rebuttal in essay definition

• Link to facebook
• Link to linkedin
• Link to twitter
• Link to youtube
• Writing Tips

A Guide to Rebuttals in Argumentative Essays

4-minute read

• 27th May 2023

Rebuttals are an essential part of a strong argument. But what are they, exactly, and how can you use them effectively? Read on to find out.

What Is a Rebuttal?

When writing an argumentative essay , there’s always an opposing point of view. You can’t present an argument without the possibility of someone disagreeing.

Sure, you could just focus on your argument and ignore the other perspective, but that weakens your essay. Coming up with possible alternative points of view, or counterarguments, and being prepared to address them, gives you an edge. A rebuttal is your response to these opposing viewpoints.

How Do Rebuttals Work?

With a rebuttal, you can take the fighting power away from any opposition to your idea before they have a chance to attack. For a rebuttal to work, it needs to follow the same formula as the other key points in your essay: it should be researched, developed, and presented with evidence.

Rebuttals in Action

Suppose you’re writing an essay arguing that strawberries are the best fruit. A potential counterargument could be that strawberries don’t work as well in baked goods as other berries do, as they can get soggy and lose some of their flavor. Your rebuttal would state this point and then explain why it’s not valid:

Read on for a few simple steps to formulating an effective rebuttal.

Step 1. Come up with a Counterargument

A strong rebuttal is only possible when there’s a strong counterargument. You may be convinced of your idea but try to place yourself on the other side. Rather than addressing weak opposing views that are easy to fend off, try to come up with the strongest claims that could be made.

In your essay, explain the counterargument and agree with it. That’s right, agree with it – to an extent. State why there’s some truth to it and validate the concerns it presents.

Step 2. Point Out Its Flaws

Now that you’ve presented a counterargument, poke holes in it . To do so, analyze the argument carefully and notice if there are any biases or caveats that weaken it. Looking at the claim that strawberries don’t work well in baked goods, a weakness could be that this argument only applies when strawberries are baked in a pie.

Find this useful?

Subscribe to our newsletter and get writing tips from our editors straight to your inbox.

Step 3. Present New Points

Once you reveal the counterargument’s weakness, present a new perspective, and provide supporting evidence to show that your argument is still the correct one. This means providing new points that the opposer may not have considered when presenting their claim.

Offering new ideas that weaken a counterargument makes you come off as authoritative and informed, which will make your readers more likely to agree with you.

Summary: Rebuttals

Rebuttals are essential when presenting an argument. Even if a counterargument is stronger than your point, you can construct an effective rebuttal that stands a chance against it.

We hope this guide helps you to structure and format your argumentative essay . And once you’ve finished writing, send a copy to our expert editors. We’ll ensure perfect grammar, spelling, punctuation, referencing, and more. Try it out for free today!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a rebuttal in an essay.

A rebuttal is a response to a counterargument. It presents the potential counterclaim, discusses why it could be valid, and then explains why the original argument is still correct.

How do you form an effective rebuttal?

To use rebuttals effectively, come up with a strong counterclaim and respectfully point out its weaknesses. Then present new ideas that fill those gaps and strengthen your point.

Share this article:

Post A New Comment

Got content that needs a quick turnaround? Let us polish your work. Explore our editorial business services.

6-minute read

How to Write a Nonprofit Grant Proposal

If you’re seeking funding to support your charitable endeavors as a nonprofit organization, you’ll need...

9-minute read

How to Use Infographics to Boost Your Presentation

Is your content getting noticed? Capturing and maintaining an audience’s attention is a challenge when...

8-minute read

Why Interactive PDFs Are Better for Engagement

Are you looking to enhance engagement and captivate your audience through your professional documents? Interactive...

7-minute read

Seven Key Strategies for Voice Search Optimization

Voice search optimization is rapidly shaping the digital landscape, requiring content professionals to adapt their...

Five Creative Ways to Showcase Your Digital Portfolio

Are you a creative freelancer looking to make a lasting impression on potential clients or...

How to Ace Slack Messaging for Contractors and Freelancers

Effective professional communication is an important skill for contractors and freelancers navigating remote work environments....

Make sure your writing is the best it can be with our expert English proofreading and editing.

Definition of Rebuttal

Features of rebuttal, examples of rebuttal in literature, example #1: the founding foodies: how washington, jefferson, and franklin revolutionized american cuisine (by dave dewitt).

“A writer in your paper comforts himself, and the India Company, with the fancy that the Americans, should they resolve to drink no more tea, can by no means keep that resolution , their Indian corn not affording ‘an agreeable, or easy digestible breakfast .’ Pray let me, an American, inform the gentleman, who seems quite ignorant of the matter, that Indian corn, take it for all in all , is one of the most agreeable and wholesome grains in the world; that its green ears roasted are a delicacy beyond expression; that samp, hominy, succatash, and nokehock, made of it, are so many pleasing varieties; and that a johny, or hoe-cake, hot from the fire, is better than a Yorkshire muffin.”

Example #2: Fahrenheit 451 (By Ray Bradbury)

Example #3: editorial rebuttal in the washington post (by eugene joseph dionne), example #4: speech on 50th anniversary commemoration of bloody sunday in selma (by president barack obama).

“For we were born of change. We broke the old aristocracies, declaring ourselves entitled not by bloodline, but endowed by our Creator with certain unalienable rights. We secure our rights and responsibilities through a system of self-government, of and by and for the people. That’s why we argue and fight with so much passion and conviction, because we know our efforts matter. We know America is what we make of it.”

Function of Rebuttal

Post navigation.

• Customer Reviews
• Extended Essays
• IB Internal Assessment
• Theory of Knowledge
• Literature Review
• Dissertations
• Essay Writing
• Research Writing
• Assignment Help
• Capstone Projects
• College Application
• Online Class

What is Rebuttal in an Argumentative Essay? (How to Write It)

by  Antony W

April 7, 2022

Even if you have the most convincing evidence and reasons to explain your position on an issue, there will still be people in your audience who will not agree with you.

Usually, this creates an opportunity for counterclaims, which requires a response through rebuttal. So what exactly is rebuttal in an argumentative essay?

A rebuttal in an argumentative essay is a response you give to your opponent’s argument to show that the position they currently hold on an issue is wrong. While you agree with their counterargument, you point out the flaws using the strongest piece of evidence to strengthen your position. 

To be clear, it’s hard to write an argument on an issue without considering counterclaim and rebuttals in the first place.

If you think about it, debatable topics require a consideration of both sides of an issue, which is why it’s important to learn about counterclaims and rebuttals in argumentative writing.

What is a Counterclaim in an Argument? 

To understand why rebuttal comes into play in an argumentative essay, you first have to know what a counterclaim is and why it’s important in writing.

A counterclaim is an argument that an opponent makes to weaken your thesis. In particular, counterarguments try to show why your argument’s claim is wrong and try to propose an alternative to what you stand for.

From a writing standpoint, you have to recognize the counterclaims presented by the opposing side.

In fact, argumentative writing requires you to look at the two sides of an issue even if you’ve already taken a strong stance on it.

There are a number of benefits of including counterarguments in your argumentative essay:

• It shows your instructor that you’ve looked into both sides of the argument and recognize that some readers may not share your views initially.
• You create an opportunity to provide a strong rebuttal to the counterclaims, so readers see them before they finish reading the essay.
• You end up strengthening your writing because the essay turns out more objective than it would without recognizing the counterclaims from the opposing side.

What is Rebuttal in Argumentative Essay? 

Your opponent will always look for weaknesses in your argument and try the best they can to show that you’re wrong.

Since you have solid grounds that your stance on an issue is reasonable, truthful, or more meaningful, you have to give a solid response to the opposition.

This is where rebuttal comes in.

In argumentative writing, rebuttal refers to the answer you give directly to an opponent in response to their counterargument. The answer should be a convincing explanation that shows an opponent why and/or how they’re wrong on an issue.

How to Write a Rebuttal Paragraph in Argumentative Essay

Now that you understand the connection between a counterclaim and rebuttal in an argumentative writing, let’s look at some approaches that you can use to refute your opponent’s arguments.

1. Point Out the Errors in the Counterargument

You’ve taken a stance on an issue for a reason, and mostly it’s because you believe yours is the most reasonable position based on the data, statistics, and the information you’ve collected.

Now that there’s a counterargument that tries to challenge your position, you can refute it by mentioning the flaws in it.

It’s best to analyze the counterargument carefully. Doing so will make it easy for you to identify the weaknesses, which you can point out and use the strongest points for rebuttal

2. Give New Points that Contradict the Counterclaims 

Imagine yourself in a hall full of debaters. On your left side is an audience that agrees with your arguable claim and on your left is a group of listeners who don’t buy into your argument.

Your opponents in the room are not holding back, especially because they’re constantly raising their hands to question your information.

To win them over in such a situation, you have to play smart by recognizing their stance on the issue but then explaining why they’re wrong.

Now, take a closer look at the structure of an argument . You’ll notice that it features a section for counterclaims, which means you have to address them if your essay must stand out. 

Here, it’s ideal to recognize and agree with the counterargument that the opposing side presents. Then, present a new point of view or facts that contradict the arguments.

Doing so will get the opposing side to consider your stance, even if they don’t agree with you entirely.

3. Twist Facts in Favor of Your Argument 

Sometimes the other side of the argument may make more sense than yours does. However, that doesn’t mean you have to concede entirely.

You can agree with the other side of the argument, but then twist facts and provide solid evidence to suit your argument.

This strategy can work for just about any topic, including the most complicated or controversial ones that you have never dealt with before.

4. Making an Emotional Plea 

Making an emotional plea isn’t a powerful rebuttal strategy, but it can also be a good option to consider.

It’s important to make sure that the emotional appeal you make outweighs the argument that your opponent brings forth.

Given that it’s often the least effective option in most arguments, making an emotional appeal should be a last resort if all the other options fail.

Final Thoughts 

As you can see, counterclaims are important in an argumentative essay and there’s more than one way to give your rebuttal.

Whichever approach you use, make sure you use the strongest facts, stats, evidence, or argument to prove that your position on an issue makes more sense that what your opponents currently hold.

Lastly, if you feel like your essay topic is complicated and you have only a few hours to complete the assignment, you can get in touch with Help for Assessment and we’ll point you in the right direction so you get your essay done right.

About the author 

Antony W is a professional writer and coach at Help for Assessment. He spends countless hours every day researching and writing great content filled with expert advice on how to write engaging essays, research papers, and assignments.

Usage and Examples of a Rebuttal

Weakening an Opponent's Claim With Facts

David Hume Kennerly/Wikimedia Commons/Public Domain

• An Introduction to Punctuation
• Ph.D., Rhetoric and English, University of Georgia
• M.A., Modern English and American Literature, University of Leicester
• B.A., English, State University of New York

A rebuttal takes on a couple of different forms. As it pertains to an argument or debate, the definition of a rebuttal is the presentation of evidence and reasoning meant to weaken or undermine an opponent's claim. However, in persuasive speaking, a rebuttal is typically part of a discourse with colleagues and rarely a stand-alone speech.

Rebuttals are used in law, public affairs, and politics, and they're in the thick of effective public speaking. They also can be found in academic publishing, editorials, letters to the editor, formal responses to personnel matters, or customer service complaints/reviews. A rebuttal is also called a counterargument.

Types and Occurrences of Rebuttals

Rebuttals can come into play during any kind of argument or occurrence where someone has to defend a position contradictory to another opinion presented. Evidence backing up the rebuttal position is key.

Formally, students use rebuttal in debate competitions. In this arena, rebuttals don't make new arguments , just battle the positions already presented in a specific, timed format. For example, a rebuttal may get four minutes after an argument is presented in eight.

In academic publishing, an author presents an argument in a paper, such as on a work of literature, stating why it should be seen in a particular light. A rebuttal letter about the paper can find the flaws in the argument and evidence cited, and present contradictory evidence. If a writer of a paper has the paper rejected for publishing by the journal, a well-crafted rebuttal letter can give further evidence of the quality of the work and the due diligence taken to come up with the thesis or hypothesis.

In law, an attorney can present a rebuttal witness to show that a witness on the other side is in error. For example, after the defense has presented its case, the prosecution can present rebuttal witnesses. This is new evidence only and witnesses that contradict defense witness testimony. An effective rebuttal to a closing argument in a trial can leave enough doubt in the jury's minds to have a defendant found not guilty.

In public affairs and politics, people can argue points in front of the local city council or even speak in front of their state government. Our representatives in Washington present diverging points of view on bills up for debate . Citizens can argue policy and present rebuttals in the opinion pages of the newspaper.

On the job, if a person has a complaint brought against him to the human resources department, that employee has a right to respond and tell his or her side of the story in a formal procedure, such as a rebuttal letter.

In business, if a customer leaves a poor review of service or products on a website, the company's owner or a manager will, at minimum, need to diffuse the situation by apologizing and offering a concession for goodwill. But in some cases, a business needs to be defended. Maybe the irate customer left out of the complaint the fact that she was inebriated and screaming at the top of her lungs when she was asked to leave the shop. Rebuttals in these types of instances need to be delicately and objectively phrased.

Characteristics of an Effective Rebuttal

"If you disagree with a comment, explain the reason," says Tim Gillespie in "Doing Literary Criticism." He notes that "mocking, scoffing, hooting, or put-downs reflect poorly on your character and on your point of view. The most effective rebuttal to an opinion with which you strongly disagree is an articulate counterargument."

Rebuttals that rely on facts are also more ethical than those that rely solely on emotion or diversion from the topic through personal attacks on the opponent. That is the arena where politics, for example, can stray from trying to communicate a message into becoming a reality show.

With evidence as the central focal point, a good rebuttal relies on several elements to win an argument, including a clear presentation of the counterclaim, recognizing the inherent barrier standing in the way of the listener accepting the statement as truth, and presenting evidence clearly and concisely while remaining courteous and highly rational.

The evidence, as a result, must do the bulk work of proving the argument while the speaker should also preemptively defend certain erroneous attacks the opponent might make against it.

That is not to say that a rebuttal can't have an emotional element, as long as it works with evidence. A statistic about the number of people filing for bankruptcy per year due to medical debt can pair with a story of one such family as an example to support the topic of health care reform. It's both illustrative — a more personal way to talk about dry statistics — and an appeal to emotions.

To prepare an effective rebuttal, you need to know your opponent's position thoroughly to be able to formulate the proper attacks and to find evidence that dismantles the validity of that viewpoint. The first speaker will also anticipate your position and will try to make it look erroneous.

You will need to show:

• Contradictions in the first argument
• Terminology that's used in a way in order to sway opinion ( bias ) or used incorrectly. For example, when polls were taken about "Obamacare," people who didn't view the president favorably were more likely to want the policy defeated than when the actual name of it was presented as the Affordable Care Act.
• Errors in cause and effect
• Poor sources or misplaced authority
• Examples in the argument that are flawed or not comprehensive enough
• Flaws in the assumptions that the argument is based on
• Claims in the argument that are without proof or are widely accepted without actual proof. For example, alcoholism is defined by society as a disease. However, there isn't irrefutable medical proof that it is a disease like diabetes, for instance. Alcoholism manifests itself more like behavioral disorders, which are psychological.

The more points in the argument that you can dismantle, the more effective your rebuttal. Keep track of them as they're presented in the argument, and go after as many of them as you can.

Refutation Definition

The word rebuttal can be used interchangeably with refutation , which includes any contradictory statement in an argument. Strictly speaking, the distinction between the two is that a rebuttal must provide evidence, whereas a refutation merely relies on a contrary opinion. They differ in legal and argumentation contexts, wherein refutation involves any counterargument, while rebuttals rely on contradictory evidence to provide a means for a counterargument.

A successful refutation may disprove evidence with reasoning, but rebuttals must present evidence.

• the dozens (game of insults)
• Definition of Usage Labels and Notes in English Dictionaries
• Affect vs. Effect: How to Choose the Right Word
• What Is Aphesis?
• Definition and Examples of Praeteritio (Preteritio) in Rhetoric
• The Difference Between Portentous and Pretentious
• What Is a Compound Verb?
• Advisor vs. Adviser: How to Choose the Right Word
• Solecism in English
• The Difference Between "Leave" and "Let"
• The Commonly Confused Verbs Shall and Will
• Defining Grammar
• Levels of Usage: Definition and Examples
• The Commonly Confused Words Prescribe and Proscribe
• What's the Difference Between 'Baited' and 'Bated'?

• How It Works
• Prices & Discounts

A Student's Guide: Crafting an Effective Rebuttal in Argumentative Essays

Table of contents

Share this article

Achieve Academic Success with Expert Assistance!

Crafted from Scratch for You.

Ensuring Your Work’s Originality.

Transform Your Draft into Excellence.

Perfecting Your Paper’s Grammar, Style, and Format (APA, MLA, etc.).

Calculate the cost of your paper

Get ideas for your essay

Want to create or adapt books like this? Learn more about how Pressbooks supports open publishing practices.

21 Argument, Counterargument, & Refutation

In academic writing, we often use an Argument essay structure. Argument essays have these familiar components, just like other types of essays:

• Introduction
• Body Paragraphs

But Argument essays also contain these particular elements:

• Debatable thesis statement in the Introduction
• Argument – paragraphs which show support for the author’s thesis (for example: reasons, evidence, data, statistics)
• Counterargument – at least one paragraph which explains the opposite point of view
• Concession – a sentence or two acknowledging that there could be some truth to the Counterargument
• Refutation (also called Rebuttal) – sentences which explain why the Counterargument is not as strong as the original Argument

Consult  Introductions & Titles for more on writing debatable thesis statements and  Paragraphs ~ Developing Support for more about developing your Argument.

Imagine that you are writing about vaping. After reading several articles and talking with friends about vaping, you decide that you are strongly opposed to it.

Which working thesis statement would be better?

• Vaping should be illegal because it can lead to serious health problems.

Many students do not like vaping.

Because the first option provides a debatable position, it is a better starting point for an Argument essay.

Next, you would need to draft several paragraphs to explain your position. These paragraphs could include facts that you learned in your research, such as statistics about vapers’ health problems, the cost of vaping, its effects on youth, its harmful effects on people nearby, and so on, as an appeal to logos . If you have a personal story about the effects of vaping, you might include that as well, either in a Body Paragraph or in your Introduction, as an appeal to pathos .

A strong Argument essay would not be complete with only your reasons in support of your position. You should also include a Counterargument, which will show your readers that you have carefully researched and considered both sides of your topic. This shows that you are taking a measured, scholarly approach to the topic – not an overly-emotional approach, or an approach which considers only one side. This helps to establish your ethos as the author. It shows your readers that you are thinking clearly and deeply about the topic, and your Concession (“this may be true”) acknowledges that you understand other opinions are possible.

Here are some ways to introduce a Counterargument:

• Some people believe that vaping is not as harmful as smoking cigarettes.
• Critics argue that vaping is safer than conventional cigarettes.
• On the other hand, one study has shown that vaping can help people quit smoking cigarettes.

Your paragraph would then go on to explain more about this position; you would give evidence here from your research about the point of view that opposes your own opinion.

Here are some ways to begin a Concession and Refutation:

• While this may be true for some adults, the risks of vaping for adolescents outweigh its benefits.
• Although these critics may have been correct before, new evidence shows that vaping is, in some cases, even more harmful than smoking.
• This may have been accurate for adults wishing to quit smoking; however, there are other methods available to help people stop using cigarettes.

Your paragraph would then continue your Refutation by explaining more reasons why the Counterargument is weak. This also serves to explain why your original Argument is strong. This is a good opportunity to prove to your readers that your original Argument is the most worthy, and to persuade them to agree with you.

Activity ~ Practice with Counterarguments, Concessions, and Refutations

A. Examine the following thesis statements with a partner. Is each one debatable?

B. Write  your own Counterargument, Concession, and Refutation for each thesis statement.

Thesis Statements:

• Online classes are a better option than face-to-face classes for college students who have full-time jobs.
• Students who engage in cyberbullying should be expelled from school.
• Unvaccinated children pose risks to those around them.
• Governments should be allowed to regulate internet access within their countries.

Is this chapter:

…too easy, or you would like more detail? Read “ Further Your Understanding: Refutation and Rebuttal ” from Lumen’s Writing Skills Lab.

Note: links open in new tabs.

reasoning, logic

emotion, feeling, beliefs

moral character, credibility, trust, authority

goes against; believes the opposite of something

ENGLISH 087: Academic Advanced Writing Copyright © 2020 by Nancy Hutchison is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License , except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book

Purdue Online Writing Lab Purdue OWL® College of Liberal Arts

Rebuttal Sections

Welcome to the Purdue OWL

This page is brought to you by the OWL at Purdue University. When printing this page, you must include the entire legal notice.

Copyright ©1995-2018 by The Writing Lab & The OWL at Purdue and Purdue University. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, reproduced, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our terms and conditions of fair use.

In order to present a fair and convincing message, you may need to anticipate, research, and outline some of the common positions (arguments) that dispute your thesis. If the situation (purpose) calls for you to do this, you will present and then refute these other positions in the rebuttal section of your essay.

It is important to consider other positions because in most cases, your primary audience will be fence-sitters. Fence-sitters are people who have not decided which side of the argument to support.

People who are on your side of the argument will not need a lot of information to align with your position. People who are completely against your argument—perhaps for ethical or religious reasons—will probably never align with your position no matter how much information you provide. Therefore, the audience you should consider most important are those people who haven't decided which side of the argument they will support—the fence-sitters.

In many cases, these fence-sitters have not decided which side to align with because they see value in both positions. Therefore, to not consider opposing positions to your own in a fair manner may alienate fence-sitters when they see that you are not addressing their concerns or discussion opposing positions at all.

Organizing your rebuttal section

Following the TTEB method outlined in the Body Paragraph section, forecast all the information that will follow in the rebuttal section and then move point by point through the other positions addressing each one as you go. The outline below, adapted from Seyler's Understanding Argument , is an example of a rebuttal section from a thesis essay.

When you rebut or refute an opposing position, use the following three-part organization:

The opponent’s argument : Usually, you should not assume that your reader has read or remembered the argument you are refuting. Thus, at the beginning of your paragraph, you need to state, accurately and fairly, the main points of the argument you will refute.

Your position : Next, make clear the nature of your disagreement with the argument or position you are refuting. Your position might assert, for example, that a writer has not proved his assertion because he has provided evidence that is outdated, or that the argument is filled with fallacies.

Your refutation : The specifics of your counterargument will depend upon the nature of your disagreement. If you challenge the writer’s evidence, then you must present the more recent evidence. If you challenge assumptions, then you must explain why they do not hold up. If your position is that the piece is filled with fallacies, then you must present and explain each fallacy.

Learning Materials

• Business Studies
• Combined Science
• Computer Science
• Engineering
• English Literature
• Environmental Science
• Human Geography
• Macroeconomics
• Microeconomics

Have you ever watched a professional debate? It’s a lot like watching a tennis match with the ball flying from one side to the other, except in a debate the “ball” is a claim followed by a series of rebuttals. One side argues a position, and the other side offers a response to that claim, also known as a rebuttal. Then the original side can offer a rebuttal to that, and so it goes for several rounds. 

Create learning materials about Rebuttals with our free learning app!

• Instand access to millions of learning materials
• Flashcards, notes, mock-exams and more
• Everything you need to ace your exams

Millions of flashcards designed to help you ace your studies

• Cell Biology

Define "logical fallacy"

True or false: Every time you present an argument, your aim is to convince your audience to agree with you that a particular action or idea is somehow right or wrong

What is another word for counterargument?

What is a counterargument?

The following are examples of ____________ :

Attacking the speaker (rather than the argument)

Appealing to audience’s bandwagon impulse

Presenting part of the truth 

Arousing fear

Inaccurate connections

Twisting language around

Evidence and conclusion mismatch

True or false: identifying a logical fallacy in your opponent's counterclaim renders that argument invalid.

There are three types of rebuttals:

• Rebuttal attacking relevance
• Rebuttal attacking logic leaps
• _______________________

How is argumentative writing different from persuasive writing?

Fill in the blank for the template for an argumentative essay body paragraph:

Body Paragraph

Topic sentence (mini claim)

_______________

How is a counterargument different than a rebuttal?

True or false: persuasive writing is open-minded and not focused on proving a single point, and so it's a good idea to include several concessions throughout a persuasive essay.

Convert documents into flashcards for free with AI!

• 5 Paragraph Essay
• Argumentative Essay
• Cues and Conventions
• English Grammar
• English Language Study
• Essay Prompts
• Essay Writing Skills
• Global English
• History of English Language
• International English
• Key Concepts in Language and Linguistics
• Language Acquisition
• Language Analysis
• Language and Social Groups
• Lexis and Semantics
• Linguistic Terms
• Listening and Speaking
• Multiple Choice Questions
• Research and Composition
• Action Verbs
• Adjectival Clause
• Adverbial Clause
• Anthropomorphism
• Appositive Phrase
• Argument from Authority
• Argumentation
• Auditory Description
• Basic Rhetorical Modes
• Begging the Question
• Building Credibility
• Causal Flaw
• Causal Relationships
• Cause and Effect Rhetorical Mode
• Central Idea
• Chronological Description
• Circular Reasoning
• Circumlocution
• Classical Appeals
• Classification
• Close Reading
• Coherence Between Sentences
• Coherence within Paragraphs
• Coherences within Sentences
• Complex Rhetorical Modes
• Compound Complex Sentences
• Concessions
• Concrete Adjectives
• Concrete Nouns
• Consistent Voice
• Counter Argument
• Definition by Negation
• Description
• Description Rhetorical Mode
• Direct Discourse
• Equivocation
• Extended Metaphor
• False Connections
• False Dichotomy
• False Equivalence
• Faulty Analogy
• Faulty Causality
• Fear Arousing
• Gustatory Description
• Hasty Generalization
• Illustration
• Induction Rhetoric
• Levels of Coherence
• Line of Reasoning
• Missing the Point
• Modifiers that Qualify
• Modifiers that Specify
• Narration Rhetorical Mode
• Non-Sequitur
• Non-Testable Hypothesis
• Objective Description
• Olfactory Description
• Paragraphing
• Parenthetical Element
• Participial Phrase
• Personal Narrative
• Placement of Modifiers
• Post-Hoc Argument
• Process Analysis Rhetorical Mode
• Red Herring
• Reverse Causation
• Rhetorical Fallacy
• Rhetorical Modes
• Rhetorical Question
• Rhetorical Situation
• Scare Tactics
• Sentimental Appeals
• Situational Irony
• Slippery Slope
• Spatial Description
• Straw Man Argument
• Subject Consistency
• Subjective Description
• Tactile Description
• Tense Consistency
• Tone and Word Choice
• Transitions
• Twisting the Language Around
• Unstated Assumption
• Verbal Irony
• Visual Description
• Rhetorical Analysis Essay
• Single Paragraph Essay
• Sociolinguistics
• Summary Text
• Synthesis Essay
• Textual Analysis

Fig. 1 - A rebuttal is an essential part of debate and integral to meaningful discourse on disputed topics.

Rebuttal Definition

Every time you present an argument , your aim is to convince your audience to agree with you that a particular action or idea is somehow right or wrong.

Here’s an example of a potential argument : “The Oxford comma makes language easier to understand, so everyone should use it in their writing.”

An argument, by definition , is a perspective on a topic that has an opposing point of view. So by taking a stance and presenting an argument on a topic or issue, you must acknowledge there is an opposite perspective, ready with a counterargument (or counterclaim).

Here’s a potential counterargument to the above argument: “The Oxford comma is unnecessary and takes more effort to include, so it should not be required in composition.”

Because you know there is always a counterargument to your argument, it’s wise to prepare a rebuttal to any potential differing perspectives that are likely to arise out of the conversation. A rebuttal is a response to someone’s counterclaim about an original argument.

Here’s a rebuttal to the counterargument from above: “Without the Oxford comma, the meaning of a message can be confused, resulting in a breakdown in communication. For example, the statement , ‘I invited my parents, Thomas and Carol’ could be the speaker addressing two people named Thomas and Carol, or Thomas and Carol could be two people who were invited to the party in addition to the speaker’s parents.”

Concession: Counterclaim and Rebuttal

To compose a thorough argument, you should consider the counterclaims that are likely to arise in response to your claim and include a rebuttal in your concession .

• A concession is an argumentative strategy where the speaker or writer addresses a point made by their opponent.

Whether you’re writing an argumentative essay or writing out a debate, the concession is the section of your argument that you devote to acknowledging the opposing argument(s).

A concession is not necessary to make a solid argument; you could argue your point completely and logically without one. However, a concession will build your credibility as an authority on the topic because it demonstrates that you thought about the issue globally. By simply recognizing that there are other perspectives in the discussion at hand, the speaker or writer shows themselves to be a mature, well-rounded thinker who is trustworthy. In this case, the audience is more likely to agree with your stance.

In a concession, you might simply acknowledge the major opposing argument, or you might also offer a rebuttal.

How to Include a Rebuttal in a Concession

If you feel your audience might be likely to side with your opposition, you can use your rebuttal to either offer additional evidence that your argument is more valid, or to help the audience see the error in your opponent’s claims.

Fig. 2- Concession is a literary device used in argumentative writing and is a hallmark of a conscientious thinker.

To illustrate the inaccuracy of the counterargument, try offering evidence that makes the counterargument impossible or unlikely. If there is any data or factual evidence to suggest that the opposing side’s claim isn’t likely to be true or even possible, then include that information in your rebuttal.

In chapter 20 of To Kill a Mockingbird (1960) , readers find Atticus Finch in the courtroom arguing on Tom Robinson's behalf against charges of the rape of Mayella Ewell. Here he provides evidence against the claim—that Tom Robinson can only use his right hand, when the attacker used mostly his left.

What did her father do? We don’t know, but there is circumstantial evidence to indicate that Mayella Ewell was beaten savagely by someone who led most exclusively with his left. We do know in part what Mr. Ewell did: he did what any God-fearing, preserving, respectable white man would do under circumstances—he swore a warrant, no doubt signing with his left hand, and Tom Robinson now sits before you, having taken the oath with the only good hand he possesses—his right hand.

You can also point out any flaws in reasoning ; start at the beginning of the conversation and follow the steps one would have to take to reach the conclusion they’re suggesting. Did you come across any inductive or deductive flaws?

Inductive reasoning is a method of drawing conclusions that looks at individual factors to form a generalization.

Deductive reasoning starts out with a general principle and uses that to draw a specific logical conclusion.

You can also attack the logic of the counterargument. Does the opposition use a logical fallacy to make their claim?

A logical fallacy is the use of faulty or incorrect reasoning in the construction of an argument. Logical fallacies are often used to bolster an argument, but will actually render the argument invalid because all logical fallacies are non sequiturs—an argument with a conclusion that doesn’t follow logically from what came before.

Here are a few ways that logical fallacies are often used in an argument:

Attacking the speaker (rather than the argument )

Appealing to audience’s bandwagon impulse

Presenting part of the truth

If you can identify any of these fallacies in the counterargument of your opposition, you can bring this up in your rebuttal. This will render your opponent’s argument invalid, or at the very least weaken it.

Types of Rebuttal and Examples

There are three different types of rebuttals you can use to argue against the counterclaims posed by your opponent: your rebuttal can attack assumptions, relevance, or logic leaps.

Rebuttal Attacking Assumptions

In this type of rebuttal, the key is to point out flaws regarding unfair or unwise assumptions in the other argument. For example, imagine you’re writing an argument that age appropriate video games are a safe and fun pastime for kids, but your opponent says video games have caused a rise in violent behavior in children. Your rebuttal could look like this:

“While some people argue that video games have caused children to behave with more violence, there are no studies that have proved a cause and effect relationship between the two. Those who would argue against video games are actually pointing out a correlation between violence and video game use, but a correlation is not the same as cause and effect.”

This rebuttal attacks the assumptions (i.e. video games cause violent behavior) at the foundation of the counterargument posed.

Rebuttal Attacking Relevance

The next type of rebuttal attacks the relevance of the opponent’s counterargument. If you can point out that the counterclaim is irrelevant to your original argument, then you can render it useless.

For instance, say you’re arguing that homework doesn’t promote learning in students. The opposing argument might be that homework doesn’t take that much time. Your rebuttal could be:

“The question at hand is not how convenient is homework, but rather does it promote student learning? Spare time is important, but it has no direct bearing on student educational outcomes.”

The counterclaim is irrelevant, and so the best rebuttal here is to point out that fact .

Rebuttal Attacking Logic Leap

The last type of rebuttal attacks the lack of logical links an argument uses to get to its conclusion. For example, say you're arguing that there should not be a universal language that everyone speaks around the world, but your opposition says that there should be a universal language because many governmental officials around the globe already speak English.

“There is no link between the use of English in governmental officials and implementing a single language for every citizen of every country. First, English was never mentioned as a potential for the universal language. Second, the language and education of dignitaries do not always represent that of the citizens of their nation.”

The counterargument took a leap in logic to suggest that English might be the global language, when the original argument hadn’t mentioned English at all. The counterargument also takes a logical leap in supposing that just because a representative of a country speaks a particular language means that the average citizen speaks it as well.

Rebuttal in an Argumentative Essay

The goal of writing an argumentative essay is to get your reader to agree with your stance on a particular topic.

Rebuttals are important to argumentative writing because they give you the opportunity to address those other perspectives and prove that you are a fair-minded authority on the subject. Rebuttals also offer an opportunity to voice your response as to why they claims of the opposition are not true or accurate.

An argumentative essay is composed of a main argument (also known as a thesis statement ) which is supported by smaller ideas or claims. Each of these mini claims is made into the subject of a body paragraph of the essay. Below is an example of a how a body paragraph of an argumentative essay is constructed:

Acknowledge counterclaim

You can include a rebuttal after acknowledging the counterclaim to the point made in the topic sentence of the body paragraph. You can do this for every counterclaim you feel is important to address.

Rebuttal in a Persuasive Essay

The goal of writing a persuasive essay is to get your reader to agree that your point is valid and deserves consideration. The goal of persuasive writing is more single-minded than argumentative writing, so including a concession is less constructive.

Rather than including a concession for each smaller claim in your essay, you might consider only including a concession for the main claim, and only doing so if it is crucial to convince your audience that your claim is more valid. You could devote a short paragraph to the concession of your main point, or add it to your conclusion.

Be sure to allow space for discussion of the topic, though. Don't just acknowledge the counterclaim and forget to offer your rebuttal. Remember, your rebuttal is the opportunity to let your argument stand up to its counterarguments, so take advantage of the opportunity.

Rebuttals - Key takeaways

• A rebuttal is a response to someone’s counterclaim about an original argument.
• To compose a thorough argument, you should consider the counterclaims that are likely to arise in response to your claim and include a rebuttal in your concession.
• A rebuttal can attack assumptions, leaps in logic, and relevance in the counterarguments.
• Use a rebuttal in an argumentative essay to discuss any counterclaims to support your main claim.
• Use a rebuttal in a persuasive essay to discuss a counterclaim to your main claim.

Flashcards in Rebuttals 20

A logical fallacy is the use of faulty or incorrect reasoning in the construction of an argument. 

Counterclaim

A counterargument is what the opposition is arguing about your topic. 

Types of logical fallacies

Learn with 20 Rebuttals flashcards in the free Vaia app

We have 14,000 flashcards about Dynamic Landscapes.

Already have an account? Log in

Frequently Asked Questions about Rebuttals

What is a rebuttal?

A rebuttal is a response to someone’s counterclaim about an original argument. 

What is a rebuttal in persuasive writing?

In persuasive writing, a rebuttal is a part of the writer’s concession. The rebuttal is the writer’s response to the counterclaim about their initial argument. 

What is the difference between a counterclaim and a rebuttal?

The difference between a counterclaim and a rebuttal is that a rebuttal is the response to a counterclaim. The counterclaim is the response to the initial claim or argument.

How to write a rebuttal paragraph in an argumentative essay?

To write a rebuttal in an argumentative essay, start with a topic sentence that introduces the claim for the paragraph and include a concession, or mention possible counterclaims to your claim. Conclude with your rebuttal to the counterclaim(s). 

Can your counterclaim and rebuttal be in the same paragraph?

Yes, your counterclaim to other claims can be in the same paragraph as your rebuttal.

Test your knowledge with multiple choice flashcards

True or false: identifying a logical fallacy in your opponent's counterclaim renders that argument invalid.

A concession contains a mention of the counterargument and often also a _________. 

Join the Vaia App and learn efficiently with millions of flashcards and more!

Keep learning, you are doing great.

Discover learning materials with the free Vaia app

Vaia is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.

Vaia Editorial Team

Team English Teachers

• 11 minutes reading time
• Checked by Vaia Editorial Team

Study anywhere. Anytime.Across all devices.

Create a free account to save this explanation..

Save explanations to your personalised space and access them anytime, anywhere!

By signing up, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy of Vaia.

Sign up to highlight and take notes. It’s 100% free.

Join over 22 million students in learning with our Vaia App

The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place

• Flashcards & Quizzes
• AI Study Assistant
• Study Planner
• Smart Note-Taking

Privacy Overview

Get unlimited access with a free vaia account..

• Instant access to millions of learning materials.
• Flashcards, notes, mock-exams, AI tools and more.
• Everything you need to ace your exams.

• More from M-W
• To save this word, you'll need to log in. Log In

Definition of rebuttal

• confutation
• disconfirmation

Examples of rebuttal in a Sentence

These examples are programmatically compiled from various online sources to illustrate current usage of the word 'rebuttal.' Any opinions expressed in the examples do not represent those of Merriam-Webster or its editors. Send us feedback about these examples.

Word History

1830, in the meaning defined above

Articles Related to rebuttal

The Words of the Week - 4/30/21

Some of the words that defined the week ending April 30, 2021

Dictionary Entries Near rebuttal

Cite this entry.

“Rebuttal.” Merriam-Webster.com Dictionary , Merriam-Webster, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/rebuttal. Accessed 1 Aug. 2024.

Kids Definition

Kids definition of rebuttal, legal definition, legal definition of rebuttal, more from merriam-webster on rebuttal.

Nglish: Translation of rebuttal for Spanish Speakers

Britannica English: Translation of rebuttal for Arabic Speakers

Subscribe to America's largest dictionary and get thousands more definitions and advanced search—ad free!

Can you solve 4 words at once?

Word of the day.

See Definitions and Examples »

Get Word of the Day daily email!

Popular in Grammar & Usage

Plural and possessive names: a guide, your vs. you're: how to use them correctly, every letter is silent, sometimes: a-z list of examples, more commonly mispronounced words, how to use em dashes (—), en dashes (–) , and hyphens (-), popular in wordplay, it's a scorcher words for the summer heat, flower etymologies for your spring garden, 12 star wars words, 8 words for lesser-known musical instruments, birds say the darndest things, games & quizzes.

• Skip to primary navigation
• Skip to main content
• Skip to primary sidebar
• Skip to footer

Dianna Radcliff

Teaching Upper Elementary & more

How to Teach Claims, Counterclaims and Rebuttals in Writing!

July 29, 2019 by Dianna Radcliff

Teaching claims, counterclaims and rebuttals in writing can improve a students opinion or argumentative essay.

This post will explain how I teach claims, counterclaims and rebuttals in writing.

To begin, let’s clarify the meaning of the following terms when giving instruction:

• Counterclaim

What is a Counterclaim?

A counterclaim is a claim used to rebut a previous claim.

A claim is the main argument. A counterclaim is the opposite of the claim, or argument.

What is a Rebuttal?

A rebuttal is when you address and challenge a claim by disapproving it.

After you have stated your counterclaim in an argument, you add your rebuttal to why you disapprove it. The goal is to weaken the main argument with your reasons and evidence.

What is a Reason?

A reason tells why a claim is made. Followed by supporting evidence.

What is Evidence?

Evidence is the facts or research to support the claim and reason.

Mini Lesson:

What to Prepare in advance:

• Download, print, cut, laminate and attach to sticks the FREE resource below.
• Write or type examples of a claim, counterclaim and rebuttal then cut up. This is for the acting out part. (see image below as an example)
• Find additional examples via student work pieces, articles or in texts to share and color code. You can share on another anchor chart, display on your SmartBoard or simply read aloud.

• Introduce the lesson by creating an anchor chart. (See below example or search online.)
• Using the colors in my example below, or your own colors, share examples from student pieces, articles or in texts you have found. You can share these examples on another anchor chart, display on your SmartBoard or simply read aloud.
• Using the stick bubbles in the FREE resource below, have 3 volunteers come up to demonstrate. Line students up in order and have them read their part holding up the stick bubble when speaking.

Anchor Chart Examples:

***Click on the Anchor Chart images to find more anchor charts you can use in your classroom!

Where to insert a Counterclaim?

When modeling, show students examples of inserting a counterclaim inside a body paragraph following reasons and evidence.

Where to insert a Rebuttal?

When modeling, show students examples of inserting a rebuttal following a counterclaim inside a body paragraph. Always use reasons and evidence.

Free Resource to Download:

More Helpful Essay Writing Resources:

• FREE Essay Planning Pages
• FREE Paragraph Writing Rubric
• FREE Paragraph Writing for an Essay Graphic Organizers (Color Coded)
• FREE Essay Writing Timing Slides
• Essay Writing Test Prep PowerPoint
• Essay Writing Sources and Prompts

***Click HERE or on the photo below to Download your FREE Resource! Simply print on colored paper (or cardstock) and then laminate!

Thank you for subscribing!

Share this:

How to Write a Rebuttal Essay — An Easy Guide to Follow

Ever wondered how to write a rebuttal essay? Face this academic assignment for the first time and can’t find an understandable guide to follow? Don’t worry because here you’ll find a detailed guideline allowing you to set the record straight and understand what tips to follow while writing. We’ll take a look at all the aspects of writing, check what rebuttal in an essay is and list all tips to follow.

What Is a Rebuttal in an Essay — Simple Explanation

Academicians also call this form of writing a counter-argument essay. Its principal mission is to respond to some points made by a person. If you render a decision to answer one or another argument, you should present a rebuttal which is also known as a counter-argument. Otherwise stated, it is a simple attempt to disprove some statements by suggesting a counter-argument.

At a glance, this task seems to be quite challenging. However, rebuttal argument essay writing doesn’t take a massive amount of time. You just need to air your personal opinion on one or another situation.

Related essays:

• Economic recession essay
• Hamlet & formal structure
• The counter revolution and the 1960s essay
• Viacom Strategic Analysis essay

Nevertheless, your viewpoint should be based on your research and comprise a strong thesis statement. An excellent essay can even change the opinion of the intended audience. Thus, you need to be very attentive while writing and use only strong and double-checked arguments.

How to Do a Rebuttal in an Essay — Useful Tutorial

Firstly, you should conduct simple research before you start expressing your ideas. Don’t tend to procrastinate this task because it is tough to organize your thoughts when your deadline is dangerously close. If you don’t have a desire to spend the whole night poring over the books, it is better to start processing the literature as soon as possible. It would be great if you subdivide this task into a few sections. As a result, it will be easier to work!

The majority of academicians have not the slightest idea how to answer the question of how to start a rebuttal in an essay. In sober fact, you need to start with a strong introduction, comprising a thesis statement. Besides, your introductory part should explain what particular situation you are going to discuss. Your core audience should look it through and immediately understand what position you desire to explore.

You should create a list of claims and build your essay structure in the way allowing you to explain each claim one by one. Writing a rebuttal essay, you should follow a pre-written outline. As a result, you won’t face difficulties with the structure.

For instance, there is a particular situation, and you don’t agree with it. You wish to prove the targeted audience that your idea is correct. In this scenario, you need to state your opinion in a thesis statement and list all counter-arguments one by one.

Each rebuttal paragraph should be short and complete. Besides, you should avoid making too general statements because your targeted audience won’t understand what you mean. If you wish to air your proof-point, you should try to make more precise arguments. As a result, your readers won’t face difficulties trying to understand what you mean.

Rebuttal Essay Outline — Why Should You Create It

As well as any other academic paper, this one also should have a plan to follow. Your rebuttal essay outline is a sterling opportunity to organize your thoughts and create an approximate plan to follow. Commonly, your outline should look like this:

• Short but informative introduction with a thesis statement (just a few sentences).
• 3 or 5 body paragraphs presenting all counter-arguments.
• Strong conclusion where you should repeat your opinion once again.

For you not to forget some ideas, we highly recommend writing a list of all claims you wish to discuss in all paragraphs. Even if you are a seasoned writer who is engaged in this area and deals with creative assignments on a rolling basis, you won’t regret it. You’ll spend a few minutes creating the outline, but the general content of your essay will be considerably better.

Top-7 Rebuttal Essay Topics for Students

If you really can’t render a correct decision and pick a worthy topic, look through the rebuttal essay ideas published below. You can’t go wrong if you choose one of the below-listed ideas:

• Is it necessary to sentence juveniles to life imprisonment?
• Why are electro cars better for the environment?
• Distance learning is more effective than the traditional approach to education.
• Why should animal testing be forbidden?
• Modern drones can help police solve the crimes faster.
• Why should smoking marijuana be prohibited?
• Why should the screentime of kids be limited?

We hope our tips will help you catch the inspiration and create a compelling essay which will make your audience think of the discussed problem and even change their minds.

• Cambridge Dictionary +Plus

Meaning of rebuttal in English

Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio

• burst someone's bubble idiom
• contradictorily
• counter-argue
• make (a) nonsense of something idiom
• myth-buster
• myth-busting
• non-acceptance
• non-recognition
• speak for yourself idiom

rebuttal | Intermediate English

Rebuttal | business english, examples of rebuttal, translations of rebuttal.

Get a quick, free translation!

Word of the Day

short for virtual actor: an image of an actor created by a computer, used for example in a computer game or instead of a real actor in some scenes of a film, etc.

Never say die! (Idioms and phrases in newspapers)

Learn more with +Plus

• Recent and Recommended {{#preferredDictionaries}} {{name}} {{/preferredDictionaries}}
• Definitions Clear explanations of natural written and spoken English English Learner’s Dictionary Essential British English Essential American English
• Grammar and thesaurus Usage explanations of natural written and spoken English Grammar Thesaurus
• Pronunciation British and American pronunciations with audio English Pronunciation
• English–Chinese (Simplified) Chinese (Simplified)–English
• English–Chinese (Traditional) Chinese (Traditional)–English
• English–Dutch Dutch–English
• English–French French–English
• English–German German–English
• English–Indonesian Indonesian–English
• English–Italian Italian–English
• English–Japanese Japanese–English
• English–Norwegian Norwegian–English
• English–Polish Polish–English
• English–Portuguese Portuguese–English
• English–Spanish Spanish–English
• English–Swedish Swedish–English
• Dictionary +Plus Word Lists
• English    Noun
• Intermediate    Noun
• Business    Noun
• Translations
• All translations

To add rebuttal to a word list please sign up or log in.

Add rebuttal to one of your lists below, or create a new one.

{{message}}

Something went wrong.

There was a problem sending your report.

• Share full article

Advertisement

Supported by

Trump’s Attack on Harris’s Racial Identity

More from our inbox:.

• ‘White Dudes for Harris’
• Republican and Ivy

To the Editor:

Re “ At Journalists’ Meeting, Trump Questions Harris’s Race Identity ” (front page, Aug. 1):

In a blatant confirmation of the racism and bigotry that have been the hallmark of his political career, Donald Trump’s confrontational interview with the National Association of Black Journalists, in which he questioned the ethnicity and Black identity of Vice President Kamala Harris, was but the latest display of the shameless behavior that we’ve come to expect from this morally unfit candidate for president.

Mr. Trump’s combative and disrespectful appearance before an audience of Black journalists displayed the decades-old obsession with racial identity that helped catapult him into national prominence and that continues to define his appeal to the prejudices of some of his most loyal supporters.

Disparaging his opponents’ name, appearance, intelligence and gender has always been Mr. Trump’s signature weapon in his grievance-dominated political career. Injecting racism into the current campaign was thus totally predictable and will not deter or intimidate the vice president or the vast majority of Americans whose determination to defeat him at the polls can only strengthen.

Roger Hirschberg South Burlington, Vt.

Donald Trump’s appearance at the National Association of Black Journalists was a huge success — for him. In trademark fashion, he made outrageous comments not to persuade but to change the focus from the surging candidacy of Kamala Harris onto him. One look at the front pages of leading newspapers proved it worked. It worked when he questioned Barack Obama’s birth certificate, as it is working now with his questioning of Kamala Harris’s racial identity.

Covering a demagogue is difficult. It is difficult to know what outrages to report to elicit public rebuttal and which ones are so outrageous that they refute themselves. How extensive should the coverage be? Is it information voters need to know, or is the press being manipulated into changing the spotlight from his opponent to him and giving him free media coverage?

Here is one test: Do the demagogue’s comments tell us something about him we did not already know? The answer, in this case, is clearly no.

We are having trouble retrieving the article content.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and  log into  your Times account, or  subscribe  for all of The Times.

Thank you for your patience while we verify access.

Already a subscriber?  Log in .

Want all of The Times?  Subscribe .