I tested 5 AI resume builders to help get a job — here's what happened
Here’s how to apply for a job using AI
I long for the day when I’ll wake up in the morning and get my AI ready to go to work for me . Until that time comes, the least AI could do for me today is to help me land a job I like.
Not everyone is a fan of resume and cover letters, but they remain staples in many recruitment processes.
For years, employers have also been using forms of AI to filter through these documents in order to narrow down the pool of applications they receive for any given vacancy.
The latest advances in generative AI mean that right now employees can leverage AI tools at their disposal to empower themselves in the job-hunting process.
I wanted to see how powerful these tools are. To find out, I created a shortlist of AI resume and cover letter builders that I wanted to try. Tom’s Guide believes in fair fights, so I used each of them as though I was applying for the same job with the same profile.
A target was required and I found a LinkedIn ad for a real job as a remote Software Engineer with generative AI responsibilities at Meta (formerly Facebook ) that looked promising.
The role asked for a candidate with over two years of coding experience and over two years of building large-scale applications. More experience was required in designing and completing medium to large features without guidance. Meta was looking for a candidate with, or in the process of obtaining, a Bachelor's degree in Computer Science, Computer Engineering or equivalent practical experience. In exchange, the company was offering a salary between $116k and $168k per year.
Sign up now to get the best Black Friday deals!
Discover the hottest deals, best product picks and the latest tech news from our experts at Tom’s Guide.
I created a fictitious aspiring Meta software engineer, Tamsin Smith, in order to have some kind of profile I could submit to the AI. Smith holds two Stanford University degrees in computing science, completed an internship with Twitter and has been working at Google as a software engineer since 2019.
If that’s not enough for Mark Zuckerberg to give her an offer, she also leads a local scouting group in her free time.
With an actual job ad and an alter ego in hand, I was ready to start reviewing AI tools. Read on to find out which tools I used, what they produced and my thoughts on their performance.
My first attempt was with Rezi.ai since it offers a free basic service and I wanted to check if the way I designed the review could work in principle. And it did!
Right after confirming my email, I was creating Tamsin Smith’s first resume.
I was presented with a choice between a “Job-Tailored Resume” and a “General Purpose Resume”; I went with the first choice as it was exactly what this test was about. It asked me for the role and company I’m targeting but I was blindsided when Rezi asked me to insert a job application I’d written for the role. Isn’t this something the AI should be doing for me?
I finished this side quest and then added basic details like my name and email, followed by my previous work experience. Here’s when I first encountered signs of AI life in the form of a bullet point generator to further explain my role.
Rezi went on to ask me to add details on projects I’d worked on, my education history, certifications, coursework, involvement in other organizations, and my skills.
The next exciting step was the summary section, where I gladly let the AI take control. It was nothing I couldn’t have come up with myself if I simply wanted to summarize my resume, but it at least merits a pass mark. (I wanted to ask the AI to write a cover letter for me based on the finished resume but that feature requires a subscription.)
Overall Rezi marked the resume it produced at 87 out of 100, which I think is a bit too generous. If you have a rough idea of what you want your resume to look like, by all means, use Rezi so you don’t have to worry about the formatting. It might also provide a helpful AI-generated bullet point or two along the way.
If you were worried that not using Rezi’s AI was the one thing stopping you from getting your dream job, rest assured that (at least with its free version) this is not the case.
My score: 3/5
Resumaker.ai
“Designed templates that will get you hired at the world's leading companies,” Resumaker proudly displayed on its homepage. I also had to pay ($0.99) to download my resume and cover letter. Surely, I was on the verge of getting Tamsin hired?
By now I’d gotten the hang of inserting details like my education and work history. In this regard, little separates the resume builders tested here.
The AI kicked in to provide me with text I could insert as accomplishments in my jobs and as the headline summary. The latter left much to be desired but at least it was presentable. Resumaker didn’t offer to beef up my volunteering section so I had to write that part manually. As a whole, the resume felt a bit dry but at least it was presentable.
However, it’s a good thing this service isn’t called Coverlettermaker. Every sentence it generated started with either an “I am” or “I have”. When you’re working with such a structure, there’s only so much you can do to make the rest more exciting. Furthermore, it left the [Company Name] field for me to fill in. AI that’s supposed to help me land a job in a highly competitive market should come with higher standards.
Resumaker.ai claims that thousands of applications it created landed people jobs. If there’s any truth to that, then on the bright side we really shouldn’t be overthinking what we’re sending to hiring managers.
The main question I asked myself before deciding whether each AI builder deserved a pass mark was: Can I send out the résumé as is?
Teal didn’t quite make the cut here.
It asked me to connect the specific job I was applying for from LinkedIn to the resume and it started analyzing the job ad for keywords I should include. Fantastic! I was ready for a made-to-measure summary, past accomplishments, and cover letter — the areas where I wanted the AI to work its magic.
Unfortunately, this is where I felt let down. In the headline summary, Teal ended up giving me a compilation of the achievements it had previously generated but also prominently added that I had expertise in “work authorization”. The AI thought the right to work in the U.S. requirement from Meta’s job description was a hard skill.
It scored its own resume at 79%.
As far as its cover letter goes, I appreciated that I could generate it for free without having to spend time adding more details than I already had. However, the result was something I could have just as easily written myself.
My score: 2/5
Kickresume.com
The last AI resume maker I wanted to test was Kickresume, which had the highest monthly fee out of the lot at $19 per month. You can bring that down by paying an annual lump sum that brings the pricing down to $9 a month or, as I did, utilize the free trial version.
Right when I was losing hope in the resume generators, Kickresume lifted my spirits.
Its helpful AI writer was alongside me from start to finish, offering handy suggestions for work accomplishments, explaining my certifications, and also suggesting skills I should list specifically for a software engineering position. I ended up with a clean-looking CV and I didn’t even have to break a sweat.
Kickresume gave the resume it generated a score of 88/100.
If I’m in a pinch and need a new resume that I don’t have to scan for AI-generated sentences that would land me in the "rejected" pile, Kickresume.com is the first website I’ll be visiting.
I wanted to add a nice cherry to the cake, so I asked Kickresume to create a cover letter using the great resume it made. But this is where I was underwhelmed.
While devoid of grammatical errors, I felt as though the AI didn’t take the résumé and job description I gave into consideration. It provided me with a few short lines that didn’t even name-drop Tamsin’s fictitious stints at Twitter and Google. You wouldn’t even know she completed two degrees at Stanford. Based on my positive experience with the résumé, I couldn’t believe this was the same AI content generator.
My score: 4/5
No subscriptions. No plugins. I wanted to see how well the free version of OpenAI ’s ChatGPT would do against the four dedicated AI resume and cover letter generators listed above.
I tweaked a prompt that I found online and, in 161 words, I asked the AI for a first draft of my new resume. I then asked the chatbot to refine its work based on the job description I gave it to make my resume less generic. In seconds, I had my second draft.
Since ChatGPT only gave me a plain text version of my resume, I then pasted what it gave me into a template from one of the previous builders.
I’m happy to announce that both myself and Tamsin were very pleased with the results. The resume easily rivals the ones generated from the other services I tested. I wouldn’t have minded some text to beef up the education section to explain what I had learned at Stanford. Also, the line pointing out that Meta was previously called Facebook is something I would never have included in a resume intended for Meta’s eyes. Other than that, ChatGPT gave me decent results in the shortest amount of time.
I was especially impressed with the cover letter I asked ChatGPT to craft for me. It was perhaps a bit too long for some tastes but it was arguably the most well-rounded out of the five.
Honorary score: 4/5
The verdict
There have already been reports of people using AI to write resumes and cover letters who ended up getting hired for the positions they’ve applied for, and I’m not surprised. But as this test has shown, a website’s claim that it uses AI to provide a service is not some kind of guarantee of the level of service you can expect.
Shop around when looking for AI resume and cover letter writers. Perhaps combine two or more of them to leverage each one’s specific strengths. But add the finishing touches yourself.
More from Tom's Guide
- Google's new Gemini AI could beat ChatGPT — here's why
- Google’s plan to train its AI now includes the entire public internet
- 3 best AI synthetic video generators you can use today — tested and compared
Christoph Schwaiger is a journalist who mainly covers technology, science, and current affairs. His stories have appeared in Tom's Guide, New Scientist, Live Science, and other established publications. Always up for joining a good discussion, Christoph enjoys speaking at events or to other journalists and has appeared on LBC and Times Radio among other outlets. He believes in giving back to the community and has served on different consultative councils. He was also a National President for Junior Chamber International (JCI), a global organization founded in the USA. You can follow him on Twitter @cschwaigermt.
I tried to use Apple Intelligence's Image Playground to design a Thanksgiving menu — here's what I learned about the app in the process
Apple could be giving Siri a ChatGPT-like upgrade — here's what we know
Forget Steam Deck — Asus ROG Ally X is $100 off right now in killer Black Friday deal
Most Popular
- 2 MacBook Pro speaker repairs are about to get a whole lot cheaper
- 3 Hurry! Apple's stunning Apple Watch Ultra 2 in Black Titanium just hit lowest price ever for Black Friday
- 4 I drove an Acura ZDX Type S for a week — and it’s luxury like no other
- 5 This is the one Black Friday deal I'm buying after getting a Steam Deck OLED
Make a Mistake-Free Resume with Our Resume Fixer
A full list of all the mistakes our resume fixer has found in your resume
Make sure your resume is error-free and compelling with Enhancv’s AI Resume Fixer
Resume fixer is a free and quick tool that can help you fix mistakes easily, comprehensive grammar and spelling fixer, repetition fixer, buzzwords and cliche fixer, quantifiable impact fixer.
Enhance your resume with our comprehensive resume improvement toolset
Content analyzer.
Our resume fixer tool does more than just rectify spelling mistakes — it offers actionable guidance to improve your content. If you've overlooked the inclusion of measurable achievements, our tool will highlight these areas. With insights gathered from thousands of successful resumes, our fixer tool ensures your qualifications and skills are showcased optimally.
Referral Link
Sharing your resume with someone who can offer a fresh perspective is a step towards securing that job. Use the referral link to your resume and send it to someone who’s been employed at the same company, or even better, in the same department or position. Connect with ex-employees on LinkedIn or join relevant Facebook Groups. By asking their opinion on your resume, you can gain valuable insights and feedback.
In This Guide:
What are the most common resume mistakes that need to be corrected, is hiring a resume writer the only way to fix a resume.
- Poor Spelling and Grammar : This is perhaps the most common mistake, and one of the most detrimental. Poor spelling and grammar can give a employer the impression that you lack attention to detail or professionalism. Always proofread your resume before sending it out.
- Being Too Vague : Your resume needs to clearly show what you've achieved in your previous roles. Statements that are vague and don't contain specific results or actions can weaken your resume. Always try to quantify your achievements.
- Too Long or Too Short : Ideally, a resume should be one to two pages long. If it's too long, it might be seen as unfocused or filled with irrelevant information. If it's too short, it may appear that you don't have much experience or achievements.
- Using an Unprofessional Email Address : Your contact information should reflect your professional identity, and an unprofessional email address can undermine that.
- Not Tailoring the Resume for the Job : It's important to customize your resume for each job application , highlighting the skills and experience that are most relevant to the role you're applying for. A generic resume can come across as uninterested or unfocused.
- Including Irrelevant Information : Information that's not related to the job you're applying for can make your resume look unfocused. This includes irrelevant job experience, hobbies, or personal information.
- Lying or Exaggerating : While it can be tempting to inflate your achievements or skills, this can backfire badly if you're caught, and it's often easy for employers to verify this information. Always be truthful on your resume.
- Poor Formatting : A poorly formatted resume can be difficult to read and can give the impression of unprofessionalism. Make sure your resume is neat, well-organized, and uses consistent font and style.
- Using Clichés : Using cliché terms or phrases like "hardworking", "team player", or "detail-oriented" without supporting them with specific examples can make your resume seem generic.
- Not Including Keywords : Many companies use software to screen resumes, and these systems often look for specific keywords related to the job. Make sure your resume includes keywords that are relevant to the job description.
Remember, your resume is often the first impression a potential employer gets of you, so it's crucial to make it as polished and professional as possible.
No, hiring a professional resume writer is not the only way to fix a resume. While it can be helpful for some people, especially if you're struggling with the format, language, or selling your experience effectively, there are several other strategies you can employ to improve your resume:
- Self-Review : Spend time going through your resume meticulously. Look for errors in spelling, grammar, punctuation, and formatting. Make sure that your resume is accurate, clear, concise, and professional-looking.
- Tailoring : Always customize your resume for each job you apply for. Use the job description to identify what the employer is looking for, and tailor your resume to match those needs.
- Peer Review : Have someone else, such as a trusted friend or mentor, look over your resume. They may spot errors or areas for improvement that you may have missed.
- Enhancv’s Resources : There are numerous of free Enhancv resources online, including templates, guides, and advice from career experts, that can help you write and format a strong resume.
- Career Centers : If you're a student or recent graduate, your university's career center can provide guidance and feedback on your resume.
- Workshops and Seminars : Look for resume-writing workshops or seminars in your area. These can provide valuable tips and feedback, and some are free to attend.
- Professional Feedback : If you're in a professional organization or network, consider asking for feedback from peers or mentors in your field.
- Using Resume Builders: There are several online resume builders that provide structured templates and guidance to help you create a professional resume.
Remember, the goal of a resume is to present your skills, experience, and qualifications clearly and succinctly to potential employers. You don't necessarily need a professional writer to achieve this, although they can certainly help if you're struggling.
Additional tools
Enhancv Executive has changed my life: One week & four interviews later, I will be making 150% more doing the job I chose.
Your resume is an extension of yourself – make one that’s truly you.
- Create Resume
- Terms of Service
- Privacy Policy
- Cookie Preferences
- Resume Examples
- Resume Templates
- Resume Builder
- Resume Summary Generator
- Resume Formats
- Resume Checker
- AI Resume Review
- Resume Skills
- How to Write a Resume
- Modern Resume Templates
- Simple Resume Templates
- Cover Letter Builder
- Cover Letter Examples
- Cover Letter Generator
- Cover Letter Templates
- Cover Letter Formats
- How to Write a Cover Letter
- Resume Guides
- Cover Letter Guides
- Job Interview Guides
- Job Interview Questions
- Career Resources
- [email protected]
- English (UK)
- French (FR)
- German (DE)
- Spanish (ES)
- Swedish (SE)
Made with love by people who care.
© 2024 . All rights reserved.
COMMENTS
Create professional, industry-tailored Resumes. No writing experience needed. Create Resumes that get you hired. Tailored to your field. Powered by AI.
Are You Making These Common Resume Mistakes? Use Our Free, Automatic Resume Templates. Our Automatic Resume Templates Make You a Perfect Resume in Just a Few Clicks. Free & Easy
Recorded Resume Review: You'll receive a 10-minute video plus written notes from a resume expert who will look over your resume and provide actionable feedback for you to make edits on your own. Live Resume Review: You'll schedule a 20-minute video call with a resume expert. During this call, your coach will discuss your resume, provide expert feedback, and answer any questions you have ...
I appreciate all her help and recommend her to anyone in need of a perfect resume! ... Didi O. says, "My experience was great. She took her time on my resume. Gave me some insight on how and what can make my resume better." See more. $165. starting price. $165. starting price. View profile. 6. Impression by sam. 6. Impression by sam. Top Pro ...
Until that time comes, the least AI could do for me today is to help me land a job I like. Not everyone is a fan of resume and cover letters, but they remain staples in many recruitment processes.
American Job Centers are located in every state, and can assist you with resume writing, skills assessment, job search strategies, and more. Find an American Job Center near you. Your public library is also a great resource for resume and job search books; many offer free resume-writing and job search workshops. Locate your local public library.
Resume Help Improve your resume with help from expert guides. Create your resume now. CV. CV Builder Create a CV in 5 minutes. Get the job you want. CV Templates Find the perfect CV template. ... With Zety, you can make a resume for free, and download it in the format of your choice.
As the world's #1 job site 1, Indeed can help get your resume in front of a wide range of employers. Why choose Indeed for your job search. 32.5M Jobs listed on Indeed 23 Hires on Indeed every minute 3; 70,000 Average number of successful connections between employers and job seekers each day 4;
Enhancv's Resources: There are numerous of free Enhancv resources online, including templates, guides, and advice from career experts, that can help you write and format a strong resume. Career Centers : If you're a student or recent graduate, your university's career center can provide guidance and feedback on your resume.
Yes, you can customize your resume using our Resume Builder. You can easily adjust elements such as section order, line spacing and section spacing to achieve your desired layout. Our Resume Builder also provides industry-specific content suggestions from professional resume analysts that you can edit or include as is.
Resume Help. Professional Resume Summary Examples. Your professional resume summary quickly shows employers you have the experience needed to do the job. Learn how to write one with our examples and tips. Conrad Benz. July 25, 2024. ... Can you help me build a cover letter?
Find resume tips and advice for various industries, career levels, formats and situations from Monster's experts. Get a free resume critique, review your resume's appearance and content, and learn how to avoid common resume mistakes.