK lies in the long period of the human and ecological interface. Modern scientific knowledge is based on mathematical and quantitative calculations. Footnote 33 It is desirable that the two systems work in tandem to develop knowledge and education.

Innovations from Traditional Knowledge: Biopiracy

The interface “between TK and innovations in the realms of pharmaceuticals, cosmetics, agriculture, chemicals and environmental conservation, which constitute the core of the ‘biopiracy’ phenomenon, provide pivotal sites in which IP, specifically the patent regime, directly engages TK in contestation over the utilization of Genetic Resources (GRs) across different knowledge frameworks.” Footnote 34 Notwithstanding these examples, “the interfaces between IP and TK/TCEs generally tend to be difficult to pin down. In the patent regime, ‘newness’ or ‘novelty’ of TK, Footnote 35 analogous to an invention, is a consistently problematic issue.” Footnote 36 It is literally impossible to go back to the pages of the past to identify the ancestral inventor or discoverer of a particular clan or tribe, of a specific practice. “In the area of copyrights, fixation and publication, especially of TCEs, are perennial hurdles.” Footnote 37 As the majority of such expressions practice within communities closely knitted and carefully segregated from the outside world, it remains technically unpublished. “In respect of trademarks and designs, claims of sacredness—as a basis of exclusion of specific marks, symbols, insignias, or systems from commercial exploitation—remain a source of tension amongst stakeholders (Coombe 1998 ).” Footnote 38 , Footnote 39 In most of the cases involving such violation, the marks are allegedly pirated and used derogatorily by western countries. Footnote 40

Case Study: Neem

Neem ( Azadirachta indica ), a very common tree species of India with medicinal value, Footnote 41 has been the subject of numerous patents. (At least 40 in the US alone and 150 worldwide) All the inventions that relate to neem virtually used public domain traditional knowledge as their basis. Footnote 42 This led to a huge uproar amongst the Indian users who refused to accept this and leading to a challenge of two patents (1) “to a European Patent Office (EPO) patent for the fungicidal effects of neem oil (Patent No. 436 257 B1) owned by W. R. Grace & Co., and (2) to the US patent for a storage-stable azadirachtin formulation (Patent No. 5124349) also owned by W. R. Grace.” Footnote 43 In the year 2000, the patent described above was revoked by EPO due to the lack of novelty and invented step. Footnote 44 Patenting Neem, name of every household, had a substantial socio-economic impact. Almost all rural and semi-urban communities are aware of neem as having a plethora of health benefits. Indian heterogeneous communities were equivocal in opposing the patenting of neem by an American company. They feared the tyranny that looms large which the patent holder may unravel once obtained from the IP rights. Footnote 45

Case Study: Rosy Periwinkle

Rosy Periwinkle (case) is another well-known instance where biopiracy was exposed against an American company Eli Lilly, a pharma-giant in Arizona established in 1876. Footnote 46 Rosy Periwinkle is a naturally grown plant found in abundance in Madagascar. (Fig.  1 ) During the 1950s, the researchers of the company heard about the medicinal value of the plant Rosy Periwinkle and collected samples from India as well as Madagascar. They isolated the samples and tested the two components, vincristine and vinblastine, as unearthed from the indigenous experts of the region. During the process of testing, they identified alkaloids which later became very effective in treating childhood leukaemia with a success rate of over 90 per cent. During the late 1950s, the company started marketing it and especially vincristine earned a substantial profit for Eli Lilly. The natives of Madagascar, who originally identified the medicinal qualities and values involved in Rosy Periwinkle, never got any share of profit gained by Eli Lilly because of the absence of benefit-sharing laws, both internationally and locally. Footnote 47 , Footnote 48 , Footnote 49

World Map showing the sample of neem taken from India to USA and EPO (Maps of World 2020 )

Laws Protecting Traditional Knowledge

National and regional laws protect TK within a limited space, but the impact of this knowledge system is global. TK, irrespective of its local applicability (generally limited to a clan or at times only within a family in a community), TK across the globe has been found to be based on certain ethical and moral precepts. Footnote 50 This homogenous behaviour of TK renders an impact that is beyond national boundaries. Practices like prohibition to the fishing of certain species during their breeding season could be seen as a standard practice amongst all indigenous fishing communities. Footnote 51 Same could be found in protecting coral reefs by indigenous communities by application of similar techniques in different parts of the world. International customary law has been flouted in almost all jurisdictions, and the impact is quite visible today. Footnote 52 Nearly ninety per cent of large fishes of the world have got extinct in the last six decades. Footnote 53 Therefore, international participation and cooperation to facilitate such laws at both, international and national level is required. Shared policy objectives would ensure protection, expansion and recognition of TK (Fig.  2 ).

taken from Madagascar and India to Arizona, USA (Maps of World 2020 )

World Map showing the sample of Rosy Periwinkle

Indigenous communities represent the social and unified ethos of our country. The sheer expansive nature of the existing TK has been inadequately represented in the prevailing laws and legislations. Some jurisdiction has succeeded in incorporating protective laws for their fading TK while some others are losing their valuable knowledge at a very fast rate due to non-protective or inadequate measures. However, a sui generis system to promote the TK has been proposed. This development owes greatly to the Nagoya Protocol, where India is a signatory. Footnote 54

The major limitations that are inherent in the Indian legal system are multidimensional. Primarily, the government do not recognize the term indigenous per se, irrespective of using the word aboriginal once, in a document before the international community. Footnote 55 This position of India in the international forum reinstated that tribals survive but not as indigenous communities. Footnote 56 However, this distinction took place at a later stage as India was a party to the ILO Convention of 1957 on Indigenous and Tribal Population. India supported the document at the early stages when it only used the term Indigenous. In several Government publications, the term Adivasis and aboriginal have been used interchangeably. The current rejection of the term indigenous was developed in the context of the Working Group in 1984 and later in 1992. Footnote 57 Secondly, India still follows ILO 107, which has already been replaced by ILO 169. There are innumerable issues to be depicted at this juncture. ILO 107 was discarded and was replaced with ILO 169. Thirdly, there are no positive protection parameters of these peoples towards their land and culture. Footnote 58 As a matter of fact, there are many indigenous communities in India which are not recognized under the purview of Scheduled Tribes, making the process 'more of politics than of law'. In submitting the Universal Periodic Review reports, India has suppressed the atrocities that these peoples have undergone in the hand of non-tribal peoples and the state. Footnote 59 Millions of these peoples have been ousted from their habitat, forcing them to change their way of life and contributed to the loss of traditional knowledge, their ancestral cultural expressions, language and traditional indigenous farming practices amongst others. Footnote 60 In the absence of any uniform legal framework proposed by WIPO (like other IPRs), TK has not been protected positively in India, Footnote 61 unlike that of Malaysia Footnote 62 or Kenya. Footnote 63

Sui generis Legislation to Combat Biopiracy: Position in India

Sui generis means something unique and exclusive to a specific jurisdiction. Sui generis legislation is passed with specific objectives in mind. To achieve certain protection for TK within the IPR domain, some sui generis legislation came into force to address the issue.

TK and its incorporation in IPR were not simple. To make this happen, two concepts evolved;

Amending the existing laws of IPR and making necessary changes to accommodate TK and its derivatives, and

To make comprehensive legislation to promote and protect TK within IPR.

Many jurisdictions within WTO have made necessary changes in their legal system to accommodate TK within IPR. India accommodated TK both by amending existing IPR statutes and creating new ones. As a matter of practice, the onus for protection of TK/TCEs globally vests upon WIPO of WTO Footnote 64 who are responsible for TRIPS to make a strategic alteration to accommodate TK and TCE. Some of the recent legislation that came up to protect TK in India is “The Biological Diversity Act, 2002”, Footnote 65 the “Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmer's Rights Act, 2001” Footnote 66 and the “Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999”. Footnote 67 There has been significant development in various existing IPR legislations in India like the Patent Act, Copyright Act and the Trademark Act (Table 3 ).

Sui generis systems per se have played the most significant role so far in protecting TK and TCEs in almost all jurisdictions. However, the actual organization that was required to be made to provide worldwide protection of TK and TCEs is that of WIPO. After the formation of WTO and the establishment of WIPO, all intellectual properties along with its derivatives have been regulated by WIPO. The absence of a specific law with regard to TK & TCEs (from WIPO) has been felt largely by countries across continents rich in tradition and culture. WIPO of late has shown interest to investigate newer avenues in framing a unified regulation to regulate TK/TCE as it has done with other IPRs. Footnote 68 Initially, WIPO worked upon various complex and puzzling positions, but no scientific conclusion could be made in this regard. Footnote 69 , Footnote 70

Paris, as well as the Berne Convention, highlights the axiomatic principle that IP rights are typically territorial. “The extraterritorial application of this public domain would also attract the same rules that relate to the extraterritorial application of IP and similar other laws.” Footnote 71

Sui generis Strategies Developed in India to Protect TK

India witnessed significant activism to protect traditional expertise from being patented in Europe and America. The basmati and neem controversy created enormous pressure Footnote 72 leading to some simple yet significant sui generis protection of TK.

Traditional Knowledge Digital Library (TKDL)

With biopiracy being rampant and the cost of fighting litigation to combat such white-collar pirates running into millions of dollars, a strategy was developed by the Government of India (GOI), which took around eight years to materialize and be effective. Traditional Knowledge Digital Library or TKDL was established with the objective of incorporating a list of codified TK practices of India. This dynamic list includes more than thirty thousand medicinal formulations and is made available online to provide relevant information to patent and trademark examiners in offices of respective jurisdictions, refraining from a grant. The data is made available in five UN languages, viz., French, German, English, Spanish and Japanese for convenience irrespective of the fact that data originated in languages like Sanskrit, Urdu, Persian and Hindi.

After this development, there has been a significant decline in biopiracy cases and frivolous filing of patent applications related to Indian Systems of Medicines (ISM). Amidst this positive development abroad, a significant loophole was detected. It was found that the Indian Patent Office has granted innumerable patents on ISM, turning a blind eye on TKDL. Footnote 73 After a review of such cases dating back to 2005, it revoked patents granted, violating TK. Later an agreement was signed by TKDL with IPO on similar lines of EPO and Patent offices of UK, USA, Canada, Germany, Australia etc. Consequently, there has also been a significant economic impact that was felt in the local pharma industry in India.

This popularity of TKDL, along with its success, prompted changes by WIPO. The International Patent Classification (IPC) of WIPO adopted the Traditional Knowledge Resource Classification System (TKRC), a novel classification system of TKDL. “The International Patent Classification (IPC), established by the Strasbourg Agreement 1971, provides for a hierarchical structure of independent language symbols for the classification of patents and utility models according to the different areas of technology Footnote 74 to which they pertain. A new version of the IPC enters into force each year on January 1.” Footnote 75 Another significant success was the identification of 1155 biopiracy claims at various IPOs by the TKDL Team. Footnote 76 Consequently, a lot of them were legally restrained from similar malpractice. Thus, TKDL has turned out to be a very successful defensive mechanism to stop biopiracy, as they carry on their effort to improve the database of 150 books inter alia , on areas like Yoga, Unani, Siddha and Ayurveda.

India's successful attempt at collaborating with TKDL inspired various countries to protect their own TK (see Table 4 ). To quote Piaroa Elder, an indigenous community of Venezuela, “When a seed is removed from its environment, it dies halfway to its destination, and the same thing could happen to indigenous knowledge”. Footnote 77

National Innovation Foundation (NIF)

Alongside TKDL, NIF is another pioneering contribution from India to protect and promote TK. Footnote 78 , Footnote 79 The main objective of NIF is to encourage and assist in the protection of TK. It is a team of experts which engages in facilitating the knowledge holders to protect their innovations in accordance with the existing IPR regime. They provide, inter alia , substantial support in conducting prior art searches, filing of patents to the people who are mostly unaware of legal intricacies that their TK may possess along with their miraculous knowledge.

The Department of Science and Technology, GOI, established NIF in the year 2000 for preventing biopiracy on the one hand and IPR protection of TK and Ancestral Knowledge on the other. This ensures, consequently, retainment of the rich knowledge the land is famous for.

Credit must be given to the relentless effort that was put into by the eminent Professor Anil Gupta of IIM, AMD and his team to formulate the Honey Comb Network, which started its journey during the 1980s. In 1993, a discussion network called Society for Research and Initiatives for Sustainable Technologies and Institutions (SRISTI) was framed to assist unearthing TKs from various parts of India. Footnote 80

The following table (Table 5 ) identifies the significant functions of NIF, which facilitates TK.

NIF has also helped substantially in the last two decades from its establishment, protecting TK. The following list (Table. 6 ) is a few remarkable achievements of NIF worth cherishing.

Proposed Protection Parameters

Traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions are integrally related and inherent to the way of life of indigenous and tribal peoples. The doctrine of discovery Footnote 81 coupled with coercion and deception Footnote 82 caused irretrievable loss and suffering to the indigenous and tribal communities across continents. Similar instances were recorded in the US where tribes were dispossessed of their cultural, historical and religious resources giving the United States “ ‘the exclusive right…to extinguish’ Indian title…whether it be done by treaty, by the sword, by purchase, by the exercise of complete dominion adverse to the right of occupancy, or otherwise.” Footnote 83 India is also not an exception where the Europeans coerced the tribal communities to participate in the Christian mode of worship, as they did in the US. Footnote 84

This divestiture of tribal land by the government implied complete loss of control over sacred sites once possessed by the tribal and indigenous communities. Unfortunately, the government has never been respectful of these sacred places. Culturally Modified Trees (CMTs) of the indigenous people of the United States and Canada are also threatened with the loss of possession. These CMTs are living Native American cultural artefacts which were used for navigational, medicinal, storytelling, burial and ceremonial purposes. Ute community is widely known for making a clock, calendar or even a compass through CMTs. In one case, they have combined two trees with a single slit in between and the only time sunlight passed through this slit was on the winter solstice. Instances of traditional knowledge pieces have been found in India as well, where few monuments use similar technology of using sunlight inter alia for determining time. Gavi Gangadhareshwara temple in Bengaluru, India, is a rock-cut architecture where the sun-rays fall on the shrine only on a specific day of the year. Footnote 85

Irrespective of the difficulty in finding the intercepting point of the knowledge systems of the various native peoples of the United States or Canada, or India, it is not very difficult to anticipate the commonality and richness of the two. One of the living examples of CMT is the living roots in Meghalaya, which demonstrates the uniqueness of India's traditional knowledge systems. Khasi community of this state twisted around the aerated roots to form them into a bridge. Footnote 86 These structures/trees hold sacred value to the community, which highlight their ingenuity and uniqueness. Footnote 87

This loss of ethnicity and cultural rights has significantly damaged indigenous and tribal peoples' rights. Cultural practices play an ideal role to make life meaningful, useful and valuable. Indigenous cultural life enshrines intangible aspects like sanctity, sacredness with tangible things attached to them. Abuse of such elements infringes community sensitivity which acts as an impediment to the universality of cultural rights.

Consequently, assimilation at a staggering pace with a significant compromise on moral and cultural ethos followed. On certain critical junctions, ethical and legal conflicts ensued, which were eliminated with the rod of office. Cultural symbols, patterns or marks created once used for religious and sacred practices were used otherwise (e.g., commercial use or using derogatory to the purpose of such symbol or mark). Culturally modified trees, like other cultural symbols of a community, also suffered a similar fate.

The Ray of Hope

At the end of the Second World War, decolonisation and protection of human rights evolved to be the two major forces to control the state of affairs. Footnote 88 Cultural rights emerged to be an integral part of human rights which promotes the right to follow any cultural practices on the one hand and refraining from harming others on the other. It is essential to contrast universality and homogeneity. Culture is the synthesis of the productivity of any society which is threatened by cultural relativism. History unravels forced attempts of assimilation, a practice contrary to the universality of human rights, in general, and cultural rights, in particular. Footnote 89 Emphasis is required to be given to protect one's culture and cultural choices. Any use of others' cultural practice, which may have an impact, should only be permitted through free, prior and informed consent. Respect for cultural diversity under international standards is also a critical part of respecting human rights. Plural mono-culturism, Footnote 90 which promotes respecting everyone's right, must be acknowledged.

Community sensitivity is an integral part of the universality of cultural rights. Footnote 91 Cultural sensitivity within the penumbra of community sensitivity includes an openness to know and acknowledge the diversity of cultural practices. Footnote 92 Various measures have been taken to create awareness programs, mandatory workplace ethics training, amongst others. Footnote 93

The people who are behind the preservation and procurement of such knowledge should be acknowledged and rewarded. As a matter of fact, they are even bereft of any benefit for what they or their ancestors have done at the enrichment of a selected few. This deprivation, coupled with non-recognition of their knowledge (generally termed as superstition) and their right over such property, has led to the extinction of TK & TCEs from the planet. Footnote 94 The concept of community ownership that exists among the indigenous and tribal communities is quite different from the western notion of ownership. Footnote 95 However, a better understanding may be achieved between the two when it comes to its management, knowledge practice, communicating values and the values we hold in general through engaging with one another with the objective of creating a safe and sustainable world. Footnote 96

In order to explore the ways and methods to identify indigenous communities, it is imperative to explore the conventional method of compensation for past exploitation, which some countries have invoked to restorative justice and the other method being access and benefit-sharing. Footnote 97 The latter has been far and few amongst jurisdictions, with the former predominating with affirmative action.

Significant development has taken place to protect the cultural rights of distinct communities. Still, violation seems to be never-ending, with regular cases of misappropriation being done inter alia , by leading fashion brands.

Case Study—Kente Cloth

Africa has housed some of the oldest people that the modern world is aware of. Their life and culture have survived thousands of years amidst challenges. Their cultural expression has played a significant role in the formation of what they are today. Amongst the various groups prevalent in this area, the Ewe and Ashanti of Togo and Ghana use certain clothes with specific geometric pattern and colour in West Africa. The said patterns, which is meant to be (in the dress) of the kings of the said community, were found to be worn by a growing number of African Americans in ceremonies like university convocations in the USA. Later it was found to be worn in a more casual context. This was contradictory to the permissible use of the said culture.

More and more blacks are dressing in whole or in part in African garb as an expression of their identity and racial solidarity or their adherence to the ideology of Afro centricity. Footnote 98

A stark distinction can be noticed in a series of cases where the appropriation has been done by fashion brands, unlike that of independent individuals, as in the case of Kente Cloth designs discussed above. Misappropriation of an Inuit Parka design by KTZ, a UK fashion brand; Mola Pattern originating in Guna Culture of Panama attributed as Puerto Rican Culture by sports brand Nike in its “Air Force 1 Puerto Rico” model of the shoe; Louis Vuitton’s Basotho blanket from traditional native designs of the people of Lesotho , to name a few.

The absence of an internationally recognised regulatory framework has badly been felt, with the rise in such cases reflecting the vacuum and the inability to protect culturally rich communities' intellectual property by existing IPRs. This emerging danger of the loss of biodiversity coupled with various facets of distinctive cultural identity cannot be avoided.

Losing cultural heritage can be mitigated with positive efforts to restore such tangible or intangible articles or artefacts. This can be made possible with strategic research coupled with the intervention of the elderly people of the community. Various culturally extinct objects can be reconstructed with museum employees' assistance having experience and expertise and activists involved in protecting traditional culture. Compensation or benefits received may also be used for the said purpose. It would also be prudent to invest in documenting the indigenous languages as well. Protecting indigenous language can be the key to the reconstruction and rehabilitation of lost TK and TCEs. Efforts are required to protect the language of various indigenous communities from extinction for sustaining these communities' cultural heritage. Loss of language contributes significantly to the loss of TK & TCEs. More and more young peoples of the clan are required to learn them from their elderly members. The majority of traditional practices have moved on from generations only through folklore and seldom by documentation. With many modern-day indigenous members living far away from their ancestral lands and their family members in such territories, it has become challenging for the art forms to be secured and safe for transmission. Information technology can certainly help in this endeavour, if used judiciously. Footnote 99

One of the recent developments to bring equality amongst the stakeholder and certainty in the law of benefit-sharing concerning TK and TCEs, the tiered or differentiated concept, has emerged, which was articulated in the Draft IGC documents (in Article 3 prepared for the 27th Session of WIPO, 2014b; 2014c). This unique approach intends to structure a framework to delineate the various kinds of TK and TCEs, primarily based on their degrees of diffusion (Refer to Fig.  3 ). This, consequently, tries to identify the extent of exclusive rights that the custodians of such TK and TCEs would be entitled to receive. On the basis of this parameter, the exclusive right may lead to conferring licence on clans or communities to explore such TK. Irrespective of the fact that this approach is not collectively accepted amongst the IGC members. The major challenges being the lack of uniformity amongst the indigenous leaders, scientific clarity of the facts beyond certain period time in the past, reinstate retrospective position prior to the colonial era and impact assessment of knowledge piracy thereof. “The ‘tiered and differentiated’ approach has been received with mixed feelings, including scepticism and trepidation, especially in the rank of demandeur countries and even the Indigenous Caucus.” Footnote 100 It is none the less a fluid concept, and it is crystallizing around the following categories: (See Fig.  3 ).

The four-element of the tiered or diffused concept (Ibid.)

Secrecy and sacredness are associated with strong or exclusive rights, whereas weaker forms of rights are attached to narrowly diffused and widely diffused Traditional Knowledge and Traditional Cultural Expressions (TCEs) since they are available in the public domain. Footnote 101

The benefit-sharing mechanism in place in India is based on traceability of origin. The benefit is shared where the tribal community can be traced. Some of the immediate benefits that India may enjoy by implementing this model are as follows:

A specific positive mechanism would be adopted for the first time in India to act as a standard for subsequent issues,

Uniformity in accessing benefit sharing amongst the stakeholders,

The element of clarity would be introduced effectively,

As identified in this article, India has shown the way to protect TK indirectly by adopting a sui generis system of TKDL. Similarly, it can introduce this system in this part of the world which may act as a model to be adapted and acted upon in similar circumstances.

This would also avoid a multiplicity of benefit-sharing laws and regulations.

This would also enable the indigenous peoples to exercise their rights over their culture, communities and ancestral practices, which upholds the promises under-taken to achieve in the UNSDGs.

The primary objective of the classification mentioned above is to differentiate the weaker forms of rights for the widely available TK and TCEs. This, consequently, would attach an exclusive right (strong right) to the indigenous community, which has kept it secret and outside the public domain. Generally, the indigenous elderly refrain from disclosing TK. Once assured of protection, voluntary documentation of such practices and knowledge be expected. This incentive would encourage the younger members of the community to carry on with their ancestral knowledge as their forefathers. In other words, weaker forms of rights may be attached to widely diffused or publicly available TK and TCEs. Footnote 102 By incorporating this process, access and benefit-sharing aspects could be assessed and be acted accordingly. Once the policy is incorporated, the mechanism would assure stratified benefit sharing amongst the stakeholders. The method has been discussed and accepted to some extent in the Global North but has not been done in the Global South. Countries like Canada and Australia have, to some extent, invoked this method of benefit sharing and have got success. Footnote 103 India, by adhering to this policy, would position itself to be the trendsetter and a leader in this part of the globe. It is imperative to state that the limited TK and TCEs still left amongst the people, mostly the elderly, requires urgent protection and documentation. The young must be assured of the economic viability of their ancestral knowledge. Special measures should be taken to promote these TK and TCEs and retrospectively protect the rights of these peoples with a robust legal framework to implement benefit sharing, adhering to the principles laid down in the Nagoya Protocol, where India has been a signatory.

To address the complicated issue of bringing TK within the purview of IPR on the one hand and protecting and preserving TK and creating an adequate benefit-sharing mechanism for the indigenous communities on the other would be the key. Given the unique nature of TK, this could be done in two ways:

By a law framed by WIPO, or

By sui generis legislation in India, as has been in some jurisdictions

The Beneficiaries

Application of laws systematically would not only help to preserve the rich TK & TCEs of the world but would be able to benefit approximately four hundred and seventy-six million Indigenous Peoples worldwide, Footnote 104 in over ninety countries which makes up over 6 per cent of the global population, and would be able to contribute to alleviating about fifteen per cent of the extreme poor. Footnote 105  The establishment of their rights would also act as an assurance for the continuance of traditional practices associated with that land which is a major untapped source of sustainable agriculture. What could follow is ubi jus ibi remedium , where the question of justice for forest-dwelling communities which have faced the brunt at the cost of 'development' could also be achieved. A systematic re-transfer of land to the displaced indigenous communities with the reintroduction of indigenous species would also help in sustainable development. International practices of community ownership should also be ensured in line with ILO 169 and directions laid down in Samatha v. State of Andhra Pradesh. Footnote 106 The growing movement of these peoples in the modern world has got its momentum from the judiciary itself. For instance, in the famous Australian case of Queensland Footnote 107 the Australian Supreme Court rightfully restored the entire land area back to the aboriginal peoples of Australia. The Indian counterpart to this, Samatha Footnote 108 where the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India acknowledges the right to land and natural resources of the tribal peoples in India. Footnote 109

It is imperative to state that the limited TK and TCEs still left amongst the people, mostly the elderly requires urgent protection and documentation. The young must be assured of the economic viability of their ancestral knowledge. Special measures should be taken to promote these TK and TCEs and retrospectively protect the rights of these peoples with a robust legal framework to implement benefit sharing. Millions of people within the indigenous and tribal communities across the world are facing survival-related challenges, where the adult-youth populace have been geographically displaced, away from their homeland in search of survival and social inclusion. Only those, who are old and not otherwise able to move or work, remain in their village. They take care of the children whose parents have migrated in search of their daily wages. Poverty, discouragement and indifference are social prejudices that label their daily lives. ‘ Footnote 110 ’ Why should this be permitted? Footnote 111 The indigenous communities, however, do not accept the labels that blemish their origin and traditional consciousness. Some recurring questions need to be addressed by the people in authority and decision-makers. Footnote 112 Is it too late today to reinstate the affairs? Would it be possible in India to protect the cultural, social and economic rights of these dying communities? Could India create opportunities for the young adults who immigrate for better lives? Footnote 113 Or would we indulge in cheap politics at the cost of our rich cultural and social heritage? Would we remain silent with the steady loss of diversity, forests and TK & TCEs? Or would we not reclaim our lost glory and help the vulnerable from their extinction. Would we not fight for their cause and help them to be compensated like their Australian and Canadian brothers and sisters? Why the modern legal minds not set up a strategy to combat the evils of policymakers and reinstate the right to life of millions of Indian indigenous peoples.

The significant limitations that are inherent in the Indian legal system are multidimensional. Primarily, the government do not recognize the term indigenous per se irrespective of them once using the word aboriginal in a document before the international community. Secondly, India still follows ILO 107, which has already been replaced by ILO 169. If Nepal can ratify ILO 169, why should India not do so to protect the rights of indigenous and tribal peoples in her jurisdiction? Thirdly, there is no positive protection parameters of these peoples possess towards their land and culture. As a matter of fact, there are many indigenous communities in India that are not recognized under the purview of Scheduled Tribes, making the process 'more of politics than of law'. In submitting the Universal Periodic Review reports, India has suppressed the atrocities these peoples have undergone in the hand of the state and non-tribal peoples. Millions of these peoples have been ousted from their habitat, forcing them to change their profession and contributed to the loss of traditional knowledge, their ancestral cultural expressions, their languages and traditional indigenous farming practices, amongst others. In the absence of any uniform legal framework proposed by WIPO, unlike other IPRs, TK has not been protected positively in India, unlike that of Malaysia or Kenya. In the said backdrop, efforts must be made at the international level to push WIPO to take this area of discourse more positively. In the meantime, India must take all reasonable measures to protect the TK that the country still possesses or may retain with corrective actions and decisions today. Thus sui generis efforts and legislations would be the key to provide adequate benefit to the people who have protected and carried on with these rich traditional practices. The tried and diffused concept of benefit sharing can be the best step forward in India to assist in these communities the right impetus to retain our lost art. This would also assist the country in fulfilling the promise and commitment made towards the UNSDGs.

Within the edifice of cultural diversity, a new global ethic needs to be incorporated, as has been reiterated by UNESCO, which would include human rights perspectives, where there should be a proper retrospection of the alternatives available amidst the atmosphere of tolerance mutual respect and democratic debate. Footnote 114 In consequence, we would be able to achieve, in building the tower of Babel, where humanity, per se, would reign supreme.

Oguamanam ( 2013 : 3).

Neubauer ( 2013 : 347–349).

Free ( 2019 : 979).

Burgess ( 2013 :15943–15948).

In this regard Hsaio ( 2015 ) observed that “Despite their agricultural, economic, and safety, pesticides can also have negative impacts on our health. Many conventional pesticides are synthetic materials that kill or inactivate the pest directly. These chemical pesticides include compounds such as organophosphates, carbamates, pyrethroids, and sulfonylureas. Short-term exposure to a large amount of certain pesticides can result in poisoning. Exposure to large amounts of pesticides is usually more likely for people such as farmers who may frequently touch and/or breathe in pesticides. The effects of long-term exposure to small amounts of these pesticides are unclear, but studies have linked them to a variety of chronic health conditions such as diabetes, cancer, and neurological defects”; Also see, Reinhardt ( 1999 : 149–149).

Yang ( 2020 : 8).

Nagaraj ( 2014 : 79).

Kennedy and King ( 2014 : 1–9).

Biju ( 2019 ).

Perroni ( 2017 ).

Founded by world-renowned scientist and environmentalist Dr Vandana Shiva, Navdanya is based in Uttaranchal.

To know more visit https://www.navdanya.org/site.

Jacques and Jacques ( 2012 : 2970–2997).

Some activists object to the terminology ‘seed’ to be broader enough to incorporate GMOs.

Each variety is different from the other and so is their indigenous ways of conservation.

Odhiambo and Kamp ( 1990 : 3–5).

AYUSH stands for Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy.

Chambers ( 2000 : 221–240).

Sen and Chakraborty ( 2017 : 234–244).

Landau ( 2010 ).

Traditional knowledge is defined in UN documents as knowledge of ‘Indigenous and local communities embodying traditional lifestyles’ IPLC, Article 8(j) CBD.

Supra note 19, at 7.

Supra note 14.

Gernigon ( 2000 : 33).

Bruchac ( 2014 : 3817).

Juden ( 2003 : 313–313).

Li ( 2010 : 385–414).

Sengupta ( 2019 : 146).

National Research Council ( 2013 : 477–486).

Oguamanam ( 2019 : 1–24).

Newness is the sole factor that distinguishes a TK from a knowledge that is commonplace.

Mgbeoji ( 2001 : 163–186).

Boateng ( 2012 : 9), Kuruk ( 1999 : 769).

Supra note 36.

Supra note 34.

Souravi, K ( 2020 : p. 489).

Dutfield ( 2004 : 53).

Some similar experiences are referred to in the work of Will Holland ( 2019 ).

Chakrabarty and Sinha ( 2021 ).

Fisher ( 2018 : 7).

It is pertinent here to state that the countries where the patents were accepted did not ratify CBD or the Nagoya Protocol.

Deb ( 2014 : 123–159).

Myers and Worm ( 2003 : 280–283).

Architha Narayanan ( 2018 : 1).

Chakrabarty ( 2018 : 14).

Argument placed by the contributors, based on the previous fact; Available at: <  https://www.telegraphindia.com/opinion/tribal-status-to-be-a-scheduled-tribe-and-being-tribal-are-no-longer-the-same-thing/cid/1691000  ≥ (Accessed 15th September 2020).

UN HRC ( 2017 ).

First-hand experience recorded by the contributor during PhD empirical studies, for more please look at Shodhganga thesis at chapter 6.( https://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/handle/10603/246918 ).

Acts, the Plant Varieties Act and the Biodiversity Act protects passively and not actively as required to be adapted in India.

Antons ( 2010 : 1189–1204).

Justus Wanzala ( 2017 ).

WIPO and WTO are two different organisations WIPO has a cultural mission and no trade aim, whereas WTO is duly trade orientated. WIPO has treaties that member states can ratify or not, WTO TRIPs is of adhesion and there is no space to non-ratification or to repel certain articles.

The Biological Diversity Act, 2002.

Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmer's Rights Act, 2001.

Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999.

Fisher ( 2017 ).

Okediji ( 2018 : 176).

Public commotion leading to a political outrage forcing the government to act.

Supra note 34 at p 50.

Brooks ( 1994 : 478).

WIPO ( 2020 ).

Supra note 20 at p 49.

Humberto Márquez ( 2002 ).

Supra note 25.

The Department of Science and, GOI, later established NIF in the year 2000 for preventing biopiracy on the one hand and IPR protection of TK and Ancestral Knowledge. This ensures, consequently, retainment of the rich knowledge the land is famous for.

Ramesh Pillai ( 2015 ).

(In the words of Professor Anil K. Gupta, Executive Vice Chairperson of India's National Innovation Foundation “ every time an old person dies a library of information is buried. Never before have we lost more traditional knowledge ." This inspired Project Linkages in Malaysia.).

Irwin ( 1997 : 35–55). Also see, Miller ( 2005 : 1).

(“The United States has imposed several restrictive laws banning the practice of certain Native American religious activities, including outlawing ceremonies such as the Ghost Dance and Sun Dance seen throughout Plains tribal cultures.”)

McNeil ( 1997 : .365).

Banner ( 2009 : 16) and Robertson ( 2005 : 99).

Dwivedi and Saroha ( 2005 : 310) and Vyasanakere ( 2008 : 1632).

Bareh ( 1985 ).

Lewin ( 2012 ).

Morsink ( 1993 : 357).

Travis ( 2008 : 415).

Šokčević ( 2011 : 735–749).

Burnette ( 2014 ).

Winkelman ( 2005 ).

For instance, Mono crop cultivation requires no conservation of seeds as the farmers would buy the GMO seed annually. This has led to the extinction of hundreds of indigenous varieties of seeds. And along with that the knowledge of preservation of those indigenous seeds has also gone extinct as well.

Small and Sheehan ( 2008 103–119).

Jensen ( 2017 : 65).

Reuters ( 2017 ).

Austin ( 1994 : 147).

Robinson ( 2021 : 369).

Supra note 37.

World Bank ( 2020 ).

Samatha v State of Andhra Pradesh (1997).

Mabo v Queensland  (1992).

Supra note 89.

Supra note 55, at p 150.

Rodolfo Stavenhagen ( 2009 : 20).

UNESCO’s International Commission on Education for the Twenty-first Century identifies “Learning to live together, learning to live with others” as one of the four pillars of education necessary for preparing ourselves for life in the twenty-first century.

Antons, Christoph. 2010. The role of traditional knowledge and access to genetic resources in biodiversity conservation in Southeast Asia. Biodiversity and Conservation 19 (4): 1189–1204.

Article   Google Scholar  

Architha, Narayanan. 2018 Domestic Biological Diversity and ABS Laws, Policies and Practice in India. In A Primer on Biological Diversity Laws, Access and Benefit Sharing ed. M K Ramesh et al., Bangalore: UNDP & CELERA, NLSIU.

Austin, Regina. 1994. A nation of thieves: Securing Black people’s right to shop and to sell in White America. Utah Law Review 1994 (1): 147.

Google Scholar  

Banner, Stuart. 2009. How the Indians lost their land: Law and power on the frontier . Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Bareh, Hamlet. 1985. The history and culture of the Khasi People revised and enlarged edition. http://dspace.nehu.ac.in/bitstream/1/7798/1/The%20history%20and%20culture%20of%20the%20Khasi%20(H%20Bareh).pdf . Accessed 20 November 2020.

Biju. K.V. 2019. Don’t drive indian farmers to suicide through rcEP, John Hopkins Advanced School of Advanced International Studies , (3 November 2019) at https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/economy/don-t-drive-indian-farmers-to-suicide-through-rcep-67565 . Accessed 14 October 2020.

Boateng, Boatema. 2012. The copyright thing doesn’t work here Adinkra and Kente Cloth and intellectual property in Ghana. African Arts 45 (3): 9.

Brooks, Harvey. 1994. The relationship between science and technology. Research Policy 23 (5): 477–486.

Bruchac, Margaret. 2014. Indigenous knowledge and traditional knowledge. In Encyclopaedia of global archaeology , ed. C. Smith, 3814–3824. New York: Springer.

Chapter   Google Scholar  

Burgess, Matthew G.., Stephen Polasky, and David Tilman. 2013. Predicting overfishing and extinction threats in multispecies fisheries. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110 (40): 15943–15948.

Burnette, Catherine E., Sara Sanders, Howard K. Butcher, and Jacki T. Rand. 2014. A toolkit for ethical and culturally sensitive research: An application with indigenous communities. Ethics and Social Welfare 8 (4): 364–382.

Chakrabarty, Shambhu P.. 2018. Tribal rights in India . Singapore: Partridge Publishing Singapore.

Chambers, David Wade, and Richard Gillespie. 2000. Locality in the history of science: Colonial science, technoscience, and indigenous knowledge. Osiris 15 (1): 221–240.

Christopher, Free M.., Thorson T.. James, Pinsky L.. Malin, Oken L.. Kiva, John Wiedenmann, and P. Olaf Jensen. 2019. Impacts of historical warming on marine fisheries production. Science 363 (6430): 979–983.

Cole, Shawn Allen, and A. Nilesh Fernando. 2014. The value of advice: Evidence from the adoption of agricultural practices. HBS Working Group Paper 1 (13): 6.

Coombe, R.J. 1998. The cultural life of intellectual properties: Authorship, appropriation, and the law . Duke University Press.

Book   Google Scholar  

Deb, Debal. 2014. The value of forest: an ecological economic examination of forest people’s perspective. In Challenges and opportunities for the world’s forests in the 21st Century , ed. Trevor Fenning, 123–159. Dordrecht: Springer.

Dickson, David. 1999. ICSU seeks to classify ‘traditional knowledge.’ Nature 401 (631): 2021. https://doi.org/10.1038/44235.Accessed10January .

Dutfield, Graham. 2004. Intellectual property, biogenetic resources and traditional knowledge . London: Earthscan.

Dutfield, G., R. Wynberg, S. Laird, and S. Ives. 2020. Benefit Sharing and Traditional Knowledge: Unsolved Dilemmas for Implementation . The Challenge of Attribution and Origin: Traditional Knowledge and Access and Benefit Sharing. Voices for BioJustice, Policy Brief.

Dwivedi, Anurag, and Monika Saroha. 2005. Copyright laws as a means of extending protection to expressions of folklore. Journal of Intellectual Property Rights 10 (4): 308–314.

Ezeanya-Esiobu, C. 2019. Indigenous knowledge and education in Africa . Berlin: Springer.

Fisher, William. 2017. The legal treatment of traditional knowledge. Streamed live on 23 March 2017 at https://youtu.be/z04fHLEOFs4 . Accessed 20 November 2020.

Fisher, William. 2018. 2017 David L. Lange lecture in intellectual property: The puzzle of traditional knowledge. Duke Law Journal 67 (7): 1511–1578.

Gernigon, Bernard, Alberto Odero, and Horacio Guido. 2000. ILO principles concerning collective bargaining. International Labour Review 139 (1): 33.

Holland, Will. 2019. Biopiracy: The misuse of patenting systems at the disadvantage of local communities . CABI (21 March 2019) at https://blog.plantwise.org/2019/03/21/biopiracy-the-misuse-of-patenting-systems-at-the-disadvantage-of-less-affluent-communities . Accessed 20 December 2020.

Hsaio, J. 2015. GMOs and pesticides: Helpful or Harmful? Science in the News . The Harvard University, The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences Blog (10 August 2015), at https://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2015/gmos-and-pesticides/ . Accessed 17 November 2020.

Ip, John. 2017. The legality of ‘suspicionless’ stop and search powers under the European convention on human rights. Human Rights Law Review 17 (3): 523–544. https://doi.org/10.1093/hrlr/ngw025 .

Irwin, Lee. 1997. Freedom, law, and prophecy: A brief history of Native American religious resistance. American Indian Quarterly 21 (1): 35–55.

Jensen, Kyle. 2017. A comparison of indigenous and western land management; Case Studies of Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei and the East Bay Regional Park District. Pomona Senior Theses . 171 at http://scholarship.claremont.edu/pomona_theses/171 . Accessed 10 January 2021.

Juden, Linda Kitchikeesic. 2003. Spiritual link is part of traditional knowledge. Nature 421 (6921): 313–313.

Kennedy, Jonathan, and Lawrence King. 2014. The political economy of farmers’ suicides in India: Indebted cash-crop farmers with marginal landholdings explain state-level variation in suicide rates. Globalization and Health 10 (1): 1–9.

Kuruk, Paul. 1999. Protecting folklore under modern intellectual property regimes: A reappraisal of the tensions between individual and communal rights in Africa and the United States. American University Law Review 48 (4): 769.

Landau, Elezabeth. 2010. From a Tree, a “Miracle” Called Aspirin. CNN Health: Matters of the Heart. December 22, 2010, at http://edition.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/12/22/aspirin.history/index.html . Accessed 20 October 2020.

Lewin, Brent. 2012. India’s living Bridges. Readers Digest. 24 October 2012, at http://brentlewin.blogspot.com/2012/10/indias-living-bridges-for-readers-digest_24.html , Accessed 20 October 2020.

Li, Tani Murray. 2010. Indigeneity, capitalism, and the management of dispossession. Current Anthropology 51 (3): 385–414.

Márquez, Humberto. 2002. Rights-Venezuela: Indians want voice in use of botanical database. Inter Press Services News Agency December 2, 2002, at http://www.ipsnews.net/2002/12/rights-venezuela-indians-want-voice-in-use-of-botanical-database/ . Accessed 18 August 2020.

Maps of World. 2020. World Map. http://www.mapsofworld.com . Accessed 19 August 2020.

McNeil, Kent. 1997. Extinguishment of native title: The high court and American Law. Australian Indigenous Law Reporter 2 (3): 365–370.

Mgbeoji, Ikechi. 2001. Patents and traditional knowledge of the uses of plants: Is a communal patent regime part of the solution to the scourge of bio piracy? Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 9 (1): 163–186.

Miller, R.J. 2005. The doctrine of discovery in American Indian law. Idaho Law Review. 42: 1.

Morsink, Johannes. 1993. World war two and the universal declaration. Human Rights Quarterly 15 (2): 357.

Myers, Ransom A.., and Boris Worm. 2003. Rapid worldwide depletion of predatory fish communities. Nature 423 (6937): 280–283.

Nagaraj, K., K. Sainath, P.R. Rukmani, and R. Gopinath. 2014. Farmers’ suicides in India: Magnitudes, trends, and spatial patterns, 1997–2012. Review of Agrarian Studies 4 (2): 53–83.

National Research Council. 2013. The mathematical sciences in 2025 . London: National Academies Press.

Neubauer, Philipp, Olaf P.. Jensen, Jeffrey A.. Hutchings, and K Julia Baum. 2013. Resilience and recovery of overexploited marine populations. Science 340 (6130): 347–349.

NIF. 2020. The National Innovation Foundation, at:  https://nif.org.in/ . Accessed 20 December 2020.

Odhiambo, Thomas, Johan Kamp, and Ran Kamp. 1990. You cannot fix indigenous knowledge. ILEIA Newsletter 6 (1): 3–5.

Oguamanam, Chidi. 2013. Intellectual property in global governance: A development question . London: Routledge.

Oguamanam, Chidi. 2019. Towards a tiered or differentiated approach to protection of traditional knowledge (TK) and traditional cultural expressions (TCEs) in relation to the intellectual property system. The African Journal of Information and Communication 2019 (23): 1–24.

Okediji, Ruth. 2018. Traditional knowledge and the public domain. Centre for International Governance Innovation Papers No. 176, at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3202976 . Accessed 20 December 2020.

Perroni, Eva. 2017. Five indigenous farming practices enhancing food security.  Food Tank (14 August 2017) at https://www.resilience.org/stories/2017-08-14/five-indigenous-farming-practices-enhancing-food-security/ . Accessed 20 December 2020.

Peter, J. Jacques., and Jessica Racine Jacques. 2012. Monocropping cultures into ruin: the loss of food varieties and cultural diversity. Sustainability 4 (11): 2970–2997.

Pillai, Ramesh. 2015. Linking the Past and the Future: Capturing Knowledge in Malaysia. WIPO Magazine (February 2015), at https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2015/01/article_0005.html . Accessed 15 February 2020.

Ragavan, Srividhya. 2001. Protection of traditional knowledge. Minnesota Intellectual Property Review 2 (2): 1.

Reinhardt, Forest L.. 1999. Bringing the environment down to earth. Harvard Business Review 77 (4): 149–149.

Reuters. 2017. Canada will pay compensation to Thousands of Indigenous Stolen Children. The Guardian October 6, 2017, at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/06/decades-after-government-seizure-of-children-indigenous-canadians-will-receive-compensation . Accessed 15 October 2020.

Robertson, Lindsay G.. 2005. Conquest by law: How the discovery of America dispossessed indigenous peoples of their lands . Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Robinson, Kwame Porter, R. Eglash, A. Bennett, S. Nandakumar, and L. Robert. 2021. Authente–Kente: Enabling authentication for artisanal economies with deep learning. AI and Society 36 (1): 369–379.

Sen, Saikat, and Raja Chakraborty. 2017. Revival, modernization and integration of Indian traditional herbal medicine in clinical practice: Importance, challenges and future. Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine 7 (2): 234–244.

Sengupta, Nirmal. 2019. Traditional knowledge in modern India . Berlin: Springer.

Shambhu Prasad, Chakrabarty and Debmalya, Sinha. Forthcoming 2021. ‘Traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions of indigenous and tribal peoples: The era that was killed and we let die’. In Tribal Justice, ed. Yogesh Pratap Singh, Rita Ray, Suvrashree Panda, Soubhagya Sundar Nanda . Eastern Book Company, Lucknow.

Small, Garrick, and John Sheehan. 2008. The metaphysics of Indigenous ownership: Why Indigenous ownership is incomparable to Western conceptions of property value. In Indigenous peoples and real estate valuation , ed. Garrick Small, Rachel M. Malmgren, and Robert A. Simons, 103–119. Boston, MA: Springer.

Šokčević, Šimo. 2011. Identity and “Plural Monoculturalism.” Filozofska Istraživanja 31 (4): 735–749.

Souravi, K., and P. Rahul. 2020. Intellectual property rights and threatened medicinal plants the scenario. In Conservation and utilization of threatened medicinal plants , ed. P.E. Rajasekharan and Shabir Hussain Wani. Berlin: Springer.

Stavenhagen, Rodolfo. 2009. Building Intercultural Citizenship: A challenge for our times. In Indigenous peoples and human rights: The quest for justice , ed. Subhram Rajkhowa and Manik Chakraborty, 1–21. Calcutta: R Cambray.

Travis, Hannibal. 2008. Cultural and intellectual property interests of the indigenous peoples of Turkey and Iraq. Texas Wesleyan Law Review 15: 415.

UNESCO’s International Commission on Education for the Twenty-first Century, at https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000109590?posInSet=12&queryId=f9897ad1-e31b-4acf-a2d8-e64997ad28ab . Accessed 20 December 2020.

UNHRC. 2017. Universal periodic review—India, New York: UNO, Universal Periodic Review India, at https://www.ohchr.org/EN/HRBodies/UPR/Pages/INIndex.aspx . Accessed 22 December 2020.

Vyasanakere, P.J., K. Sudeesh, and B.S. Shylaja. 2008. Astronomical significance of the Gavi Gangadhareshwara temple in Bangalore. Current Science 95 (11): 1632–1636.

Wanzala, Justus. 2017. Kenya works with communities on Genetic Resources and Traditional Knowledge Protection, Intellectual Property Watch February 17, 2017, at. https://www.ip-watch.org/2017/02/15/kenya-works-communities-genetic-resources-traditional-knowledge-protection/ . Accessed 15 October 2020.

Winkelman, Michael. 2005. Cultural awareness, sensitivity and competence . Peosta: Eddie Bowers Publication.

WIPO. 2020. International Patent Classification (IPC), at:  https://www.wipo.int/classifications/ipc/en . Accessed 18 August 2020.

World Bank. 2020. 'Indigenous peoples', at https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/indigenouspeoples . Accessed 15 August 2020.

Yang, Tony, Kadambot H.M.. Siddique, and Kui Liu. 2020. Cropping systems in agriculture and their impact on soil health—A Review. Global Ecology and Conservation , 23 (8), e01118. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2020.e01118 .

Samatha v State of Andhra Pradesh and Ors (1997) Appeal (Civil) 4601-02

Mabo v Queensland (1992) No 2. HCA 23

American Indian Religious Freedom Act 1980. United States Congress

Protection of Traditional Knowledge and Cultural Expressions Act 2016, Kenya

Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999,

Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmer's Rights Act, 2001 , India

The Biological Diversity Act, 2002, India

Download references

Acknowledgements

We would like to acknowledge the works and scholarships of authors of books and articles we referred to in this paper. We thank Soumil Jhanwar, NLSIU, Bangalore, Sanghamitra Baladhikari, Souvik Mukherjee of CRSGPP, WBNUJS and specially Dr Ana Penteado of Notre Dame University, Australia for their assistance. We are grateful to Dr Nirmal Sengupta and the anonymous reviewers for their comments.

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

The Centre for Regulatory Studies, Governance and Public Policy, The West Bengal National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata, West Bengal, India

Shambhu Prasad Chakrabarty

National Law School of India University, Bangaluru, India

Ravneet Kaur

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Shambhu Prasad Chakrabarty .

Ethics declarations

Conflict of interest.

There is no conflict of interest.

Additional information

Publisher's note.

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Chakrabarty, S.P., Kaur, R. A Primer to Traditional Knowledge Protection in India: The Road Ahead. Liverpool Law Rev 42 , 401–427 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10991-021-09281-4

Download citation

Accepted : 24 May 2021

Published : 03 June 2021

Issue Date : October 2021

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/s10991-021-09281-4

Share this article

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

• Traditional knowledge
• Climate change
• Nagoya protocol
• TKDL and NIF
• Tiered or diffused concept
• Find a journal
• Publish with us
• Track your research

• My Shodhganga
• Receive email updates
• Edit Profile

Shodhganga : a reservoir of Indian theses @ INFLIBNET

• Shodhganga@INFLIBNET
• Mahatma Gandhi University
• School of Indian Legal Thought

Items in Shodhganga are licensed under Creative Commons Licence Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0).

• Skip to main content
• Accessibility information

• Enlighten Enlighten

Enlighten Theses

• Latest Additions
• Browse by Year
• Browse by Subject
• Browse by College/School
• Browse by Author
• Browse by Funder
• Login (Library staff only)

In this section

The use and role of indigenous knowledge in small-scale agricultural systems in Africa: the case of farmers in northern Malawi

Moyo, Boyson Henry Zondiwe (2010) The use and role of indigenous knowledge in small-scale agricultural systems in Africa: the case of farmers in northern Malawi. PhD thesis, University of Glasgow.

This thesis examines the role and use of indigenous knowledge within small-scale agricultural systems in Africa and its relevance in development practice and theory. Using development programmes that have been implemented in the study area from the colonial to the recent times, many of which were largely underpinned by modernisation theory and practice, indigenous knowledge theory and practice is analysed for its role in development processes.

The roles of the private sector, NGOs and the government are analysed, based on a chronology of development programmes that were underpinned in many instances by the influences of the major development theories and the subsequent introduction of the structural adjustment programmes by the IMF and the World Bank. Particular emphasis is placed on farmers’ responses to externally induced development programmes, designed by experts for farmers to adopt. In their assessment of these externally driven development programmes, there is a manifestation of the extent of the resilience of local knowledge to its displacement by Western knowledge. Scientifically proven technologies are assessed by farmers for their effectiveness under their farming practices that take into account a range of environmental, socio-cultural and economic factors. Indigenous knowledge is frequently found to be effective in resisting those changes that are undesirable and of little relevance at both farm and community levels. For farmers, knowledge that is useful and of practical use is adopted, or adapted, only when it is assessed, and, in many cases, this is only after trials have been successfully completed. Knowledge that is of little benefit to farmers is discarded irrespective of its type (indigenous or Western), or its source.

This study forms the basis for understanding the importance of indigenous knowledge in development practice arising from its existence at farm level and the fact that it is continuously being fined-tuned to suit specific conditions and situations, which are in turn affected by socio-cultural, economic and environmental factors. The findings of this study also show that there are many benefits from using indigenous knowledge in development practice that include the empowerment of local people through their participation in development programmes. Indigenous knowledge is also found to be resilient and beneficial to farmers regardless of income level by reducing their costs of production, to be adaptable to different environmental and economic circumstances, and to provide for a more sustainable use of resources in farming. There is, however, a need for further studies in indigenous knowledge utilisation to enable researchers to keep pace with changes that occur at the local level if development theory and practice are to utilise indigenous knowledge fully and successfully.

Actions (login required)

Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics

The University of Glasgow is a registered Scottish charity: Registration Number SC004401

• Oxford Thesis Collection
• CC0 version of this metadata

Tradigital knowledge? Indigenous video games, intellectual property law and the protection of traditional knowledge

Using intellectual property law and video games made by, for, and with Indigenous communities, this thesis examines the challenges and opportunities for the protection of Indigenous traditional knowledges in digital spaces. Existing scholarship addresses the inability the various categories of intellectual property (IP) law (particularly copyright) as they currently exist, to provide adequate protection for Indigenous traditional knowledges. Digital media poses a similar challenge to IP law. ...

Email this record

Please enter the email address that the record information will be sent to.

Please add any additional information to be included within the email.

Cite this record

Chicago style, access document.

• Hughes_2022_Tradigital_knowledge_indigenous.pdf (Dissemination version, pdf, 4.4MB)

Why is the content I wish to access not available via ORA?

Content may be unavailable for the following four reasons.

• Version unsuitable We have not obtained a suitable full-text for a given research output. See the versions advice for more information.
• Recently completed Sometimes content is held in ORA but is unavailable for a fixed period of time to comply with the policies and wishes of rights holders.
• Permissions All content made available in ORA should comply with relevant rights, such as copyright. See the copyright guide for more information.
• Clearance Some thesis volumes scanned as part of the digitisation scheme funded by Dr Leonard Polonsky are currently unavailable due to sensitive material or uncleared third-party copyright content. We are attempting to contact authors whose theses are affected.

Alternative access to the full-text

Request a copy.

We require your email address in order to let you know the outcome of your request.

Provide a statement outlining the basis of your request for the information of the author.

Please note any files released to you as part of your request are subject to the terms and conditions of use for the Oxford University Research Archive unless explicitly stated otherwise by the author.

Contributors

Bibliographic details, item description, terms of use, views and downloads.

If you are the owner of this record, you can report an update to it here: Report update to this record

Report an update

We require your email address in order to let you know the outcome of your enquiry.

• Browse by author
• Browse by year
• Departments
• History of Thought
• Advanced search

(2009) PhD thesis, London School of Economics and Political Science. This study explores the phenomenon of indigenous knowledge within Ethiopia against a background of increasing concern for the sustainability of natural resources. A review of the indigenous knowledge, information systems and innovation studies literature finds little in the way of relevant theories and hence the study applies concepts from knowledge management. In particular, it takes the notions of tacit knowledge and knowledge processes and applies them in the context of indigenous knowledge concerning natural resource management. It combines existing knowledge process frameworks with stakeholder analysis to produce a robust conceptual tool to explore systems of indigenous knowledge. The research uses an ethnographic approach to studying an indigenous community in Debre Berhan, Ethiopia. The four-month fieldwork produced extensive data concerning indigenous knowledge within the community and the interface with scientific knowledge. It also shows the ingenuity and extent of local innovation by the villagers in an effort to solve local problems with local solutions. Using the conceptual framework, developed in the first part of the study, the data is analysed with reference to knowledge processes and the four main stakeholder groups: the indigenous farmers, the government, research institutions and local nongovernmental organisations. This analysis clarifies the existing roles of the stakeholders and leads to a new conceptualisation of indigenous knowledge, and the knowledge transfers between the indigenous and scientific communities, in terms of systems of knowledge processes. The implications of this model are considered within the light of the various external threats to indigenous communities and their knowledge. Item Type: Thesis (PhD) Uncontrolled Keywords: Natural Resource Management, Sociology, Social Structure and Development Sets: URI: Actions (login required) Record administration - authorised staff only Downloads per month over past year View more statistics Cátedra UNESCO de Sostenibilidad Sep 12, 2018 PhD Thesis Traditional Indigenous Knowledge in the Colombian Amazon Updated: Sep 16, 2018 Lena Yanina Estrada Añokazi presents today 12/09/2018 the PhD thesis "Sovereignty of Traditional Indigenous Knowledge in the Colombian Amazon - The Andoke People of Aduche" directed by Professor Xavier Alvarez from the UNESCO Chair on Sustainability of the UPC. The traditional knowledge of our indigenous peoples has allowed them to balance and preserve the environment; it is related to cultural, social, environmental, political, economic and historical aspects that, all together, contribute to the proper management of biodiversity and represent a strategic value in one's development and in the whole of humanity. The research is carried out in the Amazon region, considered as a strategic area and necessary for the world, having a great wealth of natural resources; where, at the same time, there are traditional systems based on mechanisms of government and control not yet fully known, sacred sites that represent centers of ceremonies and spiritual centers to which we are to give great respect, since they are an important part of ourindigenous peoples’ cultural identity. It presents an indigenous perspective, from my status as part of the Uitoto people, around the protection of traditional knowledge, conservation, use of biodiversity and the importance of cultural diversity in society for environmental preservation.These components are inherent to our communities because they touch the very life, being and feeling of indigenous peoples. In this context, I reflect on the history, organization and management of the environment of theAndoke people of Aduche, as an example of a people who have achieved their cultural survival, guaranteeing, through their traditional knowledge, the conservation of nature and cooperation with its own sustainable production activity. I analyze the tools that are the basis of legal protection of indigenous traditional knowledge and factors that are part of the spaces in the construction of identities within multicultural nations, such as Colombia, in this case. Finally, from the research I deduct the matter of sovereignty and organization in the cultural life, the protection of the communitarian spaces and practices, as alternatives for the protection of the collective property, the biodiversity, the local development, the complete survival of our peoples from the foundation of an indigenous vision and the construction of tools that respect and are consistent with this vision; because, what is at stake is the most valuable of our communities, our knowledge, our language, our understanding of the world and the phenomena that surround us, ultimately the legacy that will allow our next generations to continue to recognize each other as different peoples, indigenous peoples. Place: Aula C1-002, Campus Nord UPC. The Doctoral Studies Committee has counted the votes and in accordance with Article 14.7 of Royal Decree 99/2011 of 28 January, which regulates official doctoral degree courses, has decided to award a mark of: Excellent Cum Laude To the doctoral thesis: Soberania del conocimiento tradicional en la Amazonia colombiana - El pueblo andoke de Aduche Doctoral candidate: LENA YANINA ESTRADA ASITO Date of defence: 12-09-2018 Publications Recent Posts UNESCO Chair on Sustainability at IHP Council Week in Paris The UNESCO Chair on Sustainability at UPC at the 10th World Water Forum Tourism, Territory, and Society Conference 466 IMAGES 10 traditional knowledge (PDF) PhD Thesis (PDF) Indigenous Knowledge and Traditional Knowledge (PDF) Traditional knowledge patents: New guidelines or deterrents? (PDF) Phd Thesis (PDF) Bringing the Traditional Research Methods Course into the 21st VIDEO ## PhD thesis writing methods off the social science Thesis Development Traditional and ChatGPT-based (13 March 2024) PhD Thesis Writing Vlog: Day 5 PhD Thesis Writing Vlog: Day 4 Ph.D. Thesis chapter three Computational Methodology or Experimental Details| How to write 9 simple steps for getting the approved PhD thesis title ; Tip by Dr. Amit Tiwari #researchtalks COMMENTS PDF Traditional Knowledge in The Manacles of Intellectual Property THESIS INTRODUCTION Traditional knowledge (TK) is essentially culturally oriented and it is integral to the cultural identity of the social group in which it is operated and preserved.1 TK has been used for centuries by indigenous and local communities under the local laws, customs and traditions. It has been transmitted and evolved from ... Traditional Knowledge and Practices, Sacred Spaces and Protected Areas PhD thesis, University of York. Abstract While the loss of species is a well-known phenomenon that attracts much needed attention, the loss of traditional ecological knowledge is more insidious and goes unnoticed. Protecting Indigenous Traditional Knowledge Through a Holistic 13 Doris Estelle Long, 'Traditional Knowledge and the Fight for the Public Domain' (2006) 5 John Marshall Review of Intellectual Property Law 321. Traditional knowledge changes in response to culture, the environment and the passage of time. It is a living active concept, not just a snapshot of what used to be back in 'the good old days'. PDF Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Values in Ewe Musical Practice: Their PRACTICE: THEIR TRADITIONAL ROLES AND PLACE IN MODERN SOCIETY . J. S. Kofi Gbolonyo, PhD . University of Pittsburgh, 2009. Among the Ewe, music is the pivot around which indigenous cultural practices revolve. Ewe musical texts, the focus of this research, are embedded with and are dynamic in the transmission of indigenous knowledge and values. Traditional knowledge and institutions for sustainable climate change Traditional knowledge systems are not only important in building resilience of ecosystems and communities but also in introducing new and appropriate technologies into the indigenous decision making systems ... A Case Study on Gedeo Land Use (Southern Ethiopia). PhD Thesis. Wageningen University, The Netherlands (2002) Google Scholar. Kasali, 2011. (PDF) Documentation and Application of Indigenous Traditional Knowledge Traditional knowledge has been passed on to subsequent generation through oral means. There are no limited accounted versions of this knowledge, which can be preserved for future reference and ... (PDF) Traditional knowledge and practices, sacred spaces ... While the loss of species is a well‐known phenomenon drawing much attention, the loss of traditional ecological knowledge is more insidious and goes unnoticed. India, a mega‐biodiverse country ... "Indigenous Knowledge System And Decolonizing Methodology Interwoven In Abstract. What ways can Indigenous Knowledge and Diné Knowledge Systems be useful in autoethnography doctoral research? This dissertation uses Indigenous Research Methodology and autoethnography to make use of storytelling from the Navajo Creation Story and Navajo Circular Model to examine the educational experiences of Native Americans in higher education. PDF Protecting Traditional Knowledge with Geographical Indications Geographical indications can be used to promote agricultural marketing, rural development, the preservation of traditional knowledge and cultural heritage.167. To put it simply, geographical indications are signs used on goods to indicate their geographical origin and have the status of intellectual property rights. PDF Traditional knowledge in policy and practice Traditional knowledge in policy and practice : approaches to development and human well-being / edited by Suneetha M. Subramanian and Balakrishna Pisupati. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-9280811919 (pbk.) 1. Traditional ecological knowledge. 2. Indigenous peoples—Ecology. (Pdf) Integration of The Indigenous and The Scientific Knowledge A Phd thesis submit ted to the Faculty of . Social Sciences,University of Helsin ki, pp 84 ... traditional knowledge is at its best when it is matched with scientific approaches. Eminent examples ... A Primer to Traditional Knowledge Protection in India: The ... As India moves ahead in the twenty-first century to be a global player, it must take a balanced and inclusive approach. Marginalized and vulnerable tribal communities make approximately 10% of the massive population, playing a dynamic role in this regard. Their ancestral knowledge can be explored to inculcate the ethos in multiple disciplines. This would most certainly bring the much-needed ... Shodhganga@INFLIBNET: Protection of traditional knowledge as Bibliography p. 330-354. Shodhganga: a reservoir of Indian theses @ INFLIBNET The Shodhganga@INFLIBNET Centre provides a platform for research students to deposit their Ph.D. theses and make it available to the entire scholarly community in open access. The use and role of indigenous knowledge in small-scale agricultural This thesis examines the role and use of indigenous knowledge within small-scale agricultural systems in Africa and its relevance in development practice and theory. Using development programmes that have been implemented in the study area from the colonial to the recent times, many of which were largely underpinned by modernisation theory and practice, indigenous knowledge theory and practice ... PDF Climate change, Indigenous knowledge and food security in northern Ghana The thesis examines how farming households and communities are utilising their Indigenous knowledge and technologies to adapt to climate change risks and promote food security in northern Ghana. To this end, this research applies a mixed-methods approach to explore how farmers in Indigenous knowledge in Sudan: Perceptions among Sudanese librarians Abdelmoula H (2009) Integration of indigenous knowledge into conventional science: Studies on women's traditional technical knowledge in pastoral and agro-pastoral communities. PhD Thesis, Sudan Academy of Sciences, Sudan. Google Scholar. Agyemang BK, Ngulube P, Dube L (2019) Utilizing knowledge management methods to manage beads-making ... Thesis Indigenous video games, intellectual property law and the protection of traditional knowledge Abstract: Using intellectual property law and video games made by, for, and with Indigenous communities, this thesis examines the challenges and opportunities for the protection of Indigenous traditional knowledges in digital spaces. Comprehending indigenous knowledge: An ethnographic study of knowledge This study explores the phenomenon of indigenous knowledge within Ethiopia against a background of increasing concern for the sustainability of natural resources. A review of the indigenous knowledge, information systems and innovation studies literature finds little in the way of relevant theories and hence the study applies concepts from knowledge management. Indigenous Knowledge Transfer: the Case of Traditional Medicine and through practice that makes it better than knowledge transfer in school science where direct. transmission of information is done from a teacher to students. Knowledge transfer in the IK is in the form of situated learning in that it occurred through. participation of trainees in an activity useful for their survival. PhD Thesis Traditional Indigenous Knowledge in the Colombian Amazon Lena Yanina Estrada Añokazi presents today 12/09/2018 the PhD thesis "Sovereignty of Traditional Indigenous Knowledge in the Colombian Amazon - The Andoke People of Aduche" directed by Professor Xavier Alvarez from the UNESCO Chair on Sustainability of the UPC.The traditional knowledge of our indigenous peoples has allowed them to balance and preserve the environment; it is related to ... (PDF) 'Protection of Traditional Knowledge in India with reference to The need to protect the traditional knowledge captured the attention of the international community only recently but the standard setting was left to the national governments.India an abundant ... PDF Traditional Intellectual Property Protection in Tanzania: the ... The undersigned acknowledges to have read and recommends for acceptance a PhD Thesis titled "Traditional Intellectual Property Protection in Tanzania: The case of traditional medicinal knowledge" in fulfillment of the requirement for a Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Laws of The Open University of Tanzania. (PDF) PhD Thesis PhD Thesis - A Collaborative Knowledge Management Framework for Unani Medicines ... The proposed KMF is a significant step towards preserving a rich knowledge domain of traditional Unani Medicines ... essay homework paper phd project resume review speech study thesis